HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | AnthonyMouse's commentslogin

> This puts often overlooked initiatives like GDPR in a completely different light to me.

The problem with initiatives like GDPR is that they don't actually solve the problem. If you're worried about the SS then a law that tries to tell companies what they can do with some data is totally useless, because the thing you need is for the companies to not have the data.

If Apple can run code as root on every iPhone then when the SS comes, the SS can run code as root on every iPhone. They go to Apple and put a gun to their head, or infiltrate the company with operatives, and then do what they please with the central control the company already holds.

To prevent that you need to change the architecture of the systems in popular use to remove central chokepoints that authoritarians could use for censorship and surveillance. But none of those initiatives have accomplished that, and most of them don't even attempt it, even though that's the thing you'd need them to do.

You need "no chokepoints" to be the pre-existing default when the baddies come so that when they try to change it, people can already see why they shouldn't and refuse to give up the existing systems without it. Instead of needing to develop those systems only after the need arises, and then needing to do it under a hostile regime which is meanwhile using the existing systems to commit atrocities.


> Because they rule on the sprit of the law, not as it was written.

I feel like this attitude is responsible for the modern destruction of the rule of law.

It doesn't matter what the law says, the only thing that matters is vibes! And whether you play golf with the right government officials.

> You can't "Trick" them by saying "well technically this is allowed!".

The obvious problem being that sometimes it is allowed. And then do you want that being decided by democratically elected representatives and specified ahead of time so the public can know what's expected of them and of others, or decided ex post facto on the basis of feels and discrimination?


This is the case where the xkcd doesn't apply though.

The thing about insurance fraud is that the major thing that will cause it to be fraud is when you set the fire on purpose.

The tax code doesn't really have that. You'll often even see confused people inserting nonsense language in various places to the effect that doing something to avoid taxes isn't allowed, but meanwhile "doing something to avoid taxes" is the expected mechanism of operation for tax incentives meant to get people to do something they otherwise wouldn't have done.

And then because of that you need to actually care about what the tax code says and what the unnecessarily complicated nonsense allows someone to get away with without breaking the law, instead of pretending that it's all common sense and people can be punished for being "bad" without ever actually specifying what that means.


In theory "impossibility" is a defense to most crimes.

In practice you usually get screwed in one of the following ways: a) the law makes it impossible to do X without breaking the law, even though X is a normal thing and neither law was supposed to be a total ban on X, but you could comply by not doing X at all, b) the inconsistent laws are imposed by different jurisdictions and then they each insist you follow theirs, often a special case of the first one where X is "be in two different jurisdictions" but sometimes the even stupider one where a jurisdiction demands that you follow its laws even when you're not in it, c) it's impossible for you to follow both laws at once so you followed only one of them and then they decide after the fact that you should have followed only the other one.


Re: imposed by different jurisdictions. I don't know the letter of the law in the US, but here in Australia at least, most such differences are easily resolved by section 109 of our constitution (note: Commonwealth == Federal):

"When a law of a State is inconsistent with a law of the Commonwealth, the latter shall prevail, and the former shall, to the extent of the inconsistency, be invalid."

Hmmm, just googled, and it would seem that Article VI Clause 2 of the US constitution, aka the Supremacy Clause, is basically equivalent.


In the US, the Supremacy Clause only holds insofar as federal law doesn't overstep the restrictions on federal power outlined elsewhere in the Constitution. The wording is "the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance [of the Constitution]".

If you follow federal law over state law, but then a federal judge holds that the federal law you followed was an unconstitutional overstep in a domain that the Constitution reserves to the states, you are SOL


This might be happening with the founders of Kalshi. The federal law and CFTC has been saying that these prediction markets are federally regulated, but they're facing criminal charges in some states.

Even that causes problems though as normal casinos with sports betting are then offering a cftc regulated product without a license.

Kalshi isn't "bets", it's a "market" where people trade contracts related to the outcome of the sports game. I think that's the argued legal distinction.

I think it's nonsense and that gambling is very destructive, but there does seem to be a line there where sometimes sports betting is betting, and other times it's trading in a market.


What part about walking into a Casino and giving them money in exchange for a betting slip isn't a contract for the casino to payout money based on the outcome of a sports game?

I'll buy there's a difference between creating the contract and being a marketplace to sell the contract. (Ebay doesn't produce pokemon cards but lets you sell them). However then, who minted the contracts? Kalshi is just a casino; you can't bring your own contracts there and you must use theirs.


Distinction without a difference imo

You're assuming the contradiction is between a federal law and a state law and not e.g. a law of the US and a law of France.

One of the more recent fun absurdities is some jurisdictions claiming that if you have a service accessible over the internet then you're subject to their (i.e. every) jurisdiction.


Do you have some examples of an "X" activity or behavior? I understand the logic you're discussing, but can you help ground it?

Suppose you have a law that says that in order to build new multi-unit housing, a given percentage of the new units have to be affordable housing and have to be built within reasonable distance of a transit stop in the same town. Meanwhile you have a town with poor mass transit and very little land zoned for multi-unit housing, and none of it overlaps. In other words, you're both required to and prohibited from building new affordable housing units near a transit stop. Which means you also can't build the other units.

I thought one law could not force you to break another?

Which law are you breaking if you build no housing whatsoever?

Notice that there are many cases of this where that kind of outcome is what you want, e.g. if there is a law against operating e-bikes above 20 MPH and a law against going below 40 MPH on the freeway and the de facto result is "no e-bikes on the freeway" then that's a pretty reasonable outcome.

Whereas "no new housing" is a presumably unintended absurdity, but that doesn't mean you're guaranteed a way out of it.

There are also many cases where rather than being required to do something impossible you're required to do something infeasible, which in practice is the same thing but then they get to point to the entire mountain of shit you'd be required to eat and suggest that you do that.


The tax code has significantly punished dual-income married couples for quite a while. It presumably started some time in the 20th century as some sexists not wanting women in the workplace and then continued because changing it to have them pay the same taxes as they would if they were unmarried would result in a significant reduction in government revenue.

Seems to me that tax breaks for marriage are to encourage family creation. If child tax credits achieve that, why should society reward dinks?

What you need is for the interfaces people use to not be vendor-locked. At which point Nvidia doesn't have to "fail" in the sense of going out of business, but rather just have the ecosystem switch to APIs that are supported by not just them but also AMD, Intel, Apple, Qualcomm, etc.

At which point customers are buying for hardware price/performance or performance/watt rather than because they care which vendor they're getting it from.

And then you'd still have the biggest companies making the highest performance hardware, but you could also get something from the RISC-V people which had e.g. half or a quarter the performance of the enterprise GPUs but the same amount of VRAM, for less money.


We will see if this comes to pass, I hope you are right. I do fear that the cutthroat nature of this market will not allow a paradigm of interchangeable elements at the lower layers, perhaps if innovation slows or stalls.

>And then you'd still have the biggest companies making the highest performance hardware, but you could also get something from the RISC-V people which had e.g. half or a quarter the performance of the enterprise GPUs but the same amount of VRAM, for less money.

I'd think we might see some sort of Open Source GPU are the low end consumer level. There are projects ongoing. This is not exactly what you are referring to but every little bit to chip away at the market and return some semblance of control to customers is welcomed.


Is that a slam dunk? Why should someone have a right to prevent you from criticizing them by using their likeness? Should a billionaire be able to sue the newspaper for a satirical editorial cartoon?

With appropriate disclosure of AI use and non monetization. But I should not be able to clone elvis' voice and make new songs and music videos for my personal financial gain, in my opinion.

> non monetization

You think the billionaire should be able to sue the newspaper for the satirical cartoon because the newspaper sells ads or has paid subscribers?

> But I should not be able to clone elvis' voice and make new songs and music videos for my personal financial gain, in my opinion.

Elvis is dead. He can't consent or not consent to anything anymore. At which point your options are "the evil corporation who makes the artist sign their rights away while they're alive gets to do it after they're dead", "anybody gets to do it after their dead" (i.e. dead people are in the public domain), or nobody can do it even if the artist wanted them to.

What you presumably want is for the artist to be able to decide for themselves while they're alive, but that consistently leads to the evil corporation making them sign the paper in order to get the recording contract. Also, what do you want to do with people who died a long time ago? The chain of title for the likeness of Caesar is going to be trouble.

At which point the "dead people are in the public domain" option doesn't really seem that bad, because screw the evil corporation and their ill-gotten monopoly on the dead.


> We need legislation banning ai from imitating/impersonating humans and creating confusion about whats real.

The obvious problem is that if there is an unambiguous way to tell that something is AI-generated then you don't need the law, and if there isn't then you can't enforce it.


The "arguing in favor of a bad law by saying they'll just look at your intent" thing is completely invalid for the DMCA because your intent is the thing they don't care about. That's why it's such an absurd law.

Suppose you commit unambiguous copyright infringement. Then they could already sue you regardless of whether there is any circumvention and anti-circumvention is completely redundant. It has no actual purpose that exceeds what you would get from presuming willful infringement if someone had to circumvent copy protection and then having different penalties for willful and unintentional infringement.

But now suppose you don't commit copyright infringement. You make a fair use copy of the work. Completely different intent. They don't care. It's crazy.

Where this gets really wild is the prohibition on circumvention tools.

Suppose the copyright expires on a work previously under copyright. Happens all the time. You now have a bunch of works with a "technological protection measure" preventing you from copying them, even though they're not copyrighted. Your intent is now to publish a tool to help everyone remove the DRM from those public domain works. But maybe the same DRM is also used on other works that are still under copyright -- and you may not even know that. So does your intent matter or not?


To clarify by intent I mean whether the intent was to circumvent or not wrt strength of technical DRM not whether the intent was to use it fairly or not; nothing to do with morals or ethics. I make no comment on whether it is right, just, or absurd.

When people say intent matters, what they generally mean is intent to do something wrong. It implies that having no malicious intent would exculpate you. Applying it exclusively to the intent to do something innocuous is... I believe the technical term is cheating.

And does the DMCA have even that as an intent requirement? Suppose you tell your local AI to copy something without even knowing that it has any DRM, and it does. Is that still a violation? Obvious loophole if it isn't, but intent requirement 100% fully absent if it is.


> Simply banning things causes the price to go up. That alone is good enough to motivate the policy decision.

No twice.

First, banning them doesn't necessarily even make the price go up. If all you have to do to get the product is put someone else's name on the form, that raises the price by a number that rounds to zero. It probably costs your own companies more in bureaucracy and paperwork to try to enforce the pointless rules than it costs the other one to put a different name on the form.

Second, suppose it actually worked somehow. What happens then? The other country pays the higher price temporarily while throwing out some big government subsidies to develop a domestic version of the technology. Soon your own companies have a new foreign competitor in the world market which is receiving large government subsidies.

Export controls are a failed policy.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: