Even though that might help with repurposing the hardware, the L5’s value proposition goes further than than that.
For example, Qualcomm’s Snapdragon SoCs run their own proprietary code in EL3 (aka Secure Monitor). Even though the chip lets you install and run Linux on the CPU, their proprietary firmware keeps running on the same CPU cores too, and there’s nothing you or Linux can do about it, and EL3 code always wins against EL0/EL1. It interrupts your Linux anytime it feels like, sees all your data, and send it to whomever it wants.
Even if their proprietary code happens to be benign, it may have a bug that causes the CPU to silently corrupt your data, or reboot your phone every minute, and there’s absolutely nothing you’d be able to do to fix that.
What Purism promises you is that they design your phone so that it is largely free of those issues. Except for WiFi and mobile baseband, which can’t possibly work without proprietary code.
If none of these things matter to you, then fine, go with mainstream hardware. But you simply can’t use a mainstream SoC to build an open phone just yet.
I wasn't just talking about the standard "unlock the bootloader" scenario, I know that this doesn't let you control EL3 (and even EL2 on qualcomm? since we don't have unprotected kvm before elite gen 6).
That's why I said we need laws to ensure hardware can be repurposed - laws that would guarantee that the hardware can be "unfused" so we could flash those partitions we don't currently control. The proprietary code would help, but is not necessary, we'd just need laws which permit reverse engineering for repurposing the hardware.
My point was that none of this requires designing new hardware, it's just the software (and fusing). We don't have unlimited resources so such laws (the unfusing part might be challenging) would help reduce ewaste..
> That’s why the Librem 5 will include non-soldered, easily serviceable batteries that you can order.
In reality, they cancel all such orders to e.g. Europe “due to regulations”: [1]
> We will not be able to ship spare batteries outside of the USA, due to regulations. Any such order will be cancelled and refunded.
One might argue that Purism can’t be held accountable for things outside their control. But they’ve been more than happy to sell phones to customers worldwide, so I’d say this is a promise they never kept.
Because Purism is not going to have millions of customers but thousands while their R&D costs remain in the same ballpark. Plus manufacturing is much cheaper at scale.
Me too. The one single thing that actually makes me even consider the v2 as my next phone (instead of, say, a Fairphone 6) is the smart card reader.
Using a $15 OpenPGP card to SSH into stuff and sign commits and push them right from your phone feels amazing. I’m not sure I’m willing to give that up. But is it worth $1600, plus locking myself into yet another decade of laggy browsing?
Yep, FWIW Purism does some really cool things that no other manufacturer does with a phone, e.g. the OpenPGP Card and the hardware kill switches, and they do a lot of things I like with a phone, e.g. easily replaceable battery, headphone jack.
If they did a normal evolution in the ARM64 space to have more power and have a better battery life, this would be an easy buy for me.
But it seems that most mobile mainline Linux distros have moved onto Android devices (I use a Oneplus 6 now with Mobian, and I have been tempted to swap to a Fairphone 5). Pinephone straight up does not produce phones anymore. I'd like to see more hardware mainline first phones, but I am not sure this is the right step.
reply