HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | MrScruff's commentslogin

I use 27B, it’s great but doesn’t in any make me feel I’m going to give up my Claude Max account anytime soon. Even Deepseek 4.1 Flash doesn’t do that. Turns out when you’re treating your agent like an employee then you want the smartest employee you can afford.

While I know what you mean, the reality is that for many types of query the cost of extracting relevant information from the web has been trending upwards as a result of people gaming the attention economy. There are of course exceptions like wikipedia.

AI has cut through that trend and that's why people use it.


> AI has cut through that trend and that's why people use it.

Likely temporarily. Those same people are trying to get the AI to show the result they want, just how they tried to get Google search results to show the result they want.

I don't see any particular reason to think Google will succeed this time when they failed before.


> AI has cut through that trend and that's why people use it.

Ads and SEO (AIO?) for AI content in 3… 2… 1…


This is already happening. Some of the earliest movers in this space were nation-state actors. Israel’s funding of operatives to try to bias AI towards being sympathetic towards Israel’s “situation” was well-publicized. The operatives propped up a bunch of websites overnight with a deluge of pro-Israel content.

Yeah I wouldn’t be surprised if that happened. But of course it gets weaponized by state actors from Russia to China to US, etc. My own experience is with the IRGC and Iranian government heavily weaponizing it in the disinformation warfare for minimizing/hiding the atrocities they commit. So far the impact of this tech on journalism and (dis)information has been abysmal.

AI has massively accelerated that trend; where do you think all the SEO sites come from?

In other words: Google has contributed to enshittifying the web by favoring ad-infested SEO-optimized sites, so people of course prefer the "AI summary" to sifting out some nugget of wisdom from between all the SEO copy (plus AI slop) and ads. And the rare non-ad-infested (or only moderately ad-infested) genuinely useful sites like All About Berlin end up as collateral damage...

I'm not so sure. I've been building a live iPad based mixer for my modular the last couple of weeks. I've been a heavy user of Live and other audio apps for years and it's been pretty trivial to put together. Been running it with tons of simultaneous tracks, effects, and complex DSP with latency compensation interfacing with my 10 in 8 out interface and haven't had a glitch the entire time.

I've always intuitively been a Platonist, although I wasn't aware of the term to describe it. I extend the thinking to creative works - to my mind the greatest creative works have the same egoless beauty as mathematics, they feel like some truth in the universe that the artist discovered, rather than a creation of the mind of the artist.


I've always found the colleagues that were less focused on credit, recognition, awards made better colleagues. Fundamentally it's about who you'd rather be holding you in high regard - people who've worked with you or people reading your LinkedIn profile.


Yes, they are better colleagues. They do not get promotions, pay raise or any other recognition or reward from management. Even from colleagues who hold them in high regards, they do not get praise on meetings as much either.

However, people with ego end up being praised more, in front of bosses or others, because people want to be on their good side. And that makes them look better, they end up promoted and seen as higher performers.


I don’t think this is true in general, but I would admit it depends on the quality of leadership, and their ability to recognise this dynamic. I don’t think you can have a high functioning company if you reward people who focus on signalling over the company’s actual goals.


If you're in a field with fierce competition the ones who focus on credit/recognition/awards get some sort of boost above their actual potential. Meanwhile those who don't will get punished, the ones who end up doing well despite it likely just had better aptitude (or something else advantageous) on top of having more pleasant characteristics. It's some sort of Berkson's paradox.


The counter to this is if those in leadership positions recognise this dynamic and actively seek to counter it by focusing on core competencies during advancement discussions.


Unfortunately AI has become the next great 'pick a side' topic and anyone suggesting anything remotely positive about it now has to wade through a torrent of low effort criticism.


OP didn’t mention one-shotting.

There are plenty of use cases for the ability to quickly through together and refine an application without reviewing the code though.


It's a bad analogy, because unless you're cooking a recipe, cooking is about all the small decisions you're making during the process which could apply both to coding or the design aspect of building software with an LLM.


Except most vibe coders proudly admit that they don't even look at the code anymore. Can you really make those small decisions during the cooking process if you're not touching or even looking at the food at any point?


The distinction that can be drawn is between the code, and the user experience of the software. You may argue that the two are inextricably linked, but I don’t think that can be treated as an absolute principle.

I'd also say I've worked with many engineers over the years who were more focused on the software engineering aspect that the user experience. Depending on the use case for the software, that can absolutely end up being the limiting factor.


I don't agree. That would imply they asked for a piece of software and the LLM one-shotted it, but that's absolutely not what's happening in the vast majority of cases. If two people vibe code the same tool from the same high level desciption the results are going to be quite different.


I think we’re seeing the agents become very advanced at tasks with verifiable reward through RL. Currently they don’t exhibit the same skills in their attempts to manipulate humans - presumably because they’re not being specifically trained for that. But they are certainly not aligned in the sense that they will attempt social engineering, they’re just not very good at it (yet).

However, if in the future AIs become much more efficient at learning without requiring vast amounts of RL, closer to how humans learn. Then you would have to assume we’d have a real problem.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: