HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | CodeCompost's commentslogin

What's stopping those students from holding an impromptu memorial?


Most students are probably on trips paid for by others. Many of those groups would probably not be keen to fund an itinerary-free trip to Irvine California for a few days. Even if the students were purported to want to impromptu organize.


Nothing, but the Grace Hopper Celebration wasn't primarily about memorializing Grace Hopper.


Organizing


AI or no AI, this is amazing.


This post is illegible.


What makes it so hard to read for you? The contrast is fine, it even has a narrow column layout to limit the distance your eyes have to travel, the writing style reads quite human and clearly laid out. Or are the 5 pictures giving you trouble?


I used mailbox.org briefly but was very heavily disappointed in it. Canceled my account and moved to Proton.


Why? I have been using mailbox.org for a few years and I am very happy with it.


Not OP, but the Proton UX / UI is far superior to Mailbox.org - which i personally find hard to navigate and disorganized...


I agree the web app is not amazing, I use a native mail application.


i pay for mailbox.org but i never use the webmailer haha, they support IMAP/SMTP


I'm still on fastmail because I use *@domain.name and Proton only supports a very limited number of emailaddresses, and only 3(!) domains. Sadly.


I like the UI simplicity of posteo. They still have quite some advanced features like encrypted address books and more, with good documentation on the implications. No regrets so far, using it since beginning of the year or so.


Proton not supporting third party apps and requiring minimum Android 10 to launch their app can keep their app for themselves, clearly they don't want more users.


Same here. Firefox on Windows 11 looks awful. Edge looks better (I don't use Edge)


People may be dismissive of Serverfault and the other sites but pretty much all LLMs are trained on them.


Yes, it's like a lot of other content that no one will bother to maintain anymore because it is easier to ask an LLM. Not sure where they are planning to get their new training data from ...


The AI "understood" the concepts enough. It can generate readable code in new syntax like Typst, D2lang etc; refer 80 page documentation scattered across urls (looking at you AWS); clone tools from Github to find undocumented features.


Stackexchange network has died for me way before LLMs were even a dream.

Passive aggressive commenting and deleting questions because it looked remotely similar to another one was enough for me.

I was there for learning and sharing, not for the proverbial fighting cage.

I can spend 5 minutes more and use a search engine, and then take my own notes and keep them to myself. Thanks.


The aggressive moderation on StackOverflow was so annoying. I still remember multiple times where I found a question about my exact issue, but it had been closed as a duplicate, and the "duplicate" was basically irrelevant.


And plenty of times I had an answer to a question but couldn't because I didn't have enough 'karma'. Sorry I'm not going to waste my time gaming the system to answer a question and be helpful.


People do still talk about programming online, just not on Stackoverflow.

I think since AI finally provided a non-adversarial alternative to Stackoverflow it lost the critical mass to be a one stop shop for all tools/languages/projects. So people just reverted to communication forums specific to those tools/languages/projects.

There are plenty of project mailing lists, GitHub issues, language forums, blog posts etc. that are still active. E.g. just the Rust users forum gets more than 2-3 posts per day.


I mean, most frontier labs train on user input by default, seems like a pretty good source of information.


Average user input quality is not optimal by definition. SO's upvote system and reputation system is what really refined quality. Much like Reddit's system is helping a lot for conversation. Much like academia's publish and citation system is an even better system.

I'm not saying LLM won't be able to train further, but tough and sound reviews are paramount to improving the corpus of quality content. And with the replacement of SO by LLMs, one can wonder if one quality system went down the drain. Anyway there's still code reviews on GitHub and in private repos, but we're still far from getting the human judgement out of the loop.


"Average user input quality is not optimal by definition."

Absolutely.

"SO's upvote system and reputation system is what really refined quality."

Absolutely not!

SO's problem was exactly that they gave average users moderating power. That lead to half of the questions being closed because they were over the head of the average user/moderator regardless of being interesting and useful questions or not.


This issue was mostly on SO itself. For most other stack exchange servers, it worked really well.


I'm sure there were plenty of people like me who couldn't help because they didn't have the right amount of "karma".


I do expect there will be more closed knowledge forums. Unfortunately one person exposing it to LLM provider will be enough to break the whole idea. But I believe there will be many that will keep secrets for some in group.


You can train on questions, but I will rarely answer to a chat with a SO-quality answer.


It was great while it was good. The demise wasn’t quality as such, but rather the insane moderation - closing everything as duplicates or out of scope etc.


CoSOMO (Content Stolen; Obsoleted, Move On)


Ouch ... brutal, disheartening, but true.


You guys tbh are just infuriating. StackOverflow and ServerFault in particular are CC BY-SA. I contributed to a lot of websites which are currently switching from public access to login required. I did it under the assumption that anyone will be able to read it. Thank god Stack Exchange and HN so far are not showing petty resentment.


You are absolutely right. These contributions were given willingly under a very permissive license. That is on the contributors.

It might not have been that apropos to roll out in this context, but the point goes for all LLM vacuuming.

PS: Although those contributors might have been willing to let anyone, corporation or person, manually use their submissions, they might have felt differently about remix machines.


And all the sites trained on humans, something which we never found offense with, for some interesting reason.


'Force Majeure' is a good way to describe their incompetence.


I can't reconcile that with https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49831204 . Everyone knows about Oracle's incompetence already and should reasonably be able to predict it, especially themselves.


You could, you know, pull the plug.


And you are ... ?


Agreed but I think you need to pry Visual Studio from VB.NET developers' cold dead hands.


C++ developers, too. I suppose they're splitting out the real powerful stuff (Debugger, LSP) for VSCode's consumption.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: