HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | JimTheMan's commentslogin

The 'skin in the game' is I go to a competitor and use a different product.


The problem with point 2, is that person couldn't then work on other things. And there's a limited supply of people of that capability in the world.

We're now at stage where we can turn energy into thought to generate expertise on demand.


I think you are interpreting 2 as offering some large amount of money as a prize for discovering a solution. But I think it was meant more as funding a team of mathematicians to work on the problem.


Yes, that's what I meant, thanks for clarifying!

If you want to draw from history there are multiple successful examples of this in science and engineering at least: Bletchley Park, the Manhattan Project, Moon Landings.


Making the mRNA Covid Vaccinnes.It's truly incredible what the world can do, when it decides to focus on a singular goal.

I suppose the point I was making, was that the Engineers and Physicists and others, while working on the Manhattan project couldn't be doing other things.

And to develop those people takes years of education and training, and most people don't have the cognitive ability to do that kind of work. The pipeline to produce more of those workers, is skinny indeed.

Whereas now, we're limited by how many electrons we can put to work. The question then becomes, "Could our electricity be put to better use?"


Could you just get a separate agent to do a pass over existing code and make conform? Like super linting.

Not a professional programmer, so it's a genuine question rather than a statement.


Sure you can do that. But what’s the practical point if only your agent is reading it? Your agent doesn’t care about linting.


Presumably the agent isn't only reading, but changing the code to conform.


The worst part for me is, with a little effort, you can make a final product that doesn't use claude-isms and is 100% correct.

But the creator doesn't care because their goal isn't to make a tool people want to use. They make a minimum viable product, that looks super impressive but lacks that final polish and move on.

It infuriates me enough, that when I get the time I'm going to recreate the 'lighthouses of the world' example I saw the other day. Only I'm going to do it right...


> But the creator doesn't care because

I’ve always found it annoying when people make declarations like this. You can speak criticize a work without attacking someone’s personality.


A person's intent leads to the quality of a final product.

They should care if it actually has errors.

They should care if it has claude-isms.

But it certaintly seems like they don't care, at this point in time, about those things.

I'll take your feedback on board. But I'm not calling them stupid, or a bad person. I'm saying their goals are not aligned with my idea of a finished product.


or some people don't care about claudeisms as long as it is to the point and correct.


A person's intent can be the problem though, we can criticise that. We're not factory bots here (yet), the community aspect is human in nature not just output focused.


I was going to say, in Australia you would be able to claim that as a work expense against your income, reducing your tax owed.

But it looks like in the US, you would need to be self employed or own a business where it is an expense. Which is a bummer.


Reducing tax is nowhere near dollar for dollar, it would still be a huge cost. If the company wants it, they can pay.


> you would be able to claim that as a work expense against your income

only if it was necessary for the job, and the employer would've otherwise paid for it.

But if the employer originally paid for an LLM, but chose not to now, i am not sure that you personally paying for one is tax deductible (might have to argue it out with the tax office).


Imperfection isn’t evidence of ineffectiveness.

Considering this has gone unflagged for 11 years... Finding a flaw in Rust’s safety guarantees doesn’t mean that they provide no benefit, over a programming language without them.


I mean, have you worked with the Chinese? They're not like that at all.

They love money so much, you could swear they're American!


Everyone loves money but socially and culturally China is a lot more closed compared to US, much more so than what people are used to atleast.

US was arguably the most open country on the planet in terms of acceptance of ideas and cultural diversity especially in 20th century.

But I also don't think people need to be very worried but still we haven't had monocultures on the top or close to the top of power hierarchy for several decades so it's going to be uncomfortable for a lot of people.

For instance China is heavily censorious of LGBTQ and very likely against the Idea they haven't banned it outright yet thankfully. But then again lots of countries are in a similar boat.

But the biggest difference is China can easily back slide without possiblity of return on any metric because it's not a democracy.


China has a pretty vibrant LGBTQ scene, even Shenzhen was known as comrade city in the 90s. China is at the same time very closed and very open. It’s hard to describe.

I had lots of friends when I lived in Beijing who were gay, the gay bars weren’t underground and my gay coworkers weren’t in the closest, for L/girls it was even more out in the open (especially at the art schools). If you haven’t lived in China I guess you wouldn’t have a clue.


I went to China recently it felt different, the recent govt stance seem a lot more against the idea and the ones before which was my point, China in the 90s was a very different country from the China of today, then again I haven't been there then.

Again it's hard to say where it's open or where it's closed, they seem to be back sliding in very weird ways. I am not part of the LGBTQ community so I can't say for certain how bad it is, so I won't comment further but UN & human rights watch has been citing increasing censoring of LGBT representation and open-ness in China in recent times.

The biggest concern with China is lack of democratic freedom means as long as it's not bad enough to revolt the country can back slide pretty easily on many metrics with complete silence, no protests etc.

[1]: https://www.hrw.org/news/2026/06/25/china-social-media-films...


China is definitely not a democratic country, but nor is it a country where LGBtQ is repressed even if they don’t provide rights like gay marriage. It’s mostly chineee families you have to worry about, and even then the concern is more about having children, where even the straight young adults are uninterested these days.


I didn't mean to imply that if I did that was unintended, I meant to say it's something that's going in the wrong way directionally, starting with recent heavy censorship, and folks in China don't have to good way to speak out or change things.

Even countries with back sliding freedoms with good democratic structures have a fighting chance, China is just so weirdly removed from it that it's concerning when and if something does go wrong.


"Was" being the operative word there. It's been a long time since new (foreign) ideas were accepted, and the resistance to cultural change has been ever present.

American culture is capitalism, and that isn't changing, just getting more extreme. Equally American culture is "white European" and the resistance to change there (racially and culturally) is woven into US history.


You're describing pretty much any bug nation that has enormous economic wealth.


What does "bug" mean in this context? I apologize if this is an acronym or jargon I should know.

*Edit it's a typo. You meant big.


I'm in love with the cute little figure that came with the press release: https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2026/10/fig_fy_26_3x2.jpg

I appreciate the boldness of this project, it has an element of sci-fi to it. Building a base at the south pole to bury sensors in ice to measure elusive particles. The stuff of dreams!


The same guy (Johan Jarnestad) has been doing all the nobel prize illustrations and infographics for years!

https://www.infographics.se/

https://www.behance.net/JohanJarnestad


Looking at the behance site it's a pretty good choice, glad some illustrators are still making a living in the AI age.


To be fair, the base was already there and logistically essential. The IceCube topside building is just a part of the Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station, about a km or so from the Elevated Station.


This image* from Wikipedia surprised me. The topside building is...you could say...the tip of the iceberg. The detectors span a huge area going over 2km deep. The predecessor AMANDA array was also down there.

*https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IceCube_Neutrino_Observatory#/...


Yes. It spans a cubic kilometer.

The building is just for housing the data gathering and comms equipment and whatever maintenance and engineering stuff the array needs. I don’t think anybody physically works there regularly.


Umbrella corporation.


A trillion of these silly small guys pass through us every second. Funny to imagine them like that.


There are many things that my brain just can't handle, the size of the universe, more than 3 dimensions and this fact especially.


I will argue on your behalf that your brain can handle just one more dimension than the 3 you are likely referring to. :)


Most people are pretty bad at accounting for the effects of time.


Is this a Gödel Completeness thing?


If you ever feel lonely, think about all those little friends who come visit you!


We rarely bump into each other, actually. When we do it happens in a flash.


Depending on how much space you occupy, closer to 500 trillion per second


You can follow along with the researchers here https://icecube.wisc.edu/news/life-at-the-pole/2026/10/week-...


This is a very long winded way of saying, "I don't care how it happened, tell me what you are going to do about it."

There's something about the way this is drafted that irks me. It reads like AI, but not floridly so. Mostly, it's the optimistic assumptions layered throughout. That management care about reasonableness, that the reasons it actually doesn't want the details is because it 'trusts' you.

No, more likely is that this leader didn't want you to spew minutae. "Keep it simple simon, I want results not a play by play."


I believe that to be a very obvious joke. The kind that the british are fond of.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: