HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | ETH_start's commentslogin

The amount of stress that these vehicles go through as they ascend to orbit and then descend back through the atmosphere to the surface is mind-boggling. To create a rapidly usable vehicle that can do this pushes the limits of material science.

Population decline is due to government restrictions. Space colonization offers an escape from those restrictions.

have you checked how much land on earth is not used today? Which is also a lot easier to handle than mars?

If you don't use mars as a benchmark, we have still a lot of land but if you take mars as a benchmark, even desserts and greenland is inhabitabl easier than mars.


huh? what restrictions? China's one child policy was abandoned more than a decade ago, now replaced with "pls have children, as many as you like!" policy.

The point of Mars colonization is to create a self-sufficient civilization on Mars.

Nothing in the laws of physics prevent that. So at the very least, we know that it's not impossible.


For me the takeaway of all of this is that you need both government and private sector involvement to produce a thriving space industry.

I usually agree that the hybrid approach gives the best outcomes. The govt is necessary when the risk is too great for private industry to bear and the private side tends to move faster on innovation.

Instead of just being sad that people die, we should make a conscious collective choice to use the massive AI/SI compute at our disposal to advance the state of medical technology and engineering.

Gross behavior

The Anthropic IPO is going so badly that you need to insert AI advertisements in an obituary thread?

To be honest I didn't even know that Anthropic was having its IPO today, let alone that it was going badly.

SpaceX launch costs are an order of magnitude lower than those of the launches that deployed Iridium and Teledisic's satellites.

These companies are not developing AI that can replace humans. What AI is being designed for is to fulfil discrete tasks. This is a far cry from acting as an independent economic actor. The latter is something no company wants to develop, because it is dangerous and not suited for something that is meant to be used as a tool (it is actually unethical to bind an independent actor to labor for us).

More broadly, what distinguishes humans from AI is what makes humans dangerous. Our society tolerates the danger humans pose, as it's considered a prerequisite for a free society. But our society would never tolerate this danger from a tool.


> it is actually unethical to bind an independent actor to labor for us

So if I run a script that's unethical? How is a LLM inference loop different than a script?

> But our society would never tolerate this danger from a tool.

Sure about that? Cars kill people, chainsaws kill people, heck, a lot of useless tools such as alcohol kill people. We tolerate dangerous tools just fine, there has never been a tool where humanity would be like 'nope, its cool, but its dangerous so we are going to stop using it'. Not biological weapons, not cars, we never go back.


Instead of making the genuinely helpful AI that eases cumbersome things that people do not want to spend time doing, companies are racing to making generative AI models which are stealing from artists and creatives. And Ai models which have been given agency to do things when they not posess the thinking and reasonig that comes with consciousness. And yes if you run a script to do the same, it is unethical.

ML and DL have their place in research which can push the frontiers of the problems and solutions know to humans today. But are the majority if the companies focusing on that? Nope.

Any technology is a tool and if it is in the wrong hands and there are no guardrails in place, both the human and the technology become dangerous. A car in th hands of a robber, a chainsaw in the hands of someone who has an intent to hurt someone,etc.


My theory is, to build an AI that just helps with 'cumbersome things', and does not come bundled with the faculties to do a whole lot of other things, is impossible. Jagged intelligence and all of that, but intelligence is about patterns on all levels of abstractions, so if you have something that can do your expense report for you, you probably have something that can also evaluate whether its a good expense report and displace someone who does it by hand. To call this unethical is, well, an opinion. The whole history of humanity can be summarized to "learn useful things and automate them".

As for tools in the wrong hands and all, sure. Obviously. My point was that humanity never abandons a technology because of risks, or real issues.


Everyone thinks their ideas are brilliant and that the ideas that run contrary to theirs are terrible. Your comment is tantamount to saying "I disagree with these ideas".

I agree with your sentiment, but something this big should have been run through a committee of not-yes-men before publishing. I feel like honest feedback would have stopped this.

And then it would have been as lame as every other document, and we wouldn't be talking about it.

I know there are people who believe there is no such thing as bad publicity and that it is better to be remembered as a monster than forgotten, but not me.

Monster? What are you talking about?

this is not yet another document, rather a contract with all the legal baggage that comes along with that - like this lawsuit.

That is not true. Other people can have good ideas, bad ideas, kind of bad ideas, very bad ideas, terrible ideas and off the chart stupid ideas.

So, no the comment is not tantamount to saying "I disagree with these ideas". It is possible to disagree with an idea that is not horribly bad. It is possible to disagree with an idea that is quite smart, just with a trade off I dont prefer.


Would you say there's a correlation between how strongly you disagree with an idea and how terrible that idea is?

If you equate terrible with bad. Since most ideas at the far end of the scale are both emotional and the means to an outcome you feel very strongly about, yes,

This is likely the inspiration for the myth of Atlantis.

From what I've understood [0], Atlantis was never meant to be a myth, it's only a fictional alternative version of Athen that Plato conjured up as a political allegory. It's like Batman's Gotham City, it only serves to evoke New York / Chicago.

Though to be fair the concept of a powerful city lost to time is something that resonates a lot, and there's multiple similar myth like the isle of Ys, the lost continent of Lemuria, or in the arabic folklore 'Iram of the pillar', often called 'Atlantis of the sand'.

[0] There was an episode on it in the excellent podcast 'In Our Time' by the BBC (https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m001c6t3)


What Plato describes perfectly fits a volcanic island, including the central pillar of rock that some volcanoes have as a volcanic plug, thermal springs and the ring of water inside the caldera.

And the way Atlantis supposedly ended also fits what happens on volcanic islands.

Nobody at the time could fabricate it out of his own imagination. The description is too accurate.


What Plato described was an invention he created for a philosophical parable, it wasn't intended as history and treating it as such would be akin treating Batman comics as history. The imagined and fictional island was also beyond the Pillars of Heracles which means it was in the Atlantic, not in the Mediterranean.

As well as the mighty, powerful, technologically advanced empire run by.. Santorini?

They had indoor plumbing!

Indoor plumbing is very ancient. Many ancient civilizations had it, although generally only for the rich, temples, or government buildings. The Indus Valley and ancient Egypt developed it 4,500 years ago (2500 BCE). (Greek) Minoan Crete followed around 3,700 years ago (1700 BCE).

In the real world, a great many regulatory rules — possibly the vast majority — are routinely violated in the corporate world. While many are well-meaning, and in theory, beneficial, I suspect total compliance would lead to the economy grinding to a halt.

I'm assuming a similar 'routine flouting of rules' is the rule in the public sector as well, and routine even in the regulatory agencies charged with enforcing the rules.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: