HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | GoblinSlayer's commentslogin

Unschluß

cve-2026-114938 was found in assembler code, lol

>What datetime is your annual birthday celebration?

Doesn't that belong to a scheduler library?


How would it work against vulnerabilities? You still put php inside, and it handles your data. When php is hacked, all your data is stolen, it doesn't matter that your OS is slightly different.

If the host's network driver is hacked, all userland is stolen too.


But if php is hacked and that's chained with a LPE, we'd like the attacker to get root inside a sandbox where that doesn't mean much.

Php vulnerability depends on the rest of your system. E.g. imagine your system has strict sandboxing for PHP.

Also this is like the worst case where the bug is in one monolithic piece of sw. Something like the alpine ssh bug is more relevant, you can plainly see not all systems are effected.


I'm not sure any software is so valuable that you should never consider replacing it. Vibe coding a PHP substitute probably takes less time and tears than cleaning up a PHP exploit.

Someone more qualified than me can speak to isolating device drivers. I do know that one of the virtues of microkernels was supposed to be that you can run drivers unprivileged.


> Vibe coding a PHP substitute probably takes less time and tears than cleaning up a PHP exploit.

Sarcasm? Definitely not true, by several orders of magnitude. Have you seen how many built-in functions PHP has?


I sincerely try to avoid sarcasm. Communication is hard enough without it.

Just to clarify: I didn't mean the effort to find and fix a vulnerability in PHP (although that is also difficult). I meant the effort to reformat your system, investigate what else was compromised, and recover from backups after you get hacked through an exploit in PHP.

You probably don't use every last function, and you might be underestimating what became possible this year. You could have a model search for the features you use. You could have it loop until your existing code passes with the substitute. You could have it rewrite your code to use fewer features while still passing your existing tests.

I'm not saying you have to do this, but I think we should question which of our old approaches are based on old constraints.


Forget PHP, just vibe code a substitute for the ten lines of WordPress you actually need.

(Better yet, just regular code it!)


Encrypt the messages with gnupg.

I don't think anybody tries into KISS, most software is bloated and LLMs copy it, they fundamentally can't think out of the box.


That's always been my concern - there's just so much garbage code out there and very few signals about which of it is well written and which is not ... so LLMs will just regurgitate the good enough code that it's been trained on.

Now would be the ideal time for everybody to give it negative feedback when bad code is returned but I'm afraid not enough people care and we'll just settle with what works just like we always have.


At the end of the day your work is your work. If you tell Claude or whatever to do a thing it will do that thing however you tell it to do the thing.

You can choose to ignore the fine details and just tell it what to build, or you can spend more time and effort and tell it how to do things, you can ask it to create a plan, review the plan and ask for changes etc, you can review the implementation and ask for changes there. You can simply tell it you don't like how a feature is implemented and ask it for suggestions on how to improve it, include what you don't like about it so it has direction.

It's all about the effort you put in. LLMs are able to write clean beautiful and efficient code, they just can't necessarily do exactly what you want on the first try without any direction. That's why you should figure out what you want, ask for what you want and make sure it's actually building what you want.


I don't think that's it. The context that LLMs work with is simply too small, and can't get bigger. Harnesses and the models themselves are bolting structure over it manually; real people are inventing design machines that are a lot more deterministic than they look, and LLMs are just filling them in.

The design machines aren't good enough yet; and their progress has little relationship to LLMs at all. Designing computer programs and the proper level of abstraction for the easiest maintenance, flexibility and debugging is simply an open problem. There's nothing to train LLMs on that is smaller than the size of an entire program, and its history of code changes.

Get a few of those, figure out a way to analyze and reduce the patterns and lessons in them, and train on that maybe. Until then, there's no way for an LLM to figure out what lacking a particular abstraction is going to end up costing.


There's glorious open hardware rpi pico 2.


I think you misunderstood. I’m happy to buy RISC-V computer but from a vendor that I can trust I don’t need to place in DMZ or I see funny traffic on the routers


I don't understand. You will trust it only if you make it yourself?


Nope, but I hope EU would be capable not only to create regulations but being able to actually manufacture and produce stuff.


At least it doesn't silently launch nuclear rockets, smaller bugs are manageable, like accidentally forcing everything to be UTF-8 is basically nothingburger.


until you can't delete a file because it's not valid UTF-8


Google already did it and resorted to unsafe rust to be competitive.


May CGNAT save you.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: