HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | NackerHughes's commentslogin

Well, yes. With a bicycle you can ride pretty much anywhere. A bicycle restricted to roads is objectively worse.

Thunderbird breaks compatibility with plugins, again and again and again. To the point that most plugin developers have straight up given up on maintaining their plugins, because it’ll only be for Thunderbird to break everything once again.

Every time I do a system update and Thunderbird is in the list of packages, it’s a gamble on whether next time I open it half the plugins I depend on daily have been taken out back and shot.

It’s slow. Sometimes it takes up to three minutes just to open a single email (I timed it). And no, it’s not my mail provider. In the web app and in Claws mail it’s instant every time. Half of the time using Thunderbird is sitting there like a melon watching that stupid little blue bar throb away in the bottom right corner, waiting for something to happen in response to any of the clicks or key presses I did five or ten minutes ago.

And the redesigns. Oh, God, the endless, frivolous redesigns. Each one serving only to move stuff around so we can’t find it, waste more space with needless UI padding and fisher-price rounded edges, make the app actually slower and clunkier with its CPU-hogging animations and multi-layered composited fancy pants shadows (which don’t even work right with most compositors so you get another “ghost shadow” a few pixels round the edge), reshuffle all the UI components so nothing’s where you remember it being for the last however many years… did I already mention that? I guess I’m just too “entitled” (actual real words of a Mozilla rep) to have to re-learn a UI every few months because some designers and marketing idiots are bored and need job security. It’s not like I have anything better to do than gawk at your border-radius-tactic CSS animations. Certainly not anything to the scale of, say, a full-time fucking job that largely consists of reading and responding to emails, something Thunderbird is by this point actively hindering me from doing. And they harp on and on about how “beautiful” it is, as if they’re trying to convince themselves they haven’t wasted everyone’s money.

The last time I opened Thunderbird (and thank God it really was The LAST time) it opened with a full page splash screen - yes, a pop-up ad - asking me to donate! Why? So you can piss about breaking more plugins and shitting up the UI once more? Not a fucking penny until they bring back the proper pre-68 branch. Too late for me, I’ve migrated to Claws Mail and am all the happier for it. Fuck Thunderbird.


That's such a viciously poor-faith strawman that one has to wonder if you're trolling. In case you're not, you're probably beyond saving if you genuinely believe something like this, but I'll bite anyway.

When people say "maximizing shareholder value" they are obviously not referring to people who have worked their entire lives to save up some money to live on in their elderly years, so they're not thrown out onto the streets after their decades of service.

Not whatever 'ackchyually' technically correct definition you're referring to by 'shareholder', equating these humans with those who just want more money for the sake of more money, and who will stop at nothing to devise plots to extract it from the rest of us, enshittifying anything they need to in the process and making the world a worse place for the rest of us.


Great, the thing that caused so many massive new problems for us all is now being sold to us as the solution to the problems it itself created.


This was written by AI.


Starting in 2027, a silent update, nonconsensually pushed by Google, will block every Android app whose developer hasn't registered with Google, signed their contract, paid up, and handed over government ID.

Every app and every device, worldwide, with no opt-out.

This includes apps shared between friends, distributed through F-Droid, built by hobbyists for personal use.

Independent developers, church and community groups, and hobbyists alike will all be frozen out of being able to develop and distribute their software.

Registration requires:

- Paying a fee to Google - Agreeing to Google's Terms and Conditions - Surrendering your government-issued identification - Providing evidence of your private signing key - Listing all current and all future application identifiers

If a developer does not comply, their apps get silently blocked on every Android device worldwide.


I understand why you didn't mention it, but there is an opt-out: you enable developer mode and wait 24 hours.

As it runs through Google Play Services, it's pretty likely they'll boil the frog and make it even harder in the future. Moving to an open platform is a good idea.


I seem to recall some apps refusing to run if developer mode is enabled. A workaround that means I can no longer use the apps I use every day isn't much of a workaround.


Once enabled, it stays enabled even after developer mode is turned back off. It's also associated to the Google account (if any) so later device purchase don't have to wait the 24 hours period


You can likely disable developer mode after installing the app.

I’m not sure if you would have to re-enable it every time to sideload updates or new apps. You can also install via adb with no waiting period.


> You can also install via adb with no waiting period

Is this confirmed? If so, that largely removes my issue with the 24 hour waiting period for enabling/disabling dev mode.


Yes, this has been widely reported everywhere except for this scaremongering page. Google isn't trying to hamstring developers, they don't want your grandma installing apps that scrape her bank account credentials.

https://android-developers.googleblog.com/2026/03/android-de...


Adb also requires developer mode.

And my work doesn't permit it even with byod, it's so annoying.


Correct, some of the banking apps I use don't work unless I turn off Developer Mode It's actually annoying to have to turn on and off every time


The app my government pushes on everyone does not work with Developer Mode either.


This keeps getting missed out every time it's reported. I can't figure out whether people genuinely don't know, or they're trying to push a narrative that this is worse than it is


Because it's a workaround on Googles control. Next year it will be a week, then a month, then never again.


It's under google's control because it's a Play Protect feature. It doesn't exist on non Play Protect devices


But I have Google Play Services disabled, since I couldn't uninstall it.


And then you find your banking app no longer works...


Because this entire movement has gone from being a noble cause to instead spreading FUD.

The amount of misinformation to scare people is alarming.


As I understand it, you yourself will also need a google account to unlock the setting to "sideload" in the hidden "developer options" before waiting 24 hours.

What I am not sure is what will happen if I then remove the "google account" which I don't want in my device.


A wait of 24hrs is not an opt out, it is a demonstration of absolute control.


IIRC it is a cooldown to prevent less tech-savvy individuals from being tricked into installing malicious apps.

I don't think Google is doing this out of some egotistical obsession over "control," it's more that developers and FOSS enthusiasts are a vanishingly small fraction of their customer base.

There are plenty of problems with walled gardens, but IMO this isn't one of them.


> I don't think Google is doing this out of some egotistical obsession over "control," it's more that developers and FOSS enthusiasts are a vanishingly small fraction of their customer base.

It's also that that fraction is one they don't get any income from. We don't use Google accounts, Google apps or services etc.

So they don't get to track us as much except the few things you can't turn off in play services. Not everyone can work with custom rom (on those the new restriction obviously doesn't apply at all)


As I understand they're being pressured into it by governments like the Brazilian government to prevent a widespread form of scam there, but of course they're happy to comply because it means they have more control as well

We'd all be safest in a cage but no one wants to live like that


The worst problem with walled gardens is when everything is walled. Android is not supposed to be an "ecosystem", it is a damn OS on compatible hardware.


> It's more that developers and FOSS enthusiasts are a vanishingly small fraction of their customer base.

Maybe it's because direct installs are too hard to do already? Fortnite tried to go to that route and failed, if Fortnite couldn't make it who can?

And let's be real, I'm not going to accept any talk of "security" from Google when I type "chatgpt" in the search bar of the play store and I have an app with a counterfeit logo coming up at the top spot.


Or might it be when a cron job runs?


Why do I need a remote cron job to install an app on my phone?


The stated intention is to discourage scams. Bur this is exactly the same way Xiaomi makes their devices "unlockable" and in reality they just turned off their unlock server years ago and the button doesn't do anything, so you can't unlock.


Thanks for the comment Mr AI outrage farming bot!


Thanks green account created just for this comment calling someone else an outrage farmer!


[flagged]

Yes but it's not correct to say the apps are being blocked either. There is still a way to install them. You can also use adb directly.


Those things are not remotely comparable


It's like how saying the best way to avoid STDs is to not have sex, like the best way to avoid ski injuries is to not go skiing. Even though they're not remotely comparable (sex and skiing), the comparison holds in that neither offers practical advice to avoid the injury.


it's maybe histronic, but definitely drives home their point


> Calling that an opt-out is so rich, like calling suicide an opt-out method. 24 hour waiting period to do something on a device I own.

What?

You only have to change that setting once, and you can do it in advance (before the restriction takes effect). So you don't even have to wait 24 hours at all.

I can see this change having negative effects on the android ecosystem, but the direct impact on your freedom to install apps on your device is basically zero. If that's not the case, please tell me what I've missed.


you don't think they're going to yank that option away in, say, a year? or make it even more onerous, like "you have to send us a letter saying you want to develop apps"


Not quite. When the update is pushed, there will be an initial 24 hour waiting period to unlock your device. And then you can install unsigned APKs from hobbyist devs or Fdroid as before


What happens to existing APKs and FDroid apps?


Can be installed as usual after the 24 hour wait, or via ADB without the wait


Will it block existing apps already installed on the phone?


I haven't paid any fee to Google. Where does it say that you have to? Only Apple requires me to pay a (yearly) fee.


I believe that author is talking about a fee of 25$ you must pay to google when publishing your app in their ecosystem.


Not to mention, one of the most important things, the absolute best app out there for controlling insulin pumps for diabetics is an open source app you have to "sideload." I'm not usually one to make hyperbolic accusations, but in this case Google attempting to kill sideloading could put real people's lives in danger, or substantially damage their quality of life.


Is it safe to assume that GrapheneOS will not be affected by this?


GrapheneOS or other similar OS won’t be the issue.

The issue will be your bank, your gov, your uni, and school not releasing a compatible app for you.

And nowadays a device that cannot communicate or be trusted by other actors of the network (internet) is pretty much useless.

I hope those entities will wake up and start serving equivalents functionalities via the open web.

That is why we have the good old WWW for.


I already have to tell everyone I don't have a smartphone because stuff doesn't work so we'll on graphene and I don't want to explain.


the network (~~internet~~ Business interests)

Can you imagine of those "de-banking" people actually existed and could read?


> That is why we have the good old WWW for.

We can use AI to take back the entire tech stack.

Every moat, every walled garden, every infrastructure piece can be rebuilt with AI.

We're seeing it with desktop apps, with games. It will happen to infrastructure and platforms. I'm itching at the opportunity to build open cloud primitives and P2P social protocols.

We don't need big tech anymore. We just need to be able to run our models.


Great for local stuff but won't help for remote services like banks when they rely on hardware attestation unfortunately.


I want to see every *aaS’s functionality required to be offered -on reasonable and non-discriminatory terms- as an API

Who is Ford to tell me I can’t have a widget for each of my ford EVs visible at the same time? Or even that the single-car widget thry do allow has has to be four times bigger than I want it to be, and waste screen real estate on dead space and things that I don’t want?


Not at all. The app that is enforcing the change is a privileged Google app. Even if someone tried installing it on GrapheneOS, it wouldn't be able to do anything like remove apps, block installation, or disable apps.


And my experience has been that it's frequently harder to sidestep Google's bullshit on GrapheneOS because you don't have as much control of your phone, in the interest of security.

Honestly at this point, I'm just gonna start transitioning to Ubuntu Touch. The Android experiment has run its course.


What you're saying doesn't make any sense. I literally just said that GrapheneOS isn't affected.

The narrative that GrapheneOS is so focused on security that it affects usability, especially given the context, is nonsense. The change that's being discussed here doesn't affect GrapheneOS or other non-GMS operating systems. The only affected OSes are the ones that install Google apps with privileged permissions.

If you want to switch to something else, go ahead. GrapheneOS is still a better overall choice.


Yes, because GrapheneOS completely controls app installation and google play services is just an optional module.


[flagged]

In general I take your point, but in an attempt to steelman OP:

Perhaps they're using "surrender" in its meaning of "hand over something you didn't want to hand over", "give up under duress"?


So they're a piece of shit because you've decided that surrendering necessarily means losing physical possession

I agree with the wording, having to give your ID to Google when we'd all much rather that they don't have it is a surrender, it's dubious consent (read: not consent) it's precisely as vile and forceful as the word surrender implies it is


you're drawing a line between "showing" vs "surrendering" by physical possession. Well, there's a big difference between showing an ID at a bank and providing a copy to Google which they keep forever.


the business world is moving to be an authority. It's perfectly valid unless you stick to the idea that government some how is regulating businesses.


So you hand over your passport at hotels, but here it is.. unacceptable?


I, at least, also consider it unacceptable at hotels... But that battle already seems lost.

Please don't use one loss of privacy to justify more.

Something, something, slippery slope.


Good, this will get rid of scammers, poorly written apps, and ten a penny vibe coded apps. They should have done it a while ago.


At best it gets rid of some scams, certainly not most of them or poorly written apps, which continue to flood the Google PlayStore.

Despite Google's best efforts to automatically ban malicious developers, catching many legitimate developers in the crossfire, their store isn't exactly a bastion of quality or scam-free.


> Despite Google's best efforts to automatically ban malicious developers, catching many legitimate developers in the crossfire, their store isn't exactly a bastion of quality or scam-free.

I honestly doubt their "best efforts".

Fact of life is they make money off apps including malicious ones. For the same reason a lot of promoted content on Google search is clickbait and they even serve malicious apps. Money corrupts.


Removing freedom, and control will never get rid of scammers. Nor will it get rid of the plethora of poorly written corporate owned apps that will still be allowed to fester. It won't even get rid of the apps that scammers use to scam.


Because the Play Store has none of those?


and installing AI-monitored CCTV that calls the cops when it thinks you're up to no good in every room of every dwelling would reduce the number of murders and rapes by at least half.

I'm sure you will not object when that happens. you are not a murderer or rapist, are you?


I wouldn't, as long as humans aren't viewing it, think of the murders/abuse prevented, it could even monitor your behaviour and be like a pre-cog so if it thinks you sound weird or creepy it sends a robot round to question/arrest you.


and reduce domestic violence and child abuse by even more. Funny no one thinks of the children when it comes to an idea like that.


I can’t stand this sort of hyperbole.

Obviously this does not affect “every device worldwide”. I don’t have a single Android phone, and the devices I own that do run Android are not affected.


Clearly from context they meant every android device not every device.


It didn't 'take down a sizable chunk of the Internet'. Site owners took down their sites because of FUD and mass hysteria.


It's not getting tripped by "mass hysteria" to be careful and go offline for a couple hours.

Your average site is fine at 99.9% uptime.


We do need to eventually see the proof that this was so urgent. Because if it wasn't then this was effectively a massive DOS attack on society.

"9.2" is a big claim and a powerful justification for action, but with OpenAI involved my faith is very low that this isn't largely a publicity stunt. Especially given the age of the vulnerability.


This should be somewhat testable.

I'd set up a model with cyber capabilities, maybe GLM 5.3, not sure if it needs to be abliterated?

Disable web access and let it work on exploiting the pre-patch PHP version in a VM, given the info we had yesterday.

Can it do it? How long does it take, and writing the findings into a skill, how quickly can it be used on new targets?

I'd be interested in giving it a try, but unfortunately I'm very busy this week.


... meanwhile:

crickets


I think its absolutely getting tripped up by mass hysteria to go offline for a couple of hours without confirming the severity.


How are you supposed to confirm the severity of an unreleased CVE 9?


I think that you might have missed the joke.


It's risk assessment, nothing more. Some weighed the risk high and paused their site. Nothing wrong with that and not hysteria or FUD.


I think the article is suggesting that a sober risk assessment was not done by most folks period, not that they merely perceived the risk differently.


You've got under 5 minutes to decide whether or not a widely reported critical security vulnerability actively being exploited in the while is severe enough to warrant taking down your site or not. The downside for taking down your site is approximately 0, and the upside is that you don't get shrekd

No security expert can or should work that fast. Its a completely reasonable thing to do given the hyperbolic reporting just in case it turns out to be true. Some websites being down for a few hours doesn't end the world


> The downside for taking down your site is approximately 0

> Some websites being down for a few hours doesn't end the world

Many governmental websites are still down and they say might stay down for days or weeks. Some are not directly related to PHP, but auth doesn't work due to firewall hardening or similar. There definitely is a non-zero downside.


Agreed. This is all lazy chair hindsight talk, maybe by those not affected by it. In the moment you act on the imperfect information you have available and you use the safe than sorry rule. And to demand perfect information is also a fallacy, it doesn’t exist until after the fact.


I hear you, but also I'm not so sure. I remember Log4j, heartbleed, etc. and they were just as serious, but I don't recall people just going dark immediately. Scripts to validate whether or not you had exposure were built, people ran them, and if you did have exposure you started checking to see whether or not it was exploited. This timeline for this seems wildly different to me.


Because it’s not the same type. There was no actual info until the patch dropped, with some people in the know , which made it dangerous to leave your site up. The stopgaps were wild guesses. The multi-upload mitigation wouldn’t have worked.

There was no check that could be trusted to be the check to mitigate it. So that left the scenario that we went through.


Presumably the lack of sober risk assessment was on the part of the hyperbolic reporters.


There wasn't any info on the exploits beyond hearsay and the claim that they're very serious, so the risk assessment, sober or not, boils down to "do I trust the PHP people when they claim this is very serious"


Of of course, an excuse to email a user base to say "sorry we're offline for xyz", from a company I haven’t dealt with in 7 years...


The device I'm currently using has no headphone jack, no removable battery, no removable memory, no removable storage, a single solitary USB-A port and a locked-down BIOS that only lets you install Windows by default. All in the name of profit.

Yes, the device I'm currently using is worse than the equivalent model was 10 years ago. Thanks, capitalism.


Why did you buy it then? There are systems on the market still that have none of these issues.


No, labour creates the technology that people use.

The system just decides where the wealth goes.

Under capitalism, it doesn't go to the people who did the labour.


"Under capitalism, it doesn't go to the people who did the labour."

Automation is removing the human labour factor rapidly, so that no longer holds true. Karl Marx's writings never anticipated cybernetics, transhumanism and genetic engineering despite his followers believing he was some kind of infallible prophet.

The machines will build themselves, repair themselves and run themselves.


Even in the 19th century you didn't need to be a prophet to ponder what will happen when machinery finally becomes fully automated, and what the process of arriving to this state might look like.

Indeed this is the main question of Marx's work.


Marx doesn't anticipate cybernetics at all. He has no opinion on transhumanism, genetic modification, and as far as I know, not much on space exploration.

His ideas are built around an industrial working class, which may vanish completely as an economic unit within the next few decades. In previous eras, there was a need for the rulong class to have a market and a human workforce.


so wait after you remove the need for manual labor do you go dystopian capitalism where people have no jobs and grow poor, or you distribute "universal high income" and start doing communism with oligarch supreme leaders determining who gets what?


It is a major problem wherever one finds oneself in it. Billions of angry poor people with little to do are going to be even more of a problem to the elite than they are already. Most of the solutions are going to be extreme, and some are frightening.

UBI sounds great on paper, but you have to be in with whoever or whatever is doling it, and it hands them power over you.


A vector!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: