HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Hasz's commentslogin

IMO, this is driving a lot of conversation out of "public" forums and into walled gardens where there is a much higher reputational barrier to entry.

I personally like the I-know-a-guy invite system. Bad bad actors (nee LLLMs) can be snipped exactly on the invite tree and take 99% of them out as they descend from the same point.


I worked there for a couple years. IMO, the hiring process holds Canonical back from scaling like a typical tech co, but they probably don't want to. It also attracts a very specific type of person; everyone I personally worked with was very bright and capable.

IME, because of pay, they have a hard time retaining "senior" talent, eg Nvidia, Chainguard, Amutable, Lambda, etc etc etc all have lots and lots of senior+ Canonical engineers. Especially in the age of AI, I think this is a "people-strategy" mistake.

The application process is very long and you absolutely lose great candidates because of it. Salaries are not US-tech competitive, but absolutely are Central/South America and Europe competitive. Lots of great Brazilian and Polish engineers, for example.

Also I have never seen a post on HN, Reddit etc about Canonical/Ubuntu that doesn't complain about hiring process. I think it does a pretty incredible amount of damage to the brand.


> It also attracts a very specific type of person; everyone I personally worked with was very bright and capable.

How well did you and your colleagues do at math in high school?


Well if they work at canonical we know they did very well

I wonder why these bright abd capable people didn't join a company that actually pays reasonably.

> Salaries are not US-tech competitive, but absolutely are Central/South America and Europe competitive.

Don't their salary bands change between countries? They're offering 55k-ish to a Senior SWE in France, which is a low-ball offer even there.


>I wonder why these bright abd capable people didn't join a company that actually pays reasonably.

Sounds like they do when they get the chance. I've worked for a company that didn't have quite as crazy a hiring process but they had the same basic profile - very good at hiring for potential in juniors, but underpaid for the ability they wanted. As a result they really struggle to hire seniors and are often a stepping stone to a better paid position. They do manage to keep some people until retirement, though (a very bimodal distribution - generally either brilliant but don't care to work anywhere else, or utterly useless and can't get a job anywhere else)


If they're so bright and capable why can't they patch their OS?

> It also attracts a very specific type of person; everyone I personally worked with was very bright and capable.

I don't know anyone at canonical personally, so I have no specific opinion. However. This smells like the same bullshit peddled by any tech company's hiring policy but executed less competently.


To those asking about more demanding tasks, I totally think this thing could scale up, reminds me of Maslow CNC (and predecessors):

https://www.maslowcnc.com/

basically a cable driven 4x8 sheet router.


I think there is a tendency to conflate the decline in opinions of higher education with a larger anti-science or anti-establishment view.

I don't think this is totally the case! College costs continue to grow (well exceeding already high inflation), and the most recent way I have seen the value was framing it not around academics (or even job readiness, which is still not what college is about), but "building social skills" [1]. The college referenced in the piece is 40-70k/y depending on your status; fewer and fewer young people see taking out 100k+ of debt, 4+ years to "build social skills" as a worthwhile endeavor.

Asians are notably missing from that Gallup poll, I suspect the decline will not be so severe.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANHnFgyjx08


What I really want to know is.. Where is that cheap Micronics SLS printer that Formlabs bought 2 years ago?


He has a lot riding on this particular idea, and I think HN will generally be receptive.

I am not a believer in winner-take-all mechanics for models (even for AGI -- look no further than the natural world for many examples), and a large F50 company committing money/strategy to something outside the frontier labs is a great thing for the ecosystem.


Interesting, but what on earth are the photos in this piece?

It looks like a teen vogue profile. It is kind of hilarious to have an guy who is objectively brilliant posing in flowerbed or deliberately quasi-candid overexposed shots. Not even a pick of him up at 2am wandering around or hunched over a terminal or whatever he does.


> We trust confident people, even when they're wrong

I think this idea can be expanded on, and it is to separate the merits of the idea from the delivery of the idea. I see this frequently with: - neurodivergent people (of whatever variety) - ESL speakers - cultural clashes (eg Dutch / American meetings)

If you can separate delivery and the merits of a discussion, you can benefit both ways -- taking a skeptical view on the best pitches (eg from anyone on a Forbes 30 for 30 list) and an optimistic view on the worst.


imo, the easier and more likely-to-be-successful podcast idea is to press successful people on times they failed. Very few are going to be "first at bat, hit a homerun"; those people are not as interesting anyways to interview.

You solve the credibility problem (they ended up successful) while still distilling down the more valuable failures.


Software is not sold, used, or replaced on speed and memory efficiency. Case in point, most software today (including written by LLMs).

Absolutes matter. If 1x is good enough, making it 20x literally does not matter.


This is true for consumer software. I would imagine for developer tooling and especially internal tools these metrics are rather different?

A 10 minute CI pipeline is great and fine, but everyone absolutely cares if you can bring it down to 30 seconds. This software, by its very nature, is measured by speed.


I used to think this as well, but until it turns out to be a problem for the business worth solving (eg impacting $ machine), it will not get solved. There has to be a why now, otherwise plenty of "problems" get shoved under rug.

Internal tools, IME, are almost always short budget. unless it is in path of revenue, then there is $ and performance matters a great deal *if* more performance means more $.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: