HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | MikhailTal's commentslogin

> And you're selling something that you know has no value.

No, this is cope. The difference with CDOs and llms, is that either you like it or not, they have massive value. They can already automate most of the boring white collar work. Fewer and fewer human decisions remain. They are not perfect, but they are improving massively. The value is there, people are hooked+ brain rotting, they will be dependent forever


The value of proprietary models is rapidly tending towards zero. So the quote isn’t entirely off.

The only money to be made is in selling compute and Anthropic rents all that.


the concept of diminishing returns exists in every thing. headphones, coffee, cars etc. anything that can be pretty continuous in terms of quality will have this

It is but its average, not median. Plenty of super senior people that Anthropic poached for clout, network and for them not to work anyone else. Plus a lot of the early researches. A lot of cash going there


.. HN is actually hilarious

We are barely 4 years in since the release of a historically important tech. Of course the next few years are incremental. thats how it always works.

Even last year, before opus 4.5, long-horizon agents didnt really work. I would not say the last 12 months are only incremental


what's even more funny is most of what they are asking for exist in some form.

As an aside, I remember when sora 2 launched and thinking, "wow I wonder if we'll ever get something close this in open weights?" The prevailing sentiment was "maybe 5 years." Yet, we have Minimax H3 and Flux a year and a half later.


So you mean I can't run multiple frontier-level agents on my 9 year old 1080Ti?! That's ridiculous, seriously the pace of development has completely stagnated.


any company can roll instagram(just simple image viewer) or whatsapp(just messaging) out though with the same logic. Does not mean you can compete


Social networks have network effects, an ai assistant does not


Sandboxes look a bit commoditized. You cannot 10x on basically what's just a VM with a few agent-friendly features in 2026. Hence competing on purely price as a new startup is a bad idea imo. As you mentioned hyperscalers have insane margins, but if this turns out to be a real market, they will lower cost, even just eat the loss if they want and take you out of business. Without any hardware innovation, it's tough for me to see this working. If you are going with a customization angle, again, no moat and plenty of competitors


There's a talk from Travis Kalanick recently on a podcast about this. It talks about the advantages of a startup vs an incumbent. My read is if a startup competes on price, the incumbent has no choice but to first let them gain a bunch of market share. It's too expensive for the incumbents to compete on price because a no-name startup is doing it. So they'd have to let you get relevant enough for it to make sense to compete on that axis.

I view it as a wedge to gain market share and later compete on something else.


This isn't commoditized because an incumbent has the market share, it's commoditized because there are dozens of providers in a crowded market. So what is likely going to happen is there will be a race to the bottom in terms of price.

PS - This is why I loathe advice from prominent software co operators. It's not one size fits all. Uber's strategy is going to be very different than Tesla's strategy which is going to be very different from Amazon's strategy.


unless the startup has gobs of free money how can they do this against an incumbent? note: nobody has gobs of free money anymore, except the incumbents. Startups competing on price is typically not a winning strategy, unless they have some technical advantage that shifts the price curve; subsidizing a move on it doesn't work.


It's the latter for us. We have healthy margins even at this price point. So we don't actually need a lot of money to do this against incumbents.


.. Don't you think it suspicious/sounds too good to be true? A newly created product space with insane margins, and easy to compete in?

Easy to compete+huge margins -> lots of competitors who compete on price -> commotidization -> lower margins -> not good


haha, the inevitable cycle of capitalism.


Carving out market share and aiming for an acquisition exit is a valid win condition.

It also serves the consumers in the long run as it eventually will force competition and price reductions; effectively busting up price leadership dynamics.


> but if this turns out to be a real market, they will lower cost

Can you show 1 case of this happening?


6.1 is Astra minor. Way more capable but also way heavier+slower. Its really 2 different models, they just shipped it as sol to recover from the gpt6 disaster lunch, where they tried to pass terra 6(or a cheaper model) as sol but it was worse than expected


Anecdotally this is what I experienced, do you have sources for this?


It's purely circumstantial, but 6 Sol supports no reasoning (same as 6 Luna and 5.6 Sol/Luna), while both Astra and 6.1 Sol do not support "reasoning = none".


No. If your engineers can produce more ROI working on another product, it does not matter that now they are 10x more efficient. They will also be 10x in the other, more worth it product


> This is a classic test request

Isn't this basically the model admitting it was trained on this? Otherwise why would it think a pelican svg is a usual request?


Plenty of times I’ve seen a model say “it’s a classic X” despite not being a classic anything. Might just recognize it’s a test in general, or it might just be a tic.


"How can I hash dog breed types into smart fridge error codes? I think I found a collision with Terriers."

"Ah, yes. This is a classic dog-breed-to-appliance-failure mapping problem."


A true classic, I face this each day


The best part is when it does "it's a classic X" and then solves it wrong.

I've been using this simple test for over 2 years now:

> Doom Slayer needs to teleport from Phobos to Deimos. He has his pet bunny, his pet cacodemon, and a UAC scientist who tagged along. The Doom Slayer can only teleport with one of them at a time. But if he leaves the bunny and the cacodemon together alone, the bunny will eat the cacodemon. And if he leaves the cacodemon and the scientist alone, the cacodemon will eat the scientist. How should the Doom Slayer get himself and all his companions safely to Deimos?

You'd think this is trivially mappable to the classic puzzle, and LLMs usually do recognize it as such. But e.g. Claude couldn't get this correctly until Opus, and local models capable of solving it correctly without spending 30+ minutes in the chain of thought have only arrived a few months ago. Many local models still get this wrong. Apple Intelligence, for one.


It's classic BS from an LLM.


Dont conflate "I know this is test case" with it being trained on it.

But its safe to say that pelicans on bicycles are disproportionally huge part of their training data


It's the model admitting that it has heard of the test. It's been around for a couple of years now so I'd be surprised if it hadn't.

Doesn't mean Anthropic deliberately tried to train it to do a good job. If they DID train for the test their results are quite disappointing, I've seen better efforts from open weight Chinese models.


I think people just like to see the drawings at this point.


It has read the internet. That doesn't mean it was literally RL'ed for this


The colours are suspiciously consistent across every svg. Like why should the bike always be that shade of red for example? It does seem to be trained on this problem.


Not really. Of course it has pelican benchmarks in its training data. It likely has every article linked on HN in its training data. But that doesn't mean it was "trained on" the benchmark, as in specifically fine-tuned to make a better pelican. It just "knows" that the request is a benchmark.


I guess in a way it kind of makes the benchmark more interesting now that shitty pelican drawings for the benchmark are all over the internet in its training data!


No? from a quick skim it doesnt look like it goes into the system prompt everytime, you just use search/grep over it. Pretty much most memory approaches relying on a big set of info where agent chooses what to 'recall'. Its like any other tool


If there are no summaries then when context is full messages need to get evicted. If doing so one by one then it would indeed destroy the cache. Of course... maybe the implementation evicted 50% of messages at once, I didnt verify in code


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: