HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Matticus_Rex's commentslogin

> you're basically saying "it's not theft, because now it's mine"

No, that's not at all what they're saying. Taking something is only theft if it's rightfully owned in the first place. He's saying it wasn't rightfully owned.


I mean, in a legal sense, no -- it's not theft of the proceeds. You may mean that you think it's morally/philosophically similar to that, in the same sense as piracy and other IP violation, but these things are very specifically not classified as theft from a legal standpoint.

Violating the intentions and purposes of the creators is in some cases an IP violation, and in others it isn't -- it all depends on the details. A lot of AI training on IP-protected materials can fit into the bucket that isn't an IP violation (or any other legal violation), though much of the historical actual training data wasn't collected this way.

IP creators don't have an amorphous right to "a return" or to have their intentions and purposes strictly respected. They have very specific rights in law, and those often don't match up 1:1 with expectations, and almost never with a specific set of the creator's intent (except where that aligns with already-existing law).


They aren't making a legal claim, "What they did was technically legal" is almost never a compelling argument in favor of behavior, and the fact that people can't expect legal protections from this behavior is exactly why they're taking matters into their own hands, leading to the information protectionism that started this comment thread.

It analyzes in segments, and the percentage is of the segments, not of the words.

Yes but the segment sizes are huge and any amount of LLm generated sequences within that block cause all of it to be flagged as AI.

That's the state of the tech right now. It'll be nice if we can get it and keep it more granular than that, but even at the current state it's pretty impressive.

I think my issue is more about how the tool communicates it's result than with the tool itself. The people I speak with don't understand that this is a binary "YES/NO" for many of the passages they are testing.

No, not until January


after many rounds of frivolous law suits if I'm reading the tea leaves correctly


The lawsuits won't stop people from taking office.


The newly elected Congress critters can't take office until they are sworn in by they speaker. As we've already seen from the pettiness of the current Squeaker of the House Mike Johnson, he has already used skullduggery to delay the swearing in of new members. I'm sure claiming that a seat's validity being questioned by ongoing litigation would be cause to delay that person being sworn in.

Over the years I've seen way way too many off-by-one errors when people reflect on who was "in charge" at the time.


Check your idleCompaction line in /config to make sure it's off -- several times they've toggled new features on by default for me. This one isn't in the VS Code extension so I don't know if it shipped default-on.


Legislation you can generally access for free. Case law you often cannot.


Should that change? In my opinion, in the age of AI, both should be generally accessible for free.


Yes, it should absolutely change (both should be freely available), since ignorance of the law is not a defense, and case law is law (here, in the US, since we're a common law country). But the flip side of that is that the law has to be knowable, if ignorance is not a defense, or you're just going "lol too bad for you for not knowing the secret law".

Also, because how the judicial branch decides case law needs to be reviewable by the People, so that we can inform the various legislatures to adjust the law if the judicial system is not ruling to the will of the People.


Even without AI it should be. Honestly the less AI has to do with giving people access to our laws and court records the better since the value of having that access would decline with hallucinated laws/interpretations/attribution. A post about how AI isn't even fit to write wikipedia articles just fell off the front page a few hours ago, and providing something like this to the public seems at least as important.


Electrical & building codes are also paywalled, IIRC.


Its outrageous.

Thing which are public law should be publicly accessible.

There's an online portal for NEC code book, but they made it awful, no search, no hyper links, the bare minimum.

I used codex in computer mode to collect the relevant pages to my project. (Electricity to shed).


There are benefits to specialization, and will be for a long time even with AI. It's worth a premium to not limit all my software to what I and my agents know, and to be able to rely on other people to fix it if there's a problem.

Investment size for software plays is going to drop, and people will still invest for the same reason they do now: solving problems for people is valuable. Marginal costs dropping will bring down a lot of costs in various places, but the software itself is only part of what SaaS provides.


> I think everyone has known that inference is profitable overall for the major providers for a while

A lot of AI haters like Ed Zitron and their readers have refused to update on this. I don't know if any of them have yet, but it'll take a year or two for the idea to fully filter out of their podcasts anyway.


Seems a bit of a disingenuous framing. Most of the arguments I see are some mix of

1. Their figures have been pretty dodgy or excluded training costs so why is it trustworthy this time?

2. API inference charged at a profitable level rather than heavily subsidised subscriptions means everyone tightens up their usage + governance Which we very much saw with the rise of openrouter et al.

Personally I think there's a lot of the bait and switch of 2 when people talk about profitability of the 10-20% of API usage for Anthropic while also wanting to lump in subsidised chat users as if they're profitable too.

I think we know if it was this clear cut then the behaviours of companies would be wildly different and more consistent with profitability.


There are thoughtful versions of these arguments, sure. There are also thoughtless versions, and it's not disingenuous to note it.

It's not actually clear that subscription users are unprofitable as a group (and the group level is the only important one).

We do know the companies are not currently profitable, because they're open and intentional about that, but that tells us nothing about their margins without infrastructure buildout and investment in training.


This is a stream of disingenuity.

> It's not actually clear that subscription users are unprofitable as a group (and the group level is the only important one).

[Open AI losing money on subscription users](https://fortune.com/2025/01/07/sam-altman-openai-chatgpt-pro...)

If anthropic were making money on subscriptions they wouldn’t be pushing people onto API + enterprise packages.

> We do know the companies are not currently profitable, because they're open and intentional about that

Why do they keep engaging in stunts like excluding infra costs then?

You are picking choosing to ignore evidence and actions when it suits you and then saying “oh we can’t possibly know” when we do absolutely know the problems of capital and debt raising on infrastructure problems (which are mostly not the Big Frontier labs either) there’s hard arithmetic for what’s needed to make these projects profitable and right now all the inputs are getting more expensive between chips and capital.


Ed Zitron is a professional apocalypse predictor. Which is to say he's always wrong.


It's certainly an overstep, but just the hash they're sending wouldn't be PII.


The hash itself is irrelevant.

The question is what PII does HIBP collect on submission (eg IP address), and with whose consent, and for which purposes?

All that should be explained in excruciating detail in the ticket and in the documentation, to begin with.


They were coined in the extremely influential foundational research the "pop science book" was based on, but that doesn't make it a marketing ploy; System 1 is very fast non-verbal subconscious heuristic operation, and a lot of our brain's classification takes place at that stage. Anyone familiar with the usage immediately had clear ideas about how it'd ideally be used (e.g. heuristics that reduce search space, manage context elements dynamically, etc) vs not (e.g. as a 1:1 replacement for something that could already be easily solved with a classifier).


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: