HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | JamesBarney's commentslogin

Yeah I've seen this a lot. People freaking about issues that have small or moderate impact on deadlines, and very little to no revenue impact. And suddenly you're moving 50% slower because you have weeks of review processes to make sure nothing is missed.


Trust them completely != "assumed that we were competent"

I've worked with plenty of competent people. Only a few were so good I trusted them completely.


It's more mixed. They like it because shields them from frivolous complaints, and lets them document evidence against subjects.

They don't like it when management uses it for frivolous minor policy enforcement or they feel like it reduces their ability to use discretion.

But overall police officers who are given cameras tend to me more positive after using them.


You ever talk to any cops?


So no citations?


https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html - "Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine."; "Don't be curmudgeonly."

FWIW, with a foothold in both domains, this is quite similar to a cop forum poster dismissing all conversation on CVEs until they get a citation on whether or not SWEs like memory safe languages. It's asking for research, when it can only be afforded an opinion poll, and the issue is too complex to boil down to "yes" or "no" - i.e. some "no"s may reveal the underbelly of dislikable cops, some "no"s may reveal it causes them to lack discretion in enforcement due to an over-zealous manager.


That’s not snarky. I am asking for evidence based on the original comment that police like wearing comments. My own anecdotes differ but they are of course anecdotes. Asking for citations is neither snarky nor worth of posting a rules link.

You seem to be misreading what I said. I am pointing out that what I have are anecdotes and I would love to have some real data instead of folks just claiming what police like or dislike. I am sorry you feel the need to be slightly rude in your response too. Again I am not hand waving but simply saying it’s hard to believe cops like wearing them but I have no idea what they feel and I would love data instead of folks expressing ideas. Unions highly opposed the rollout of cameras and I know in the biased selection of videos we see, conversation is often muted. Sorry my post confused you, I am not claiming to know either way!


They're market makers who provide liquidity. So it's not exactly zero-sum.


Honestly academic writing is the only place where I think AI slop might be an improvement over the status quo writing style.


As an academic who is forced to review AI-generated conference/journal submissions, I can assure you this is not the case. LLM-heavy papers are terrible.

Even if they manage to avoid straight-up factual incorrectness, the writing is full of ambiguities and vagueness when you look closely. Meanwhile, space is wasted repeating the same claim in multiple ways, or explaining something simple.

They also seem unable to resist the hype/advertising tone, overselling the contribution while exaggerating the limitations of related work.

I would much rather read grammatically incorrect or awkward sentences.

While academic writing does have a few pointless historical conventions, the huge majority of "status quo writing style" is a logical consequence of 1) minimizing ambiguity, 2) organizing ideas coherently, 3) distinguishing opinion/interpretation from fact, and 4) providing enough detail to be reproducible.


Almost every. Pangram is pretty accurate on longer texts. I haven't seen any glaring examples of false positives.


I’ve heard good things about Pangram but it’s trivially easy to fool it. I generated text using Opus 4.8 and then humanized it using Grammarly. Pangram determined it 100% human-written. Tried it numerous times with the same result. GPTZero claimed with 80% confidence that it was human-written but AI polished. Nothing in that text was human-written.


How long was the text? And mind sharing?


This! Pangram is very good. They claim 1 in 10,000 fp rate.

I had to change my mind on AI detectors after playing around with it.

It would be interesting to hear how this detector compares. It also seems to be aiming for low fp rate.


This should really be the #1 comment on this post.


This really depends what you mean. If you spend $5.00 on anthropic tokens does that cost Anthropic more than $5.00 to serve? No.

If you amortize all of their training and salaries over that $5.00 then yes.

If you only amortize the training costs of that specific model then again we're back to no.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: