HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | BoumTAC's commentslogin

Vals AI just affirm that Grok 4.7 is worse than Grok 4.6 (It ranks #24 on the Vals Index at 54.2%, down 5.0 points from Grok 4.6 (#14, 59.2%))

https://x.com/ValsAI/status/2102086608476590432


Is this an ad for Vals AI? Looking at their website, the rankings don't mesh with my observed utility for almost any model outside of fable and astra being good-ish.


Absolutely not. I know Elon retweet them a lot when Grok is good. This is how I discover the company.

I like to follow them and look for benchmark for each LLM release.


Ah gotcha, not on twitter so just hadn't seen them before!


Noob question: what's the purpose of having so many request libraries? In JavaScript it's crazy, but in Python it's starting to feel the same: requests, httpx, httpx2...

From my perspective, HTTP requests have been mastered for years (decades?). What's the point of switching libraries? What's so extraordinary about the new HTTP library that makes requests look crap?

I understand that new protocols appear from time to time (like HTTP/2), but that's very rare. And if there are performance differences between two libraries, are they really that huge? Even if they are, 99% of people don't need that boost. What prevents someone from just improving the existing library's performance?


`requests` has a friendlier API than the standard library. However, it does not support newer versions of HTTP, nor does it support `async`. The maintainer considers it complete, feature-frozen software, IIRC - they'd rather keep it stable for existing users and let other libraries succeed it.

`aiohttp` supports `async` but was never popular for non-async

`httpx` supported newer HTTP versions and both async and non-async. However the maintainer decided to close all outside submissions, issues and discussions for personal reasons.

`httpx2` is a maintained fork of `httpx`


'urllib3' completely saved me once. We had to authenticate with the border proxy using a certificate, then make a request to a web service ... that needed authenticating with a certificate. Urllib3 was the only one that could do it.


I've had to do similar in the past, and also wound up on urllib3.


Thanks for the explanation !


Also niquests as well which is a dropin replacement and imo wayyy better than httpx


niquest is something like a one-man-show, which is an issue-per-se

Of course, it is clearly superior to everything else (being authored by a french guy !). But sadly, some people do not accept this simple fact :(


“Niquer” means “to f*ck” in French slang


And why don't people use pycurl? Curl is the king of the hill...


There are tradeoffs to the non-Python HTTP libraries like pycurl and pyreqwests, namely:

- Non-portability to alternative Python implementations or environments without the supporting C libraries

- Less visibility into the client internals (for debugging etc)


Thx!


thanks for the summary.

>`httpx` supported newer HTTP versions and both async and non-async. However the maintainer decided to close all outside submissions, issues and discussions for personal reasons.

how can something like this happen? and which positive consequence there can be out of that?


> how can something like this happen?

https://xkcd.com/2347

Specifically in this case, the consensus seems to be the maintainer is having some mental health struggles and chose to close out outside contribution.


ohh thanks for that xkcd! totally right!

only problem I have and that's probably why I didn't associate it directly myself is that I see the example very valid for many other FOSS cases.

but in this case it feels like the part at the bottom is made of multiple random persons, not a single one, and one of those random persons decided to exclude all the other random persons.

so maybe the lower layer shall be represented as made of multiple pieces that fight each other, beside the all modern shit on top of it.


HTTP is a pretty complex space once you get into the nitty-gritty of use-cases, common request handling patterns & conditional/dynamic header-definitions. In general this leads to:

- (a) built-ins (& some libraries) being very verbose to use because they tend to take a "fundamentals of HTTP" approach & not implement shortcuts/common patterns

- (b) libraries commonly falling into the trap of going the opposite direction & ending up with massive scope-creep and/or oversimplified, un-expressive APIs.

This leads to a churn of libraries due to developers yearning for a Goldilocks implementation in between.

Javascript tends to be ahead of other ecosystems in churn due to ease of library publishing, Python's catching up, but overall it's the same pattern in both.

---

Also, one big additional factor is async:

- NodeJS built-ins implemented a callback pattern just before promises took off, & have struggled to upgrade to promises cleanly without breaking backward compat.

- Python's got a similar story with various generations of http library being sync, or relying on different async approaches in confusing ways.


There can be different APIs or different technical implementations with certain performance characteristics. In this case, there isn't any purpose, though. It's just that development has slowed or stopped on the previous libraries and forking/renaming is easier than trying to continue the previous projects, for various reasons.


Async ruins everything, as usual.


The DHH hate is absolutely crazy on HN.

I don't understand how people can be so out of touch.


It's not hate, it's not wanted to be associated with:

see https://victorwynne.com/dhh/


I need to go look up the CEO of my refrigerator, dishwasher, couch, car, cell phone, TV, shirt and jeans, and oat milk to see if they said anything I disagree with on social media so I can boycott them.


Do they have prominent blogs that are good to read to keep up in the industry you work in?


Unironically, AI could automate the boycott.


I mean, that might not be the worst thing?

Like, if you have something you regularly spend a lot of money on, it might be worth spending 2min on the Wikipedia article about it’s manufacturer to verify that it’s not made by child slaves or someone who sends all their profits to the KKK or whatever.

Doing that seems like basic prudence for an interconnected world, and a far cry from like … digging around Reddit threads looking for reasons to be outraged.

I have no opinion on DHH. I do think it’s good, actually, that lots of people are incorporating politics into their product use/purchase choices these days. Those decisions always had political consequences, so it’s good that people are now considering that.

Some people definitely have rubrics for making those decisions that I think are stupid, and some people do it dishonestly (e.g. performative public outrage over a random OSS contributor’s transphobic tweet while spending money on Harry Potter shit). But the fact that people are increasingly considering the social context of product use is still good, dumbasses would find other ways to be dumb regardless.


Update: I read DHH’s blog. I now have an opinion on DHH: not good.


I read the original post DHH links to. I don’t think it warrants the kind of hate he gets.

DHH has always been very outspoken in his opinions. That’s why he bashed Heroku so badly when he introduced Kamal. It’s what makes Rails such a clear minded framework.

In his political blog, he’s raising an issue that’s occupying all of western politics. And he’s very aggressive about it - just how he was very aggressive when he said “stop paying ridiculous amounts for stupid managed clouds”.

Instead of arguing where he’s wrong, people - including the blog post you cite - write “that’s hateful and racist” and refuse to engage beyond that. That is the very shut-up mentality he writes about.

It frustrates me so much to see this here on HN. HN is supposed to be a place to discuss, not blame others. This resistance to engage in a constructive discussion, even if the person with the differing opinion isn’t articulating them well, or has errors in their reasoning that upset you, is super harmful. It’s what gives all these far right parties their rise to power. They occupy the subjects then that their voters have on their mind, because everyone else doesn’t dare to talk about it.

We could have constructive discussions around such topics. But if we don’t, all that happens is that those who don’t feel heard - in this case rightfully so, because we chose not to hear them - will develop more and more extreme ideas.


> Instead of arguing where he’s wrong, people - including the blog post you cite - write “that’s hateful and racist” and refuse to engage beyond that. That is the very shut-up mentality he writes about.

What a weird statement. He has a platform, people that think his content is hateful and racist don't have a platform. He writes about kicking out normal people living their lives from places that he is not even from. Antagonizing people in position of power with this kind of mentality is what every sane person should do.


There is no "constructive discussion" to have with racists


I did not really knew why DHH was controversial until a few month ago. He was heavily promoting the en translation of an old super far right french book. It is from the 70's and it is absurdly far right when you look up who wrote it and who promoted it in France at that time.

He is probably at a KKK level of racism.


I don't hate the guy (I don't know him personally so I cannot hate him), I just disagree with his opinions and I personally don't want to use anything that he makes or endorses. Easy as that.

I know that there are other people contributing to Rails, and that's their choice. Other people stopped contributing once DHH showed his true nature.


I presume, that you're not shopping anything on shopify?


Good question, I don't know. I usually buy stuff online from a few big websites that are specific to my country.


Do you think DHH is out of touch too?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: