Yeah not sure where the C comes from; models lack access to knobs and switches of the system they're on and taking over the OS isn't control over the hardware still since it can't upgrade its RAM, or GPU
No it doesn't. It feels like that cause we're anxious wrecks here due to job insecurity, healthcare insecurity, and housing insecurity
We just lie to ourselves as being honest about all the time lost to stupid toil due to archaic leadership stuck in 1986 and inane screen use is just depressing so we make up a story to feel better
Agreed. I would apply this further; stop letting 1970s and 1980s pop culture fads consume our attention; let go of Star Wars and Marvel etc etc; previous centuries headlines
Let go of software dev; as is a mechanical task from the 60s-70s
Why? His incompleteness work explains why software and math suck so he would already expect them to; they're rhetorical and can never fully be a closed loop body of knowledge as we can never with rhetoric concretely observe/define the far future or far past; merely simulate rhetorically
Ergo all defined axiomatic systems have sentences about the far past and future that cannot be defined in those languages with certainty. Most do not make the connection to physics. Gödel did and would 100% aware the limits exist and will always exist
Scaling laws aren't just for computers; humans cultures do not scale infinitely through time, just approximately 2-3 generations
As I understand immutable physical truth like this played a huge role in his early research and ultimately were the forcing function that led him to incompleteness
"all defined axiomatic systems have sentences about the far past and future that cannot be defined in those languages with certainty."
This is often misunderstood or misstated to mean that there are some things that are unknowable or unable to be solved. (I'm not saying that's what you were implying, I am referring to the common way I see his theorem being represented)
But what he really proved is that no single sufficiently powerful, consistent, effectively specified formal system can prove every arithmetic truth.
He didn't prove that there are mathematical truths that are unsolvable through any possible extension or alternative framework. It's just that one framework isn't enough to solve all problems.
You're just restating Gödel verbatim without considering what that would entail physically; they're implicitly unsolvable as it would take forever to solve them all; the universe would experience heat death before they're all solved.
Scaling issues do not just matter when making bridges and when hosting LLMs.
Back in Gödel's day physicists were like rockstars and all Gödel's output was 100% influenced by Einstein and the rest. Given the group's expertise in the domain the implicitly forever incomplete/never computed did not need to be spelled out explicitly.
This part is already true without Gödel: combinatorics means there is mindbogglingly more that could be expressed in the universe than ever will be. The shocking aspect of incompleteness was how it made mathematics closer to physics (or perhaps, from some points of view, to philosophy), not what it implied about what was knowable in physics.
I think you're conflating abstraction like E=mc^2 and concrete ground truth of every moment ever everywhere in the observable/non-observable (observable has to come from
somewhere) universe.
Yeah we can and have formed general conclusions from what has been observed.
But Gödel was talking to the limits of usefulness of abstraction like E=mc^2 when it comes to determining past and future physical truth to a high precision.
E=mc^2 is, to conjure an absurd simile to invoke a reaction of how insane the effort would feel, like saying there's a rock on a hill.
Gives us nothing about the shape, color, mass... any sentences describing the concrete properties cannot be proven without observation.
Technically we cannot empirically know if E=mc^2 was true 700 billion years ago. Our trusted abstraction are only relatively true.
We did have 30 years of software advancement; LLM are the next step. I would argue what we didn't have was 30 years of hardware advancement as everyone bought x86_64
Blow and coders have a hammer so all they see is nails; it didn't "solve coding" AI solved "machine state management". Totally different; human tagging/coding will still exist just at the presentation layer cause we don't need a bunch of syntax like:
def sumAllCustomerAccounts() {
Some desired physical state of machine based on mathematical axioms
}
AI solved naming that function (the coding with human context part) with
f() { generate a function to add all customer balances}
We moving on from 1960s and 70s machine state management, pushing context coding to the presentation layer
Blow is just doing that thing humans do where they wrap their entire identity up in who they were 30 years ago and still think that's who they are today and will be tomorrow; rotary phone companies, bowling alley equipment manufacturers... new generations are superseding them... circle of life Simba
Not really gonna put Blow and Carmack on a pedestal; they never invented computers or software dev. They came along in the middle of the hype. The read the manual for old machines. We're just moving on to new kinds of machines.
People flipped out over the printing press too. Nothing to see here; it's just the upper bound of the middle age generation having a mid-life crisis
The HW advancement was much actually stronger than the sw advancement, very clearly so. It just happened behind the facade of the x86_64 and ARM64 ISAs so it was partially "invisible" to software developers.
Trump & most of Congress have no idea how the world works as they chose willful ignorance and fail up thanks to post-WW2 demand for American goods as the rest of the world was a crater
50+ year olds have done little more than take STEM research generated in the pre-1950s late 1800s era of science and copy the knowledge to computers; no net new physical science has come out of the last 50 years; it's all just carrying on nuclear, relativity, electromagnetism research conducted in the pre-1950s era; leadership is a bunch of know nothing American philosophers.
The very definition of functional illiterates who cannot reason outside their childhood cultural tropes; American domination and subjugation of the globe
They noodle tiny decimals of percents such the financial network effects make them richer.
That’s work to them. Zero meaningful contribution. They're TV personalities who offer nothing more to humanity.
Despite the obvious big picture trend all this science and tech existed even if in just rudimentary form when they were in Sunday school; they truly believe they're a divine people lucking into existence and responsible for human progress; 100ish million truly insane lead gas fume huffing, post war/cold war paranoid people control American economy and politics
But the M+P aspect def fits.
reply