HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Coeur's commentslogin

From the comic: "Over the course of a year, Io's orbital time varied by 22 minutes".

This sentence implies that at some point in the year the time it takes for Io to do one single orbit, as viewed from earth is 22 minutes longer. That's not true. This is not a good explanation comic.

What happens is that if you have a clock that is very accurate and has a drift of less than a minute for a whole year, and you measure the exact moment that Io's eclipse happens (every 42.5 hours) over a full year, you might expect that it's every 42.5 hours all the way through the year. But what you actually see is that this moment varies over the course of a year by 22 minutes - it's later if Jupiter is far away.

Now you might ask how can somebody create such an accurate clock - in the 17th century? He used a pendulum clock which had a drift of like a second in 6 hours, and at the beginning of each night, he corrected that clock based on some other daily occurring measurement of the night sky, like when a certain star crosses a fixed point when viewed from his observatory.


I think it is still a good explanation because the context makes it clear, although on its own the statement is wrong. Perhaps you could have written "Over the course of a year, its orbit period was late by up to 22min". Phase is too technical and you would have lost a loot of readers already.

Orbit period means the same thing though!

Maybe "observed orbital time" (or "apparent orbital time") would work better.


True, quite difficult to explain it correctly. Perhaps substitute "late" with "shifted".

I was very confused here, your phrasing would definitely help. Once understanding breaks down at the beginning, we may never get out of it.

I believe the universe sets the standard for constants science is attempting to articulate.

With that said, the observation of an orbit being late is an observation that our tracking of the orbits is not accounted for accurately.

Time is vague. If our use of base-12 is to account for 60x60x24 seconds in earths rotation and our calendar systems are based around earths orbit. They fail to align with our solar systems constants.

Likely just another counting and dating system approaching


Oof, "not a good explanation comic" is a bit harsh. I deliberately skipped the synodic-period / cumulative-delay framing because I worried it would add a layer of complexity that might bog down a comic aimed at people with zero physics background.

Didn't intend to make you feel bad. I'm sorry if I offended you.

I think it's interesting that readers often believe "in the medium of comic, things are easier to understand". But it's not so by default. As a writer, it's all about first getting a good intuitive understanding yourself. And then breaking things down into easy to understand chunks that build on top of each other. Which can work in text just as well as a in sequential art.

If I used the form of comic to explain this, I would have shown a graph of time and when eclipses happened, that a scientist might make of this on earth. The graph would have expected eclipses as regular black dots, and there would be red dots with the time of the actual eclipses. And the actual eclipses sometimes line up with the expected time, and sometimes the actual eclipses are a bit late. That would have used the medium to make things clearer.


I'm not sure if it is "comics are easier to understand", but rather that for many, "comics are more inviting to consume than books".

I have 3 (now adult) children -- one was a bookworm and the other two were not, despite doing all the supposedly right things in their rearing (reading to them every night, a large collection of books tailored to them and lining the bookcases in their bedroom, etc.)

They just don't like to read. But Manga and other assorted graphic novels will catch their attention.


I didn't write the original comment but perhaps a suggestion that may satisfy both of you would be to say the "apparent orbital time"? You don't need to get into the details but this way no one will think that you claim that the actual orbital period varied, only its measurement from earth.

Edit: re-reading the comic I think it was pretty clear already but still maybe this helps.


But the apparent orbital period doesn't vary by 22 minutes, the cumulative error in the orbital period reaches as much as 22 minutes.

100 laps that are all a second too long makes a cumulative error of 100 seconds but there was no lap that was 100 seconds too long.

(I actually have no idea about Io, but that's the distinction I think Coeur is trying to make).


I think you're right, the orbit is much faster than 6 months so the 22 minutes would be spread across many orbits. Excellent point, thank you.

It is confusing, Tau usually means period but it should be more like a long duration clock time t.

Ok i still don’t know whats true but at least this explanation with 0 visuals was very intuitive.

Ain’t nobody got time for that nowadays

Piano playing is not like using a typewriter. It matters how you sit, the position of your body, arms and hands, and how you touch the keys. How to not become cramped.

I'd recommend taking lessons with an experienced piano teacher instead of looking for a software solution.


For the near burnt out individual this would be a tempting option for some zen in ones own living room.

This has already been going on for years. Google Flights and Kayak already have fare histories, fare forecasts, fare monitors with automated notifications. So now anybody can get the cheapest price with a low effort.

The industry responded with aggressive unbundling - basic eco now has no carry-on, no seat selection, no changes. All can then be bought as extras.

This is a scenario across many industries - hotels, car rental, cruise, concerts, online retail etc.

Basically - yes that trend is bad for Bob, but it makes things more transparent, fair, and increases competition. It's the way the world goes - hard to stop that.


Yes, but this type of stuff compounds. Moreover, the fact that agents are now the lowest friction interface for this stuff makes it a potential double-whammy.

A similar example discussed recently on the podcast ”The Real Eisman Playbook”[0] illustrates the point: Many retail investors have trading accounts with some cash sitting idle. The brokers earn a healthy margin by investing that cash into short-term money market funds (MMF).

Now obviously, the diligent investors could easily buy the MMFs and pocket the profit themselves. However, many of them are lazy or don’t care. But now with agentic access, even the laziest user can optimize their short-term cash holdings, which might cost the brokers relying on this income dearly.

  [0] https://youtu.be/y45yqiCdfI4?si=TzVcAb0mXjdXObUs&t=490

"multiple providers disclose sensitive conversation-derived artifacts — including titles, prompts, and screenshots — to third parties, often alongside persistent user identifiers that enable user attribution. We also find that some providers publicly expose conversation permalinks without access controls, allowing trackers to read the entire conversation."

Not good at all.


“Screenshots”

The amount of sensitive information that accidentally gets left on screenshots is pretty large. This is a pretty massive security issue


I'm shocked... SHOCKED! that these companies would sell this data to advertisers and violate the privacy of their users. Who could have seen this coming??


No way will your future spouse be an AI entomed robot, with a percentage of your salary endowed to the corporate owner of the hardware.


Have a big virtual hug from me, hxii!


Author claims the system setting "Privacy & Security > Apple Intelligence Report > Report Duration" with its 3 options [Off | 15 minutes | 7 days] sends that data to Apple with that frequency. This is wrong - this is a transparency report so that you as a user can see everything that is getting sent to Apple as a part of Apple Intelligence. Nothing additionally is getting sent to apple if you switch this away from "Off".

It's placed right next to a similar report for the user to see which apps generally connect to the internet and to which domains.

Basically, the main point of the article, "I discovered that macOS 15.3 had enabled a feature that was phoning home every 15 minutes with personal data" is not true.


The main point of the article is not the report duration toggle, it was the whole activation of Siri and Apple Intelligence.

The author turned it off in a previous version, and as they updated their OS it got turned on again (the "Apple said yes" part of the title)


Worth noting that this “report” can only be viewed through a json data export file, which the average Apple user has no idea how to interpret.

It is designed to not be user-friendly.

> Nothing additionally is getting sent to apple if you switch this away from "Off".

Another way of saying this is “personal data is still being sent to Apple if you switch this to off.”


Alas for Apple in this era of AI dumping that file into a chatbot will give you a fully interactive experience to go through the data.


>Concerned about what Apple AI is collecting so I'll dump it all into another corporate AI to find out what it is

We've finally achieved AI Inception here. And I'm sadly sure we're going to go deeper.


Very boxer rebellion-coded. "We won't use the tools of the enemy"


The Siri AI app does not support uploading JSON files to chat.

How far we’ve fallen from the “it just works” era of Apple.

They can’t even make a JSON reader, and require their users to understand the jargon generated by third-parties training on your personal Apple data.


IF this is true apple has done a horrible job at explaining what this is.


that's not the main point of the article

that's not even the topic of the article

that refers to a post from 2025 that he links to. this is clear from the first sentence of the article. I suspect maybe you didn't actually read the article and spent more time writing this erroneous comment than you might have reading the article.


This is literally the main point of the article: "The nice thing about keeping a blog is that I can say at precisely 9:51am, Wednesday 5th February 2025, I discovered that macOS 15.3 had enabled a feature that was phoning home every 15 minutes with personal data. And that I said “no” and turned it off."


Disappointing that we have multiple 10-deep reply chains pearl-clutching Apple's disrespect for the user, and no one actually bothered to verify the premise of the article. They just want to be mad.


The problem is, where's the checkbox labeled "keep your 22 Gb of local models off my 256 Gb drive and keep your assistants off my battery" ?

Apple made the thing compulsory so we're not giving them the benefit of the doubt because they don't deserve it.


When I updated, I had to actively sign up for new Siri and even make space for it. Until update, my phone had the "old" Siri. Not sure what the issue is


Maybe that we're talking about laptops and desktops :)


Welcome to every Apple discussion for the last 25 years.


Snowden got into action because he believed that the US was fundamentally good and needed to get back on track. Over the past 12 years, in the US and around the world, this belief completely vanished. Whatever remains in the archive no longer holds any valuable news.


Therefore there should be no harm in releasing it.


That doesn't equate. Something can have no value as news but incredible value as security. Your passwords, for example.

The big question is whether Snowden's original thesis - that these newsagencies would find the right balance - was correct. In some ways, I hope there is a complete leak of the archive in decades' time when the relative risk is minimised so that the public can, in turn, evaluate the press of the day as to their ability to do this assessment. It may inform future similar whistleblowers whether Snowden made the right choice.


You are correct of course.

Example being the gross irresponsibility of Wikileaks releasing unredacted documents that detailed source identities (although all I know about this is anecdata).


The problem here is an information imbalance between seller and buyer.

This could be solved via regulation (unlikely to happen in the US).

Another solution would be independent testing labs / publications. To stay independent, they can't finance themselves using ads. Would people be ok to pay for information, on the internet? For $1000 lawn mower maybe, what about for a $50 kitchen appliance?


This is the same position of Yuval Noah Harari in his recent Economist interview: The ones in power (Musk etc.) try to frame the bad AI future as inevitable, instead of shouldering responsibility. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FNZhxTtOL-I

The whole interview is well worth your time.


Beautiful perspective if you need to take a left in 500 meters. Not so great if you have to take a left in 3 kilometers because that would just not be visible.

Now of course you could change the parameters so that the upper screen border is 3 kilometers. But normal standard perspective is even better, because it can show you up to infinity. The inherent concept here is that there is a cut-off at the top, and that there is always a lot of unnecessary stuff near you whizzing by to look at / dopamine kicks. So you would have to constantly look at the screen - instead of at the road.

Navigon (among others) back in 2009 showed a perspective that balanced between showing the next junction and the next few kilometers. And leaving out anything unnecessary. I like that better. Example: https://www.notebookcheck.com/fileadmin/_processed_/csm_Garm...


The trick would be adapting relatively, which a lot of apps already do... zoom/flatten out if it's a long stretch of nothing, back in when you start approaching more complicated sections.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: