HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Ariarule's commentslogin

Context matters; a comment comparing HN to Reddit in the middle of huge thread specifically about the character of the community and how it may (or may not) have changed is different than a comment on a random thread. Especially as quite a few seem to think that, no, something really has changed the last few years and it's not merely a "a semi-noob illusion"?

We're not allowed to talk about that here.

I don't completely like or think this is a good ultimate decision, but looking over the thread on Github, it's being done for practical rather than ideological reasons after trying a more liberal policy first, and the discussion thread there indicates that they're already considering how to relax and refine it. A long-term and total ban on AI contributions would be a mistake as it all but guarantees a competitor or a fork, beside enforcability issues that create a "now you have two problems" situation. But as a temporary stop gap as specifically indicated by https://github.com/qgis/QGIS-Enhancement-Proposals/pull/387#... this seems fine, and it's such important context that "QGIS bans AI assisted contributions" is true but misleading.

The linked discussion thread specifically calls this a "moratorium" and it's unfortunate that they decided not include that explanation in the policy document specifically to avoid controversy and flak, with the end result that there's now a 202-comment-plus HN thread: https://lists.osgeo.org/pipermail/qgis-developer/2026-Septem... -- the "proof of life" concept being tossed around in that thread, although rejected, is genuinely interesting and I hope they revisit it and allow a nominal financial contribution to the project to prove a human is behind a PR regardless of AI assistance (probably along with some other approach, as a total exclusion and the only way it would also be bad).

My own experience with QGIS is limited to the most basic navigation and queries of some local maps I've archived. Nonetheless it's an obvious gem and I hope they're able to arrive at a balanced and sustainable policy. Maybe they would get there faster and more reliably by tightening the previous LLVM-inspired policy rather than the slam-shut and then loosen approach they seem to be taking, but hardly anyone has experience with a situation exactly like this, so only time will really tell.


Ok, I've included a link to the email thread in the toptext and put the word 'moratorium' (which does occur there, into the title. Maybe it will dampen some the more boring flamewar responses in favor of the reflective subthreads which have also popped up here.


Wonderful work, and it's unfortunate that knee-jerk anti-AI sentiment is getting in the way of appreciation for the accomplishment by some others. Consider this: if the exact same oddities and anomalies had been discovered 3 to 5 years ago with traditional NLP, or OCR and/or some clever statistical techniques, would anyone be dismissing it? The post goes into the work they did to orchestrate and explore with the AI in this case, so it's no less impressive an effort than the hypothetical, and the discoveries just as valid for consideration.


I don't understand this sentiment. This whole thread is quite positive towards the findings. What we have is a societal verification problem where work has become hard to evaluate and verify, so everyone is being extra careful with their judgements.


I understand the sentiment - I spent most of my childhood having it pointed at me, as the disconnect between my perceived effort and my outcomes was enormous.

People… don’t actually care about what you do, when you succeed. They care about how you do it. You have to be seen to be sweating, struggling, toiling, generally having a terrible time of it - otherwise what you produce is worthless.

Why? Identity. Protection of self from an arbitrary and unfair universe. The internal narrative of “I worked very hard so I deserve this”.

Things which threaten that narrative - be it a child prodigy or a machine prodigy - are very upsetting for people, as they attack a core element of the tale they tell themselves that allows them to survive in this world. That I am valuable, because what I do has value derived from struggle.


LLMs are a clever statistical technique. And this use of it is a reason for this "let me code by hand" grognard to cheer.


> it's unfortunate that knee-jerk anti-AI sentiment

I’m so tired of this comment. You’re like the people complaining of vegans and Apple users—I see more of you complaining about the group than there are members in the group. Ironically the thing “getting in the way of appreciation for the accomplishment by some others” is your knee-jerk anti-anti-AI sentiment.

Give it a rest. There aren’t that many comments on the thread still and yours is the top one. No one is contributing more to the anti/pro argumentation than you are. Don’t stoke the flames then complain the house is on fire.


When I made my comment yesterday, the previous top comment was negative and dismissive, and for a vacuous reason. Why not reply directly instead? I decided it would be better to positively _appreciate the original work done in itself_, to not boost a vapid debate from a eye-rolling starting point, not to make it personal towards anyone, and especially, as it is actually the greater portion of that comment you quote, to make an analogy to other techniques.

And then I get this useless advice to "give it a rest", as if there were no such negative reaction in the first place, no such parallel drawn between older work and newer work, and as if the counterfactual of what would happen if people were not willing to appreciate such works was not immediate obvious. If there were a substantial contingent on HN claiming that projects done on Apple devices were somehow not real, and trying to shout down Mac-based projects, it would indeed be very tiring, but the problem would not be with people musing on parallels to similar workflows in Linux environments to highlight and acknowledge when a project done on a Mac was good work, nor with Apple fans!


Why didn't _you_ respond directly to the negative comment?


> When I made my comment yesterday, the previous top comment was negative and dismissive

In other words, the contrarian dynamic.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

> and for a vacuous reason.

I read all top level comments on the thread older than yours, and don’t see any which is “anti-AI”. Yours seem to be the first top level comment which even mentions it.

> Why not reply directly instead? I decided it would be better to positively _appreciate the original work done in itself_

The very first sentence in your comment is criticising others. If your goal was to be positive towards the project, you could have done just that. It wouldn’t stop you from separately replying to (and downvoting) the other unspecified comment with your criticism of their point.


The previous top comment is trivially findable with a page search for "AI". Contrarian dynamic could explain why the reactions overall look more positive now, fair enough; I'll keep in mind it's possible to give an incorrect impression in the future as a result of the comment order shifting.


I do not, in fact, see such an unambiguous, unhedged claim in OP. Can you quote it?


An unhedged claim can't be quoted because there isn't one, but nobody claimed otherwise. Absolutist claims are, of course, an unrealistic bar for journalism. It's unclear why you are writing ominously/non-colloquially. I'm guessing you have some kind of unstated bias here, and are falling into the internet trope of speaking as though something doesn't even exist unless it is proven in a court of law or via formal math or something.


Ha! It is actually _some_ funny serendipity. I just stumbled across this in my saved pile and thought it would be an interesting oldie to share, and did not realize that release was going to be today at all until I saw these comments here now.

It was actually submitted three days ago originally. I don't know if whoever second-chanced it had the timing with the new game in mind, so it may or may not be a complete coincidence that way.


Amazon says it's in stock right now. Costco also has it online and says it's on the shelf at my local warehouse.

It was literally available from the first two places I checked.


Always glad to see more open-weight models, but this caption on the 2nd demo image had me do a double-take: "Land or Water Generalization Experiment: We recreated the viral X puzzle by asking Beam to create a fixed 180×90 grid for longitudes -179° to 179° and latitudes -89° to 89°, with 16,200 points. This puzzle is a few days old, so could not appear in the training data, thus testing the model’s generalization. Beam gets 95.5% coverage right, putting us between Opus 5 (92.5%) and Fable 5 (97.8%), which shows how well it generalizes to novel new tasks."

Oof, no, this "puzzle is a few days old" is incorrect even if it's a social media trend just recently. Asking a model to generate a world map in this way is _at least_ from August 2025 as it appeared on LessWrong at that time: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/xwdRzJxyqFqgXTWbH/how-does-a...


Yeah I remember when the original post about this came out. Def not recent. Though I think their point survives in that they didn't exactly RL on this.


Thanks for pointing this out, it's a great point. The team did not realize that the trend went that far back.

We've updated the caption to read: "Land/Water Generalization Experiment: We recreated the viral X puzzle by asking Beam to create a fixed 180×90 grid for longitudes -179° to 179° and latitudes -89° to 89°, with 16,200 points. Despite not being trained on multimodal inputs like images, Beam runs the analysis in text mode and gets 95.5% coverage right, putting us between Opus 5 (92.5%) and Fable 5 (97.8%), which shows how well it generalizes to novel new tasks."


I'd love to see these tests repeated for the current frontier models...


It could be old but still not be part of the training set.


Yes, but then you can’t use “it’s 2 days old” to assert that it can’t be in the training set.

Seems sloppy.


Seems rather sloppy to not validate it wasn’t in their training or RL data.


I don't think age of the puzzle even matters, all models have search capacities these days


> all models have search capacities these days

one would hope that they disable websearch and internet access (maybe all tools?) when doing generalization testing?


Model weights (what is being tested here) don't inherently "access the web" when inference is running. If the model has access to a web search tool, that's a different story.


Is search part of the model or the harness?


Maybe that's a rhetorical question but just in case - the search would always be part of the harness. A model is only handling next-token prediction for a given input. That token may be something like [[web search]] to invoke a tool call but the actual call would be handled by the harness.


Yeah it was rhetorical. Search would be implemented as a tool call. Pure intelligence tests would likely have limited tools. But maybe they would have a python sandbox to solve issues like Rs in strawberry.


If they made that statement and knowingly had search enabled, it would essentially be fraudulent.


No byline, acknowledging that it's part of series that usually doesn't have them. Google trends has nothing for the phrase right now. UD, as of this writing, never heard of the expression (although don't be too surprised if someone swoops in to "correct" that later). Even for a generation that's ostensibly not going to have a huge social media footprint yet, that's rather remarkable for a supposed "biggest insult".

https://trends.google.com/explore?q=%22That%27s%20so%20AI%22... https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=That%27s+so+...


Huh? Processed ingredients don't generally get a pass on nutritional labeling requirements in the US. A bag of flour in a grocery store should have a label.


The European grocery-bought bag of sugar I have lying around has a regular nutritional label, including a list of ingredients. Spoilers: sugar is made out of sugar and contains almost 100g of sugar per 100g.


I checked some 25lb bags of flour (not from a grocery store) and they do not appear to have any nutritional facts label.


Ok, if they're meant to be marketed for food service, like a bakery regardless of who actually purchases them, then that does makes sense.


That is also the title I see clicking through into the page, although it seems to be 24 characters over the limit, so that _some_ change to OP would have have been required to submit it.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: