HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Lumich's commentslogin

Not the reason for this post, but while we're here I have to side with quotemstr, whose comments I've been subscribed to for a while because of their quality. There was, in my view, nothing personal about his comment, at least nothing to take issue with.

But I guess it has to do with that strange and hypocrite ideology that makes some people abuse grammar and employ plural personal pronouns when they fully well know that (a) the guy is singular and (b) the probability of him being female is almost zero as the climate on HN is toxic for women. (Maybe it's a way of pretending it isn't?)

Anyway.

So, my "karma" reached a new high-score, and it means that once again, all my comments are stillborn, dead by default, killed by software (obviously, no artificial or other intelligence involved in any way, not even simple text analysis).

How did this come about? Well, it's the work of bigots. They abuse the "flag" feature, which is meant to stop spam and trolls, to suppress comments, opinions and even facts they dislike or disagree with. I haven't counted, but I'd guess that close to two dozens of my comments have been flagged to death. Not a single comment was spam or trolling. Not a single one.

Even my very long and thoughtful post about my doubts concerning T-rex and, by extension, the science of dinosaurs was flagged (50089549). Why? What's wrong with these people?

While bigots may only account for a small percentage of HN users, they are effectively handed over censorship privileges to limit HN discussions to their narrow-minded vision of the world.

They're not religious bigots, of course. Instead, they're ideological bigots, or even scientific bigots (in as much as science has displaced religion as ideology for the educated classes).

It would be easy to change the effect bigots have on the site and the discussions that can be had here. For example, it seems users can look at other users' "karma", which is seen as a kind of "merit". Well, abusive "flagging" could be punished by negatively affecting "karma". Plus, next to "karma", some "flagging" stat could be displayed so "flaggers" would be seen as such.

HN has been around for a long time, and people with a mindset similar to mine must have shown up now and then and made the same observations and maybe complained about it in some way. I have seen some such comments and complaints. To no avail, apparently. So I have to conclude that the de facto censorship the minority of bigots are allowed to exercise on HN is fully intentional.

Then of course it is not a site for minority views, and not even for curiosity. It's not a site purely for bigotry either, of course, but, sadly, bigotry seems to play a more important role than curiosity.


« This was then translated to desktop apps at the same time desktop screen real estate became a non-issue for everyone »

Exactly. I remember opening a Metro/TIFKAM app for the first time on my new Windows 8 connected to my new 27" QHD monitor, and then staring in bewilderment as it went fullscreen and 95 % of the screen was just monochrome with nothing on it at all.

Wtf were they thinking? That I would enjoy vanilla sauce on my roastbeef because they weren't serving strawberries yet?

Still puzzling to me how such a multi-billion $ company can fuck up so hard.


« 70 million years ago, when dinosaurs still lived »

Do we know that for sure? Let's zoom in on Gideon Mantell and Richard Owen, who helped invent dinosaurs in 19th century England, preceding Research Casting International by roughly 150 years. This curious concoction should be read by taking into account all three sibling comments, dead or alive (50083123 etc).


The fact that 70 million years ago dinosaurs still lived, e.g. in the lands where the house of my grandparents was located (close to some places with Cretaceous fossil finds), is a fact that is known with a far greater certainty than e.g. the fact that your neighbor is not a serial killer.

Compared to the 19th century, now there is a huge amount of accumulated data about the history of the Earth, which is internally consistent and consistent with any scientific experiments that we are doing in the present.

While we know only a small part of what happened millions of years ago, many of the things that we know are much more certain than what we know about things that happen in the present, but which are hidden from us, so we do not have enough information about them.

From time to time some suppositions about the past have to be changed in the light of new evidence, but to falsify a thing supported by such a huge amount of diverse evidence, like the fact that 70 million years ago there were living dinosaurs, that would require an incredible amount of new evidence.

You do not have such evidence, so your comment is not useful. You could comment that anything you hear in this world should be doubted, including the past existence of dinosaurs, which is very true, but that does not mean that everything is equally doubtful. Some things have a great uncertainty, while other things have an overwhelming probability to be true.

Governments frequently make great efforts to alter the presentation of the human history in ways that are beneficial for them, e.g. to convince their people that they were the good guys in a war, while the opponents were the bad guys, so there are serious reasons to doubt the official histories supported in many countries, but what happened more than a few thousand years ago has too little political importance, so there are no conspiracies to alter the conclusions of paleontology. At most, some bad researchers may try to publish false data, if that can be useful for their careers, but that is usually discovered sooner or later, and it can never influence facts so fundamental like the existence of dinosaurs.


« At most, some bad researchers may try to publish false data, if that can be useful for their careers, but that is usually discovered sooner or later, and it can never influence facts so fundamental like the existence of dinosaurs. »

I asked Chatty for the best book on the history of the discovery (or invention) of the dinosaurs in the first half of the 19th century†, and it came up with The Dawn of Dinosaurs by John R. Horner, published in 2005. The title struck me as odd (I would have preferred Dawn of the Dinosaurs), and it appears the book doesn't exist, Chatty had made it up.

But that turned my attention to Jack Horner, a very important figure in paleontology (at least in the USA), who has discovered various T-rex skeletons and dinosaur eggs and whatnot, and so I watched a couple minutes of a lecture he gave in 2001, which left a peculiar impression (I mean his personality), and then I read his Wiki page and was not disappointed to find my impressions totally confirmed by the article …

https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Horner_(paleontologist)

Can't fault him for liking young girls, that's human nature, and he had the money to be a customer of Jeffrey Epstein; but isn't it curious how he didn't allow dyslexia from stopping him to rise to the top of the field? And what does it say about a field (at least in the USA) if such characters somehow manage to rise to the top? Could it be there is a (well-funded) system that facilitates their ascent? Because they have just what it takes to fulfil the role?

That, of course, should not reflect negatively on whatever paleo findings were made on the lands of your grandparents.

† Chatty next suggested The Dinosaur Hunters by Deborah Cadbury (Terrible Lizard for the US edition), which I found on AA and which seems to do a proper dive into history as is essential to find the truth of the matter.


Thank you for the reply, which I didn't expect; and sorry for the wording of my parent comment, the intent of which was only to check whether mere mention of Gideon Mantell and Richard Owen in connection with dinosaurs would be enough to trigger the HN comment kill software (which HN moderator dang referred to in a reply to me).

I agree with you with regard to governments and human history. As for natural history, I concede that at first glance, there is no reason to assume anyone would want to alter it, and doubts like mine seem absurd. And doubts they are – while I'm leaning towards the heretical view in as far as dinosaurs are concerned, I have not yet reached any kind of "personal certainty" in this matter. Which makes the topic all the more interesting to me.

The initial motivation that one may assume for "coming up with the dinosaurs" does not necessarily have to be of a political nature. It could have been as innocent as a hoax invented for fun, or as a form of intellectual art, or as a theoretical monument – science fiction, if you will, or science as a form of art. Later on, when the artefact had entered the edifice of science proper and become part of a serious scientific consensus, a certain if moderate political quality would have been gained in as much as Science (as a whole) had displaced Faith as the ruling ideology for the educated class, and consequently as an important pillar of power.

On the other hand, rather than having sophisticated creative jokesters at the origin of the story, such as would gather in places like the Royal Society (the English being known for their humour), we could have a simple misinterpretation as the foundations of the dinosaur edifice, without any ill or peculiar intent at all.

But I'm leaning more to the jokester scenario. These 19th century natural historians were collecting and assembling lots of bones into skeletons, and to the creative mind it must have been both tempting and the obvious thing to make up some new "extinct animals" from whatever bones are available. It would have been a lot of fun, you just need a bit of phantasy and maybe some "missing links". And think about the possibilities once you get hold of whale skeletons (cf. your comment 47374816) … and it turns out the golden age of whaling coincided with the invention of the dinosaurs.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_whaling

Pascal said, « le cœur a ses raisons que la raison ne connaît pas », and the same applies to other traits of the human mind that don't fit the narrow rationalistic model that we think underpins our current-day science and its ancestors of the last couple centuries.

Are dinosaurs a "fundamental" fact? True, they precede later lifeforms, but nothing depends directly on their existence; and while they have been woven into the evolutionary graph, that framework itself, by admission of its own postulates, consists mostly of "missing data", which means that relationships of descent between species are fraught with uncertainty.

You're invoking the concept of scientific consistency. In science, everything has to be consistent. I don't know whether it actually is. For example, it seems science says that during the cretaceous, sea surface temperature was ~35°C and we had rain forests covering both poles; whereas today, still according to science, we need to be scared because a certain atmospheric trace gas is on the rise, part of which due to human activity, and that will bring us beyond a so-called tipping point, from which there is no recovery (a ludicrous claim thoroughly disproven by Earth's history, still according to science).

So what we have here is an example of how everything isn't consistent in science when questions of, let's say: political expediency, arise; and also a case where scientific integrity seems tainted by such politics. (Because in the final analysis, horribile dictu, on average and in the vast majority, they won't bite the hand that feeds them.)

As you know so many things (which makes your comment stream an interesting read) you're probably also familiar with Ott Christoph Hilgenberg, a disciple of Alfred Wegener, who put forward the theory of a "growing globe" (Vom wachsenden Erdball). There is a lot of geological evidence for Earth actually having grown in the relatively recent geological past, but the idea has been discarded (and is now considered heretical) because it seems irreconcilable and inconsistent with other theories about how the cosmos formed and works, and current physics does not allow for a growth mechanism. Instead, we have plate tectonics, which postulates absurd motions like India ramming into Asia, having come all the way from SE Africa, crumpling up the Himalayas, and lots more of even more absurd continental motions as can be seen in the bumper car scenarios of the Wilson cycle, forming a series of unlikely supercontinents in order to accomodate the findings of natural history.

So we've seen sacrifice of consistency to politics, and here we have sacrifice of plausibility to consistency. My point is that in order for consistency to be a key criterion, we have to assume that everything is correct, because otherwise some mistake in some place may lead to more mistakes in other places – for consistency's sake. So how certain are we that everything is correct?

I do not have any new evidence. In fact, I have no evidence at all. I'm not even a scientist. I'm just wondering and thinking, for example whether the evidence for dinosaurs is sound, reliable, trustworthy, to be accepted.

Still, it seems a bit unfair to conclude that my comment is "not useful", at least if read together with the dead comments I gave the IDs for (the direct parent comment's wording was just the Mantell/Owen test, as explained above). Let's also observe there's no absolute definition of usefulness, as the concept presupposes the existence of a user and a purpose, and we may assume users and purposes are not all alike and uniform, but rather exist in various forms.

Also, I don't posit that everything should or could be doubted. In fact, I disagree with such a stance. Rather, I have specific points that I doubt. These curiously overlap (but are not congruent) with what features prominently in TV documentaries.

Now, to add a bit about dinosaurs, let's take the tyrannosaurids. You observed in 38592967 (3 years ago) that their heads are big and their arms are short. These features are highly conspicuous. I tried to think of other bipedal predators, whose existence couldn't be cast in doubt, but could think of none. Only the kangaroo came to mind, which is much lighter, whose head is much smaller, whose legs are stronger relatively speaking, and whose couching posture seems much more relaxed and at ease, so not at odds with gravity like the T-rex.

I asked AI for bipedal carnivorous animals, and it replied there are basically only birds. Now I know birds have come to be seen "by science" as descendants of the dinosaurs, but the differences are enormous (size, body part proportions, weight, configuration and development of arms and legs, beaks). But go figure, there are no other bipedal predators … other than us humans. Chatty called birds "the most widespread obligate bipedal reptiles" and "avian theropod dinosaurs" (literal quotes), but there has not yet arisen a "consensus" that this is "a fact", so I guess there is at least some common sense left among competent scientists.

To my thinking, the tyrannosaurus is in serious doubt by the very fact of its unlikely construction. It looks like a fraud. And in an investigation, if one element of a compound is fraudulent, then the entire compound must be put in doubt.

By the way, having read a book about dinosaurs in elementary school age, I never had doubts concerning their reality until four years ago. And sorry the comment got a bit long.


I posted a reply doubting the existence of dinosaurs (50073836). When I looked after about one hour, it was dead. Maybe it was killed immediately, like another similar one I had posted in August, possibly killed by a moderator (49312918).

Now I'm wondering whether HN uses some sort of language model to infer semantic similarity and thus kill content automatically. Frankly, whether this is automatic or by consensus of certain users, there's not much of a difference. It is dystopian, especially given the mountains of meaningless one-line comments that abound here (probably “too little substance to be worth killing”).

Once upon a time the Internet was the realm of free thought and free speech. I get it that spam etc needs to be fought and suppressed, but frankly, none of my comments that have been killed (quite a couple of them already) come close to that category. Rather, it seems the ruling HN mindset is about as narrow-minded (if not more so in certain respects) than your typical mainstream forum.


It's probably user flags. I flag trollish comments.


In this case I think it was automatic, due to the inclusion of a link to Canadian Research Casting International company's website, which I first posted in 49312918, which at one point was suddenly dead.

Don't know about you specifically, but people here clearly "flag" things they disagree with, which is part of why what could be an interesting discussion often ends up being a dull CJ style chorus between affirmative and know-it-all. As if there was no middle ground between that and a "flamewar".

I've read comments to the effect it would be easy to change to the better by administrative means, but apparently there's no will, so "smug-flagging" seems to be in line with the purpose of the site, and that's it.


« hypothesizing essentially Bronze age peoples did not have conscious thought, but attributed their thoughts to gods speaking to them »

The Mesoamerican advanced Stone Age peoples who had an ongoing encounter with the Spaniards certainly did have conscious thought, despite their gods. Why would Bronze Age peoples have been different in that respect?


Could you take a look at 50003450 ? It shows as dead after one hour. I cannot see whether this is because someone disliked and killed it, or whether "software" is out on a run again. We talked about this before (49841897).

At any rate, suppression of such comments is to be expected for CJ style groups but not for open-minded discussions.

Same applies to my dead comments 49953689, 49954141, as well as 49938615 and 49941900, on the subject of Hiroshima. If you cannot even quote top experts and administrators with first-hand knowledge (such as A. de Seversky and general C. Sams) just because they contradict the prevailing narrative, then what kind of discussion is that? And the flavour of "curiosity" involved must be very peculiar.

Frankly, my impression is that some people are using or abusing the "flag" feature and perhaps other features they may have at their disposal to remove opinions and facts they don't like or don't even want to see published.


The Nuremberg laws were calqued on US race laws. Can't go wrong by copying the US, can you.

Just as the moniker for the administrative status of occupied Poland, Generalgouvernement, was explicitly copied from British practice.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Governor-general


« to test whether an integer is null or non-null »

Shouldn't this more correctly read zero or non-zero ?


Null and zero are synonymous, but null is preferable when used as an adjective and zero is preferable when used as a noun.

There are 2 words for the same concept because "null" comes from Latin, while "zero" comes from Sanskrit through Arabic.

Etymologically, "null" means "not even one" (by being a diminutive form of "not one").

The use of "null" in some programming languages to mean things like "undefined", "not applicable" or "nothing" is incorrect. For those the right choice is NIL, as in LISP (NIL means nothing).

While LISP had made the right choice by using NIL, it made later the mistake of calling NULL the predicate that tests if something is NIL. That predicate should have been called something like "is_nil".

When C.A.R. Hoare had introduced the word "null", he applied "null" to references, i.e. to pointers, not to the things pointed by those pointers. So a "null" pointer, whose value is zero, points to NIL, i.e. to nothing, and this is an alternative to devising an encoding for the things that are pointed to, where a special value is reserved to encode NIL (like the Not-a-Number values of floating-point numbers).


I presume you didn't make all that up, but which authorities did you consult and under which circumstances would which audience immediately agree with you on all points?

In British English nil means zero as in a nil-nil draw in football. In this case it is effectively an ordinal number and it means none, not nothing.


In correct British English "nil" means "nothing", not zero, as can be checked in any decent English dictionary. See e.g. at https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=nil

> nil(n.) "nothing," 1833, from Latin nil,

In at least several other European languages a draw in football is correctly called "null-to-null".

If in UK it is now called "nil-nil" that must have originated in people with poor knowledge of English and then it was imitated by others.

Both "null" & "nil" come from Latin, where their meaning is "zero" and "nothing" (they are contracted forms of "ne ullum" and "ne hilum"). When first borrowed in English, they were used by educated people, who knew very well their original meanings.

Nowadays, most people have no knowledge about classic languages and poor knowledge about their own native language as it was spoken a few decades earlier, before the widespread influence all over the world of sources that display frequently incorrect language, e.g. TV shows, Hollywood movies, and now YouTube and the like, which leads to many cases when words are used in inappropriate ways. This is annoying because it results in ambiguous language, whose precise meaning cannot be understood without additional verbose explications of what is really intended and it also results in misunderstandings when people read the older literature.

In mathematical language, "null" has always been used correctly, for "zero", and this is the meaning that should have been inherited in any programming language, but unfortunately most popular programming languages are full of mathematical mistakes.

In non-mathematical English language, "null" has acquired additional meanings, e.g. in legal language it may be used for an invalid contract, sentence, law, etc.


  > auto m2 = m; // implicit too
  Taking a copy requires making an allocation.
C++ makes it “look nice” at the cost of clarity. But not consistently. Overall, despite addition of syntax sugar in various places to make things look smooth, we arguably have “a lot of syntax” (“syntax castles”) in C++, as a result of embracing a lot of complexity. C, OTOH, avoids both sugar and castles.


« Their source was a U.S. intelligence report. » — In other words, blowing smoke around some important government lies.

« lab leak theory » — Doesn't matter whether you adhere to the lab leak theory or the bat market theory. I'm sure there is a theory for some fringe group that points to “clear signs of extraterrestrian origin”, or “generated by AI”. Any crap will do. The only thing that matters in this business is that you believe there is some new-fangled and dangerous “CoVID” out there to get you.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: