I really don't understand why most people here act like this is some weird unproven and unsafe technology. This is literally a solved problem. They are everywhere in Germany and it's no issue.
The inverters follow the grid AC and shut off their output if they are disconnected or unplugged, so the plug is never "hot". The power they input into your home wiring/the power grid is limited to 800 Watts as to not overload any installation. And the power meters know not to run backwards if you happen to feed power into the grid. Most can even meter how much power you fed in total (you're not going to get paid for it, though)
If you want, you can add battery storage that follows the same rules but lets you save excess power during the day to feed into your home at night or during demand spikes (washing machine, ...).
The setups are dirt cheap (often 200 - 300 EUR for an inverter and 800 - 1000 W(peak) of solar panels) and pay for themselves in about 1-3 years in saved electricity costs.
EEE here. I've not looked at these in detail myself as they are illegal in my country. Off the top of my head, the big problem I see is that, since you are injecting power BEHIND the circuit breaker an end-user can overload a circuit.
i.e You have a circuit with max current 16A; clever end-user plugs in 3 x 800W panels into different sockets BUT they are unfortunately on the same circuit; now 26A can be potentially drawn through a single cable IN THE WALL without tripping the breaker. This is a BIG fire hazard.
And you can't wave this away with instructions. It has to be 100% impossible for an end-user to do this.
That's why in Germany you are limited to at most 800 W for you house with plug-in solar.
Of course your argument still stands, but we're talking about at most 3.5 A extra current, not 10 A. Home installations seem to be adequately sized to be able to handle that load. At least I'm not aware of any reported incidents, and people have been putting them up for quite a few years already. And typically, German regulations err on the side of caution.
But sure, with 110 V, you will have more problems with the extra current for the same power, so in the American grid there could be further precautions necessary.
You cannot rely on that limit though. People WILL plug in more than that. The whole system has to be kept inherently safe. All other concerns are solvable, but I don't see how you solve this, bar having a special balcony-solar-socket installed where an electrician has verified that it will be safe in all scenarios.
I would contest it's without incident. The US is higher risk since it uses 120V => the currents are x2 higher and US electrical safety standards are an eclectic mess of: world leading and 3rd world.
Not picking on the US though. These panels in their current incarnation, are lowering the level of safety of electrical everywhere.
This is all just my opinion though. A lot of my background is in compliance. I've been frustrated by some obvious electrical safety advancements that are STILL not being implemented. I also have first hand experience with many many signed off electrical systems which were death traps. This all biases me heavily towards not compromising on electrical safety. But maybe I am overreacting.
Americans are, for the most part, fucking morons. We invented the infamous warning labels like DO NOT EAT THE TONER CARTRIDGE or DO NOT HOLD THE CHAINSAW BY THE BLADE or REMOVE CHILD BEFORE FOLDING STROLLER or PEANUTS: CONTAINS NUTS
We're also very litigious, as it isn't hard to convince a jury to award damages to a fellow moron.
Italy has the "Do not store your cat under the seat" warning. They do NOT put it on Italian-market scooters and they definitely DO put them on US-market scooters.
Everybody in the world is a moron. Americans just recognize some places where we are morons and try to prevent stupid people (which includes me and you!) from doing some stupid things.
Not everything, Americans do get by with doing other moronic things that other countries do things to prevent. However other countries also do their own moronic things that Americans are much less likely to.
It would in practice be (mostly) fine, just as it is elsewhere. But electrical safety principles in the US are typically "must be safe regardless of the dumbest possible use" so that "mostly" is a big obstacle.
I sincerely get your concern. Clearly explain on the box what NOT to do and be explicit about the risk. Use an icon of a house on fire. Done. Life is risk, and regulating and banning things based on the lowest common denominator of human judgement is a fool's errand. Should we ban vehicles as well since about 40k people die from vehicle related fatalities annually?
In my view it's more that: electrical safety has advanced to it's current "version" and allowing these panels is a regression in safety. There's already plenty of products/theoretical-products that are banned and/or tightly controlled for electrical safety sakes (suicide cable is the poster child).
To use your car analogy, we're not banning vehicles. We're disable one of the airbags when enabling fuel economy mode.
Final edit: "61% of respondents support having one device per household circuit while 19% considered that
only a single plug-in solar device should be permitted per premises citing alignment with
44
Engineering Recommendations G98 Issue 2 Amendment 1, impact on the network, old wiring in
properties and the ability of consumers to correctly identify separate electrical circuits.
Government response: Having considered consultation responses and stakeholder feedback,
the government's approach is to limit the deployment to one per power circuit, subject to
corresponding changes to the G98. Some respondents suggested limiting the total capacity per
dwelling to 800VA, but we think the evidence for doing this is weak considering most UK
dwellings have a minimum of two power circuits"
-- i.e. they thought about it and the concerns got outvoted.
It's probably fine. There's a lot worse lurking in outdated UK installations. Then we get on to ring circuits, which the rest of the world disagrees with and also seem to be fine.
Wait, people in the UK actually follow those instructions?
In the US, even with a warning, you'd get regular home fires as people hooked one of these panels into every available outlet just because they can. I wish I were joking.
I hope it's at least "probably fine". I've seen some pretty shoddy electrical work in my lifetime (including new installs) and am now of the mind that the deep-defense-in-depth of electrical safety we have these days is to also "cope" with shitty electrician work.
Wouldn't all three being plugged in be likely to trip the breaker, because it's just AC and the breaker can't really tell whether energy is flowing "forwards" or "backwards"?
Seems like the worst case scenario is when you mix solar panels with load on the same circuit.
800W at 110v is about 7 amps. Suppose you have a 7 amp solar inverter plugged in as the first thing on that circuit. Further down the line, you have 22 amps worth of load. The circuit breaker sees 15 amps, but the wiring between the panel and the load is carrying 22 amps, which would ordinarily trip the breaker but it doesn't because the solar setup is masking it.
I'm not an electrician. Perhaps wiring code has enough safety margin that being 800 watts over on some circuit isn't actually a serious safety concern, but I could understand why this might not be allowed.
The EU is on 230v, so maybe it's a bit more practical over there because you can add twice the solar capacity for the same amount of additional current you'd have in the US, so they aren't eating into the safety margin quite as much. Though it seems they also use thinner wire gauge generally, so maybe the difference is moot.
Yup. Worst case scenario is indeed mixing generation and load on the same circuit. And you have to assume that some number of people will manage to do that and create a fire hazard. To connect it safely, you need to know the circuit layouts and the rating of the cables. This is not something solvable with a safety sticker and safety instructions. A huge amount of effort has gone into making domestic electrical installs as inherently safe as possible and these panels are a back door to that.
Don't get me wrong, I think they're a spectacular idea, especially for renters. But you'd need an electrician to check the circuit and maybe even have a special balcony-solar-plug to prevent people plugging in too many panels in the wrong locations.
Quick edit: Random idea. I guess if the panel could communicate with the RCBO it's connected to and that RCBO can dynamically alter it's trip current could also solve it. But again, that's an electrician call and new thing installed.
I’d also guess bad inverter hardware could cause lots of dirty/noisy AC power effects and damage other equipment on the system. This definitely doesn’t sound like a very safe approach without a lot of conditions being met and exactly like your example there are too many ways it can go wrong.
You might be thinking about it as you might a DC circuit or a battery with electron shuffling one-way down the wire.
But it’s AC, the electrons are shuffling in both directions at 50/60hz
Voltage goes forwards and backwards and odd but current also goes forwards and backwards, for both appliances and generators.
The difference between consumer and producer is only the phase angle between the voltage and current waveform.
Because power is VxA, do that across the wave cycle and the power direction changes for consumers and producers.
At every junction, Kirchhoff’s current law will sum the currents so you get a “net current” waveform on a wire that might have both a kettle and a plug in solar panel.
That summation means the kettle will chomp as much current as the panel can deliver and than take more from the grid. Swap the kettle for a small LED which takes a fraction of the current and the sum gives a NET supply, and on to the next junction.
Maybe a useful mental model is a trampoline? The grid is like a jumping elephant or something (I don't know if they jump, we'll say they do for the sake of the analogy), and you could have people also jumping on the trampoline. If they're a bit late, the elephant launches them in the air, and if they're a bit early the elephant sucks the energy out of their jump, but that energy makes the elephant jump higher. And a fully distributed grid would be one where there is no elephant, just a million people jumping on a trampoline.
I think at this scale that it's cleaner to think of the grid as a flywheel system of enormous (~infinite) mass. Every consumer (home, factory, business, whatever) and every producer (home solar, nuke plant, wind machine, whatever) is connected to this flywheel system, and they're all in parallel (just like circuits in a home are).
Take power out of the flywheel? Sure, why not -- that's exactly what we've done with it at home since we had an AC grid to speak of.
Try to impart higher voltage to put power back into the system? Fine, no worries. Flywheel just accepts and absorbs whatever you put into it as long as it has the right shape.
Try to change the flywheel's AC frequency or waveform, though? Hah, fat chance: Flywheel will trip your breakers or reduce your gear to ash -- whichever comes first. We play by the flywheel's rules, and those rules aren't optional at all. It may be just a big dumb flywheel, but the flywheel's enforcement is absolute.
Anyway, it's a big mythical flywheel. We get charged money to take power out of it, and (with the right arrangements) we get paid money to put power into it.
And by design, grid-tied inverters are quite good at following the flywheel's rules. They match the flywheel's waveform very well [lest they go poof]. They can only put power into that flywheel, and they reject power from that flywheel. The inverter is a one-way thing that, from a high-enough viewpoint, looks kind of like a check valve or a diode does.
---
But it's not an ideal, perfect system. It does not exist in a world of frictionless pulleys and ropes that don't stretch.
That imperfection shows up in the wires and transformers connecting the house to that flywheel system, in that these parts have a non-zero impedance. (For the sake of this discussion, impedance can mean about the same thing as resistance)
And that impedance is useful. It means that we can increase voltage a very tiny bit on our local leg, and thereby succeed at using our puny little solar power system to help cover our own local base load.
Suppose our plug-in solar widget can produce 800 Watts today. The plug-in kit increases the voltage that it drives that plug with until 800 Watts of power output is achieved (which is only a very tiny amount of extra voltage, but it's real anyway). This is its purpose: Where some robots pass butter, this robot puts 800 Watts into a power socket.
Since the wiring between the plug-in solar and the local household baseload stuff has a lower impedance than the path to the mythical flywheel does, our baseload stuff (the fridge, the router, the fan by the window) gets first dibs at that 800 Watts of minutely-enhanced voltage.
If we produce more than we use, the excess local power production gets provided to and soaked up by the flywheel (maybe we get paid for that).
If we use more than we produce, then the deficit is made up for by the flywheel (and we definitely pay for it).
If our generation and consumption is perfectly balanced (which never really happens), then the flywheel plays no real part in the program except to provide a waveform for our solar inverter to synchronize with.
---
Anyway, it's not new tech at all. It's safe in that it won't work at all without a connection to the big flywheel in the sky. And folks have been using grid-tied inverters for quite a long time, but that was done on a dedicated circuit (with a dedicated breaker or fuse or RCBO or whatever they're called wherever you are).
But there's still some new stuff going on: It can be a plug-in system that works without individual planning or permitting; in some places, a person can legally buy and use a kit without obtaining extra permission.
The safety of sharing a circuit is also important, since enhanced potential exists for overheating things. Germany limits their plug-in solar to 800 Watts, or about 3.5A @ 230V, while their circuits are usually 16A.
That means there could be as much as 19.5A of nominal current flow within a circuit before some combination of circuit breaker or inverter limit is reached.
I learned a long time ago to never question a German about their electrical standards, though, so I can only assume that very smart people have worked very long hours to see that this situation is safe-enough.
It’s not even really an issue with DC either, like a lot of people’s battery systems have multiple DC loads and multiple sources (e.g. DC MPPT solar controllers) going to a busbar connected directly to the battery.
Current load pulls the voltage down, sourcing current pushes it up. No bother, as long as your sources cut out if the voltage goes too high, and your loads cut out if it goes too low.
Maybe the issue is in the terminology? In the UK, we don't call it an "outlet", we call it a "plug socket", or just "socket"; it's a socket that takes a plug, no direction is implied.
In terms of electricity and physics, this is unremarkable, the bit that probably scares people is the fact that you have a plug connected to something that's _outputting_ AC, particularly for those of us with 240V supplies.
If it were any old AC source on the other end they'd be correct, but current technology allows the output to be cut in milliseconds, faster than the period of a single AC wave, once the plug is removed.
Tangentially; if you have solar (mine's roof-mounted) don't assume that flipping the breaker means there's no power; I live in a 1930s UK home with all sorts of interesting wiring and flipped the breaker to change a plug socket, only to be shocked; literally and figuratively when it was hot.
No, I think it's that we've been repeatedly told of the dangers of plugging a generator into a socket of the house and the problems that will occur if the power comes back on if it's still running.
When we had our solar installed, we had to make sure we had a newer power meter that could handle power both ways, so it probably is a problem for some situations, but the power flow for a single solar panel into a plug isn't enough to trip this, or maybe newer power meters are better?
We definitely think of it as somewhere a power comes out of, but I don't think it's the name, just that it's only ever been that way.
Clearly some people think of it differently if they're plugging generators into wall sockets to power the whole house, dumb as that may be.
There seems to be several levels of compatibility, at least here in the UK, based on age.
My home is 1930s, it's fuse, in the black Bakelite housing typical of the era was insufficient and we were missing a incoming breaker to/from grid, those were updated. Our meter is much more recent, though still dated; allegedly it would have worked but it wasn't a smart meter, which we wanted so we had that updated.
I've also heard through my many hours of watching Solar videos on YT before our install that some breakers, RCDs(?), RCBOs(?), whichever it is, aren't always suitable for bidirectional current flow, so that's a possible issue too.
All of that is aside the "suicide cord" danger of the old generator method, but that's gone now with modern tech, the output is cut before you can get your hands on the contacts on the end of a plug.
It's just been legalised here in the UK, and I think it will help people with their bills, but the key is to keep installation costs down; if it's DIY you can look at a decent ROI time, but with the cost of trades-people these days, if you have to call out a sparky to inspect before you plug it in, you've added potentially years to your payback period.
At ~800W, I think on the whole we'll be fine; the equipment in our homes has got much more efficient over the years, and our homes were mostly built for times where we were using higher powered devices. If you can draw over a kW to power an electric heater or kettle, I don't see why feeding a mere 800W back in would be a huge risk.
Disclaimer: I'm not an Electrician, but I do have a degree in Electronic Engineering.
You can backload via generator plugged in. Nothing physically stopping it. You just would need to shut off the primary breaker so you don't load the line outside of your house.
The solar is the same way, but with an auto cutoff.
> When we had our solar installed, we had to make sure we had a newer power meter that could handle power both ways, so it probably is a problem for some situations, but the power flow for a single solar panel into a plug isn't enough to trip this, or maybe newer power meters are better?
This has very little to do with the power meter itself, and more that the power company wants to be able to monitor if the meter is 'running backwards' (i.e., if power is flowing out rather than into the meter). Older meters could only run in one direction.
> Clearly some people think of it differently if they're plugging generators into wall sockets to power the whole house, dumb as that may be.
There's frankly nothing wrong with this if you do it properly. The 'proper' way would be to have a generator input socket near the main breaker panel, and the main breaker is interlocked with the generator input (i.e., only one can be on at a time). You absolutely can just plug a regular generator into a wall, assuming you aren't overloading the wiring or breakers... the safety issue is overblown. The reason why it's 'super dangerous and bad stuff will happen' is because people are stupid and forget to turn off the main breaker. Which, admittedly, is a reasonable concern because... people do forget.
> No, I think it's that we've been repeatedly told of the dangers of plugging a generator into a socket of the house and the problems that will occur if the power comes back on if it's still running.
Yes, but that's dangerous for reasons[1] that people often don't bother explaining -- and that aren't important for solar grid-tied inverters[2].
[1]: The seemingly-ideal way to plug a big fat generator into an American house in a hurry is to use a double-ended suicide cord to feed into the 240v dryer outlet. That provides plenty of power to get a lot of things done, it's a single-outlet circuit, and it lights up both sides of the split phase panel. But that's bad.
The most obvious way that it's bad is because we shouldn't have energized male prongs. Like, ever -- that's just extra shit to get hurt with. But this suicide cord idea relies upon their use.
The other way that it's bad is that the generator doesn't know whether the house is still connected to the grid or not. So unless we deliberately disconnect from the grid, there's a wonderful chance that we feed it even though that grid is presently non-functional. This can fuck people up: The transformer on the pole outside (or in the box down the way, or whatever) will cheerfully convert the sleepy 240v from the generator into thousands of volts on the wires outside that were completely dead until someone decided to get clever. Now, the guy cleaning up storm debris down the block or the lineman doing the repair gets the fuck shocked out of them in spooky-dead kinds of ways. (Yeah, yeah: We shouldn't ever do anything near downed lines of any kind, and the lineman should always have appropriate PPE. And we shouldn't plug our generators into our dryer socket, too. Death is permanent.)
Panels with interlocks and wall-mounted male sockets that accept generator input both exist, and the combination of them mitigates both issues. The combination also prevents a third problem: Power coming back on while the generator is running.
[2]: But a proper UL-listed plug-in solar inverter doesn't have any of these problems. The issues are sidestepped because it outputs nothing when the grid is down, as a baked-in function. So there's no energized male plug to be a hazard, and there's also no interlock required to ensure that the grid isn't backfed while it is down. You can hypothetically unplug the solar inverter from the wall on a bright sunny day and lick the prongs, and nothing happens.
Essentially this is simply what solar panels have done for ages, feed back electricity to the grid, sure it's not through a power outlet but essentially it connects to the grid in a similar way.
What's new is cheap and ubiquitous micro-inverters. Before it wasn't worth putting a $800 inverter on a small 2-panel 600 or 800 installation. Now with micro inverters being so cheap, this tech becomes viable. And with loads so limited (less than a microwave) the regulation is equally light to allow this convenient plug-in solution.
What’s the issue? Electrons flow both ways… Just have to synchronise the AC signals of the inverter to the grid, have good limits on frequency and voltage fluctuation, and monitor for faults properly.
This is also how generators work, so it's not new at all, though with a generator you need to disconnect from grid power so you don't electrocute lineworkers. The solar backfeed devices don't work when the power goes out to avoid this (called anti-islanding).
Electrically, this is no different to a regular rooftop solar system. All inverters connect to your household wires like any other device, except that it’s normally on its own circuit and breaker.
Is it not almost similar to IPS? the device is charging through the power outlet, whenever the power is out, it's inverting and feeding power to the home. This exists for over 20+ years iirc? It works, and haven't heard of any incidents.
For panels and inverters, there's really too many to count, but mostly names that one is not typically familiar with. For integrated solutions, familiar names might for example be Anker Solix or Tepto, which offer battery storage with integrated AC inverters. I'm running an Anker Solix Solarbank 2 E1600, which is not really the latest model but rather cheap and runs nicely.
If you want to get an overview of the ecosystem, googling "Balkonkraftwerk" gives you the most relevant results.
You can get Google AI Pro through verizon fios or mobile in the US and pay only 10/mo. For 5TB cloud storage, and decent gemini usage its a compelling option
The inverters follow the grid AC and shut off their output if they are disconnected or unplugged, so the plug is never "hot". The power they input into your home wiring/the power grid is limited to 800 Watts as to not overload any installation. And the power meters know not to run backwards if you happen to feed power into the grid. Most can even meter how much power you fed in total (you're not going to get paid for it, though)
If you want, you can add battery storage that follows the same rules but lets you save excess power during the day to feed into your home at night or during demand spikes (washing machine, ...).
The setups are dirt cheap (often 200 - 300 EUR for an inverter and 800 - 1000 W(peak) of solar panels) and pay for themselves in about 1-3 years in saved electricity costs.