I am not sure who I hate and distrust more… Google or the US Government. Probably the US Government. To have a hypothetical benevolent us government you would need revisions to history earlier than 1776
The thing that I always come back to whenever some kind of heavy-handed government intervention is proposed: what would the other side use this same power to do? OP explicitly called out a hypothetical benevolent US government, but the government changes every 4 years. Even if there were such a hypothetical benevolent government in power when this happened, 4 years later it could be something entirely different.
I sincerely question the intellect of those that join the military of the USA and Britain. I don’t trust these people and would not allow them in my inner circles. If they are not lacking intelligence they are lacking morality.
I can only speak for the US, but at least here it's largely not a question of intellect, but opportunity. If you're a teenager, not particularly academically inclined, in a community without a lot of hiring opportunities, the US military is the single best option you have for making a living wage. They'll feed you, house you, and pay you on top of that, all you have to do is sell your soul. That's a hard deal to turn down.
The people I don't trust are the ROTC lot. They had everything they needed to get into college, and then still decided their skillset was best applied committing atrocities. They're vastly more likely to be some jingoistic nut than the average highschool-to-bootcamp pipeliner.