lol, don’t do the Mac fanboys bidding for them now. I’ve owned Macs for probably 15+ years now and we’ve had Thinkpad and XPS among other options that are objectively every bit as good and subjectively far preferable for me than the Mac options. And a good chunk of that time between butterfly keyboard and thermal fiascos, the PC options easily beat them objectively and subjectively. Notebookcheck takes a purely objective approach to this and has always had many models that are equal or exceeding the Mac options according to their data driven purely objective criteria ratings.
“ I don’t want to spend _any_ of my spare time tinkering with why my WiFi drivers aren’t working, or if a specific GPU is compatible. That still rules out Linux (or at least it did in 2024 when I last properly looked)”
This is not true on Linux supported hardware. These issues stemmed from trying to run Linux on hardware that isn’t officially supported. It runs circles around windows in this aspect. By all means use Mac for other reasons but if you buy hardware that specifically supports Linux you won’t have this issue like you do on windows.
> if you buy hardware that specifically supports Linux
If I go on to the main retailers online and buy any PC hardware there’s an incredibly high likelihood it works with windows, and if I buy a peripheral it will work on a Mac. The reason that I don’t use Linux at home is because not using it entirely eliminates that problem from life
It will likely come with Windows loaded up with OEM bloat however if you re-installed Windows yourself you would probably have to go to the manufacturers website to find drivers whereas Linux is far more likely to just work right out of the box.
As far as peripherals I mean Linux is such an established industry standard now I would expect anything that plugs into a computer to work on Linux these days. I think your concerns are officially outdated now.
Or just…buy one of the abundant high quality Linux supported/certified options out there? It’s a win win, they’re usually nicer machines anyway like thinkpads/xps etc.
I don’t complain I can’t run macOS on unsupported hardware, that’s just the fact of any operating system out there including windows, there has to be driver/hardware support in the operating system itself. Windows just seems like everything supports it because that’s the most ubiquitous and default from the historical first mover advantage. There’s no magic windows fairy dust though, it needs driver/hardware support just like Mac and Linux and all other OS do as well, that should be pretty obvious.
And peripherals, like the other guy said that’s long an outdated concern for most mainstream options. I usually just find the best rated/most popular options on windows and they nearly always already are fully working and supported on Linux just fine. It’s been many, many years when I actually had to put in effort to find a Linux supported peripheral since my first choice always just works.
Couldn’t have said it better myself. HN and Reddit are the kings of delusion in thinking they’re remotely close to even 1% of the market Apple and others are concerned about. And rightly freaking so, they represent an rounding error in revenue and generally are never happy with anything, at least anything short of a product that would be, in turn, undesirable for the other 99% of the market.
> Lots of Linux options is actually a bad thing for most people. They want just one that does something reasonable.
Yep, exact reason (among quite a few others, but one of the primary ones) myself and so many other devs I know ultimately quit desktop Linux. It’s such a bad experience to not have one single reproducible, standardized option that the entire industry supports like Mac or windows. Check out the stackoverflow survey, which reflects it as well. Hell, I spent many years at Red Hat and probably 50% of devs and technical staff are running Mac’s for their work machines for that exact reason, and they all prefer it despite working at the most notable Linux company. They don’t care either, since RH makes virtually zero money off of desktop Linux.
Having options isn't a silver bullet and it won't make everybody happy. It's also not intended to make everyone happy, but to solve a problem of software ownership.
The problem isn't when adopting a closed platform, but when people start expecting it to respect their preferences. It's always a matter of time for the experience to degrade little by little with no option to run to.
This is to say, we should use the tools that get the job done, but always be vigilant with coupling to any vendor, but specially proprietary ones.
reply