I suspect a lot of this has to do with context (both geographically and culturally). E.g. There's a big difference between there's been a short term local collapse, e.g. after a natural disaster and civilisation will return to normal afterwards (so there's some incentive to behave because bad behaviour might get punished at some point) and the whole society has collapsed (it's going to be a free for all for long enough bad behaviour is unlikely to be punished).
Even if there's plenty of evidence that people will band together in times of crisis, despite what popular culture might tell us. See Lord of the Flies vs actual kids marooned on an island. In a hyperpolarised society with ready access to guns I suspect that would be different as the counterpunch article suggests.
I suspect the smart thing to do is hedge your bets and be prepared for both eventualities (be a villager AND an anti-pillager) as they'll no doubt be a bunch of people out there that are hungry and don't have the skills/temperament to be a villager.
At the risk of being controversial, isn't there also the choice not to implement autocomplete and then avoid the above conundrum, especially once you factor in the fact that they can't possibly catch all combinations of words/letters so a grey list isn't actually an effective solution either, other than it provides a we tried defense.
The ultimate problem being some subset of consumers want autocomplete and some subset will retain the right to be offended and some subset will be both of those?
EDIT: And at what point does accidently sending male chauvinist pig to your boss because of autocomplete absolve you of the responsibility of reading the message before you send it?
Is there any reason apple can't give us the choice of.
The biggest problem with it for me is it also affects swipe typing by tracing over the letters. There’s no way to implement that (and have it be even slightly usable) without some amount of predictive text.
If it didn’t auto complete then that would be fine when hitting keys individually, but when I’m swiping the words, it means no matter how accurate I am or how many attempts I make, it will literally never produce that word in that position.
And it’s contextual. Obviously I can swipe in “me,” but if it’s after the word “kill” then it’s banned, and I simply can’t dedicate the space in my head to learning this inscrutable list of banned phrases that until this article I’d been unable to find anywhere so I could only ever discover a phrase was on it by having an extremely frustrating time trying and failing to type it until I realized “oh, this is a politically or emotionally charged phrase (or could be in a different context) and I’m not that bad at typing so it’s probably banned.”
And some Zak Stein covers some interesting points in these, not least the increasing risk of kids becoming more emotionally attached to their friendly always on AI than their parents:
The one that tickled me, was Carrion Crows and Eurasian Magpies using anti-bird spikes as part of their nests, with the Magpies placing them on top possibly to deter other birds.
But here's one well researched viewpoint on that which suggests post-collapse will be a case of villagers vs pillagers.
https://www.counterpunch.org/2021/03/19/villagers-pillagers-...
I suspect a lot of this has to do with context (both geographically and culturally). E.g. There's a big difference between there's been a short term local collapse, e.g. after a natural disaster and civilisation will return to normal afterwards (so there's some incentive to behave because bad behaviour might get punished at some point) and the whole society has collapsed (it's going to be a free for all for long enough bad behaviour is unlikely to be punished).
Even if there's plenty of evidence that people will band together in times of crisis, despite what popular culture might tell us. See Lord of the Flies vs actual kids marooned on an island. In a hyperpolarised society with ready access to guns I suspect that would be different as the counterpunch article suggests.
I suspect the smart thing to do is hedge your bets and be prepared for both eventualities (be a villager AND an anti-pillager) as they'll no doubt be a bunch of people out there that are hungry and don't have the skills/temperament to be a villager.
reply