HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | JackMorgan's commentslogin

As someone who's spent too much time grinding leetcode: leetcode is very effective in filtering for people who are willing to put in 50-100 hours prepping a cognitive skill only used in interviews. People who have the time to spare to do the prep and are willing to do a bullshit task for the chance to work at the company. People who are desperate for the pay or prestige, and will likely not rock the boat too hard because they worked hard for the job.

Leetcode could be replaced by learning a made up language, memorizing a huge list of numbers, or reciting an epic poem.

The Leetcode game is mostly memorizing pre-existing solutions and then practicing applying them to lots of variations of the same problem.

The real filter is psychological: will you jump through hoops even when they don't make sense?


I've come to believe the dark side effect of LLMs is going to be signal collapse, the complete breakdown of trust in anything on the Internet. So much can be easily faked now: reviews, credible looking websites, email, text. It becomes very easy for scammers to introduce fakes and honeypots. Everything starts to become suspect.

Is this coffee I'm drinking somehow altered with a man in the middle supply chain scam? Am I sure the milk wasn't purchased through a new cheaper vendor that looked completely legit online and has thousands of faked reviews? Am I sure my doctor passed their medical exams or cheated their way through with LLMs? Have I read all the source code of all the dependencies of this software to ensure none are honeypots with backdoors?

Society as a whole is already experiencing a slide to a "low trust society". I think this is going to accelerate until everything becomes so suspect that it becomes almost impossible to operate without spending nearly infinite resources on validation. I'm not sure "governments" are going to solve this in a meaningful way without extreme costs and regulatory burden. This is going to come as a significantly increased cost to everything. The amount of purchasing power available will continue to shrink as the cost of verification takes a bigger bite.


We will not end up like this. We will use formal verification to prove safety of supply chains, of software, and so on; as long as conjectures cannot be proven, we will keep fixing the system until they become theorems.

I wonder if it’s time for software engineering to become licensed. Yes this only covers our field but at least it shows thought exists that understands the ramifications of what AI tooling generates (I guess). I’m sure this wildly unpopular with business because it prevents them from driving a complete race to the bottom. To use an AI tool, you need to be approved and verified. Minimized and reduced versions of the tool still exist for public consumption.

Maybe, just maybe, the EU was onto something with the AI act. The authors of that piece of regulation have identified the same problems, and proposed some concrete measures to combat them.

Some people are calling for verification protocols and techniques so we can avoid all these problems. Tech has reached the self harming point.

ps: sent by old wetware


This is a great article, probably the best about AI I've read to date. I hope more people read this.

The author pitches several possible outcomes of signal collapse, but I suspect they will all happen in different areas. Some might rely on guardians, some might drop trust entirely, some things will be fully upended.

See also Fall or Dodge in Hell for an example of an Internet with zero trust where people pay guardians to edit what they are able to see to prevent meme viruses from causing paranoid delusions. (Which memes already cause in the present day). They also use PERDAs as linked unfakable authorship tokens to help build trust between individuals. No other book I've read has tried to tackle the thorny issues of society wide AI use so deftly.


I watched this is and it's such a great documentary. I really want to take a year now and try to get at least in the top 25% of birders for the year. I was into casual birding before (it's my favorite thing to do when traveling to a new place, just wander around the area and spot local birds). But now I'm loving the idea of these monthly or annual "competitions"


I never hear anyone address the addiction-forming variable reward from pulling the LLM handle and sometimes getting what you want, sometimes getting garbage, and sometimes being thrilled. It's like opening loot boxes for a living. Highly addictive.

Slowing down to review the code feels like drudgery in comparison.

I'm in the review every line camp. I don't trust things that are addictive without a virtuous loop (like exercise). I have to interact with addictive things like video games, loot boxes, gambling, and alcohol in moderation. LLM use fits that perfectly. I'd rather use it throughout the day but still pause and feel the discomfort of reviewing the code, often throwing it out and having it try again when it inevitably makes a hot mess.


I've been seeing this exact outcome this past year. PMs vibe code a hard-coded idea, then the SWE builds a real working one a week later. By the next meeting the SWE has more features than the PMs demo. A week later the PM is still struggling trying to add more ideas to the hard-coded mess while the SWE is cranking out new ideas.


After Covid I joined a volunteer fire and EMS company. They paid for my Fire 1&2, EMT, Instructor 1, and Officer 1. All nights and weekends only. EMT was like 4 months every other Saturday.

EMT was a challenging class because a few of us were competing for highest grade.

I don't do too many EMT calls these days, most of my volunteering is as a lieutenant on the fire side.

I'm very glad I did both, it's been fantastic for my chronic anxiety. I've seen some upsetting things but then I take a break for a bit to process it in therapy. There is a huge need for volunteer emergency response in the suburbs and farther out. If you are interested definitely check it out. If you find a station that's got too many assholes just find another one. Also the people I thought were the worst assholes turned out to just be a little prickly to newcomers and now we are always going out to dinner and renfaires and stuff. Heck my current year long TTRPG game is all folks from the station.

I am also a thru-hiker so I'm very interested in getting into wilderness search and rescue in the future.

I don't think I could ever do emergency response as a career, but I love volunteering. Nothing makes me more appreciative of getting to sign into work with a nice cup of tea and soothing music.


I think there's a lot more to be blamed on a planet that's getting hotter, pesticides in the food, lead in the soil, plastic in the food containers, hormones in the meat and cheese, and cost of living that goes up while salaries don't. Social trust is at an all time low. 99% of the population gets poorer everyday and can feel it. There's no hope of things getting better, so yeah plenty of people stop doing enriching activities.

Porn isn't the cause, it's a symptom of a population losing hope that things will be better for their kids. Or that can't afford kids at all.


This is slopulism, aka you read social media too much and got depression.

> 99% of the population gets poorer everyday and can feel it.

Absolutely not true in the US. What did happen is that poor people's incomes vastly increased since 2019, while upper middle class incomes stagnated.

It may of course be true in some countries.

> Or that can't afford kids at all.

Birth rates declining is a sign of increased incomes, because people can afford entertainment, and prefer to consume it over having kids, which are kind of a bummer and mean you can't have fun for the next 18 years.


> Birth rates declining is a sign of increased incomes, because people can afford entertainment, and prefer to consume it over having kids

This is a ridiculous take.



Eh, don't please.

Just look at the effect it has had on yourself. And tell me it didn't depress you?

I have clients telling me their lives were destroyed because they couldn't stop the addiction.


Do you believe a 50 year old software engineer is mentally no longer able to work?

Should they be forced to sit back and tell stories of the good old days because their knees are blown out?

Do you believe that one of the greatest living programmers is so washed up at 50 that _even with the greatest LLM tools_ cannot ship something publicly in four years to back up his claims?


As firefighters we enter homes in our full turnout gear with fire boots, even for simple calls like automatic fire alarms. The reason being 1/100 automatic alarms are real fires, so we don't want to be caught with our pants down.

Throughout my fire and EMS training I was taught to anticipate possible violence from the residents. I personally know folks who have entered buildings and been shot at or found booby traps. One guy I know responded to an arson house fire where the resident had cut out holes in the floor under every window and door and covered the holes with rugs, Home Alone style.

The US has a serious drug and mental health crisis. First responders often have to deal with people who probably would be in state care if we didn't spend all our tax money on bombs and tax cuts for the wealthy. Or at least they would have caretakers who visit and help them take medications and escalate when they start setting up booby traps to defend against the voices.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: