HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Avamander's commentslogin

About time.

It really is. There are a lot of problems with the large freemail providers, but requiring DMARC is not one of them.

A bad mirror is much less likely than someone MiTMing, at least for most machines.

If your scale actually makes caching worth it you can run a local HTTPS mirror. If you don't control the endpoints to do that, you don't get to MiTM anything.

Who actually does that this day and age?

I do. Helps massively when seeding virtual machines using auto-install scripts.

Thinking about it, that's not a good argument for http being the default. If you're seeding VMs, you're already in control of the config. Using a dedicated repository proxy (apt-cacher-ng? sonatype nexus? pulp? something?) might even perform better than a generic caching proxy.

Same. It's faster and feels respectful to not keeping hitting freely provided repos for the same packages over and over. Someone has to be paying for the bandwidth.

Developers

So a minuscule part of the install base that can absolutely alter system configuration to use a local mirror.

Not something that should be the default, exposing everyone to the dangers.


Not surprised at all. I remember all of the heated discussions (even here on HN) around there being absolutely no need for HTTPS because "everything is signed with PGP".

Exposing all of the internals of something to any and all MITM keeps on demonstrating how it's a dangerous idea.

Hopefully this example settles at least some of this pointless discussion.


That's exactly why layered security is a thing since ever. Weird that some argued that a singular layer is sufficient.

Does it?

Let's compare the extremely, extremely rare edge case of this with signed packages via Debian's keyring on the local box, vs all the bugs and issues with any code in the SSL layer. And of course, that the people most able to MITM, which are often 'state actors', likely have root certs by various means regardless.

I would be astonished if for example the NSA hadn't obtained the capacity to generate certs for MITM at the drop of a hat.

And regardless, without certificate pinning, MITM is a thing with SSL anyhow. There have been quite a few sketchy SSL providers over the years, there was a deep post about how hard Mozilla works, for all their other foibles, in trying to keep bad actors out of their accepted list.

Point is, SSL isn't actually that secure, has its own layers of bugs and issues, not enough people certificate pin, and so on.


That speed comes with its own cost though. Might be simply too unreasonable at their scale.


My understanding is that (at least part of it is)the OTW has legal concerns over hosting fan works on somebody else’s computer. So they took the very reasonable step of hosting it on their own computer.


As I understand it, the second site will allow them to resume operating at a limited capacity sooner than 2-4 weeks?

Other than that 2-4 does sound more like hardware lead time rather than time it takes to resolve a security incident.


CDOC2, there are also other similar widely used encrypted container formats.


I recommend comparing what it rewrites to something that Gemini models output. I think there's still a lot that Anthropic could improve.


All Anthropic models write like that since Opus 4.8. Opus 4.8 was still tolerable.

Unfortunately only Gemini models can write text that isn't vomit-inducing.


Opus 5.5 doesn't write like this anymore


It has different awfulness.


I don't find it anywhere remotely as bad. I'm not saying it's good, but jesus.. i was ready to leave anthropic lol.


I literally left. 5.5 is so much better. I don't know how they managed to mess up 5 so bad


5 I couldn't bear. It was terrible AND verbose


I did leave. Opus was just pumping out so much verbosity and wasting tokens on all that nonsense, plus I was bitter that Anthropic gates the best model behind usage credits, so I switched to ChatGPT just as Astra came out.

Then Opus 5.5 came out and I switched back to Ant after 1 month of OAI. Opus 5.5 fixed all the previous Opus 5 problems, and while Fable still requires credits, there's hardly any need to use it since Opus 5.5 is so good and so token efficient.


It's less obvious but it's still there. For starters it loves to anthropomorphize everything, it excessively uses verbs that shouldn't be used with inanimate objects and concepts. Not the only issue though.


Fable 5.1 does. Wretched


I made it with 5.5, sorry!


Every other comment on LLM news in 2023:

"this is the worst it will ever be"


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: