HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | 762236's commentslogin

Sounds like a reasonable explanation. I've never wanted to deal with running an open-source community (I'm way too introverted and focused on coding, not chatting), but now that AI is here, I will be releasing something awesome. I don't know how I'm going to deal with the community though. Possibly it will be so awesome that others create the community in my absence, and that solves the problem.


This is silly. I bought my Model Y specifically because its safety is so high. You can see it in (1) the crash rate numbers when using FSD, (2) the crash-test ratings are fantastic, and (3) impossible situations where people survived such as plummeting off a cliff on route 1.


but how well will the people in the other car fare if you crash into them? with the Cybertruck especially, its sharp edges make it seem like a set of knives on four wheels. the pommel is just facing the driver rather than the pedestrian or other vehicle.


International law is primarily a set of treaties between sovereigns. The point of being sovereign is that you can unilaterally leave a treaty. There are consequences to doing that for those that are weaker, of course.


I can't decipher what you refer to with 'your'.


It sounds like you're justifying Iranian war crimes. Retaliatory strikes against American military targets aren't war crimes.


Those of us that believe in preserving civil liberties argue that we should take away powers of the government so it is harder to bully people under the color of law --- the process is the punishment. I'm not sure why the left only cares about this topic now, and not when the left was in power. The Left had a lot of opportunities to take away government powers before Trump entered office.


> we should take away powers of the government so it is harder to bully people under the color of law

This coincidentally makes it much easier for private parties to get away with illegal discrimination


Because "The Left" is not some unified body as you're making it out to be. Rather it consists of professional politicians who lean authoritarian, and the grassroots who lean libertarian. And the same basic dynamic exists on "The Right" as well. It is the professional authoritarians' main job to sell their respective grassroots tribes on justifications for the authoritarian actions of their administrations. Currently, it is "The Right" who is cheering on the authoritarianism (and quite voraciously!), so anybody earnestly interested in preserving civil liberties should be opposing "The Right". When the buntings change, "The Left" gets the power back, and is back to being the marketers for authoritarianism, then it will then become necessary to oppose "The Left".

But of course to actually make any positive progress for civil liberties, it is necessary for the grassroots to hold their own politicians accountable rather than merely cheering when it is their team's at bat. Meaning it is currently the responsibility of the grassroots right to be calling out these flagrant abuses of power. They were easily easily recognizing when it was being done to them, but now they mostly seem silent. Which is the same condemnation as your comment makes, but applied to the tribe who can actually act act the moment.


Trump is doing plenty of stuff that he has absolutely no legal authority to do, so I’m not sure why you think the law is some sort of roadblock.


Do not forget that world leaders are heads of sovereign states that are in charge of their self defense. Those that actually have to defend themselves, like the US, rather than relying on strong allies, need to make public statements that are not hypocritical about what they would do for self defense. This is why both U.S. administrations support Israel's actions


Pretty sure that's not why US administrations support Israel's actions.


Bad phrasing on my part. That is one of many reasons


  need to make public statements that are not hypocritical
wow, you hold a very high opinion of american politics. you must have been reading new from paper news paper for the last 30 years


> Those that actually have to defend themselves, like the US, rather than relying on strong allies

Sure, but are we going to ignore about the US having to rely on its "helpless" allies to provide staging points and cannon fodder for its illegal imperialistic wars? How much of a superpower would it be without its overseas bases?


Sure, the need to self defense against US dangerous neighbors. Looking at you, Canada!


Have you been living under a rock? The time when "public statements" used to work is long, long gone.


Why don't people explain their acronyms? What is a Rust LSP?


People communicate with regards to the audience they expect.

This is why Rust (it’s a systems programming language) and LSP (the language server protocol invented by VS Code) are not explained in the article.

I am hoping I don’t have to define the words I used, but if in doubt, Google or ChatGPT are your friends.


It makes sense to always explain acronyms. I always do to avoid random people reaching out for more explanations


> It makes sense to always explain acronyms.

It does up until a point. Would you say the same about "AI"? What about "LLM"?

On HN (Hacker News), I expect that most would find a definition for AI or LLM to be redundant today. LSP is borderline in my opinion, especially when the context of Rust is already given.


Language Server Protocol, it's what your IDE (like VSCode or other) uses to do linting, syntax checking, and "go to reference" stuff.


LSP is a well known term among programmers these days.


Not if an LLM writes your code. I get thousands of lines of high quality Rust per day without ever stepping into VScode.


Then why not just ask the LLM to explain what LSP stands for?


what's an "LLM"? ;3


How do you know it's high quality?


I made myself an expert at Rust before I started using LLM's, and I review the code.


You made yourself an expert in Rust and have never heard of an LSP?

This seems surprising to me given that Rust was one of the first languages to broadly advertise a toolchain and editor integrations which rely on the technology.


I just put VScode in vim mode and rely on its basic symbol completion. My goal has always been to write as little as possible by thinking out the minimum solution. The simpler the code, the easier it is to reason about and to maintain.


Props to you. I've been writing Rust for around 7 years now and I couldn't QA 1000s of lines per day.


We sample it, and upon finding problems, adjust the system to eliminate that class of problems in the future.


Did you just create a new account so you could keep arguing with people?


Yes. HN is groupthink central, and enforces it through down votes, which marks the account as low quality, which then turns off commenting for that account. It is a classic negative feedback loop that enforces the groupthink. You can tell how many accounts I've created by the account number.


... Right.


> Not if an LLM writes your code. I get thousands of lines of high quality Rust per day without ever stepping into VScode.

LSPs are orthogonal to both LLMs and VSCode. For example, see Metals[0].

0 - https://metals-lsp.org/


So you're not a programmer, and therefore aren't part of the audience for a programming tool.


Very little quality, let alone high-quality, code is written in VSCode.


This is an astonishing assertion. Can you back that up with evidence?


No


You've got to re-evaluate... something if you genuinely believe that. Pretty much the same level of sanity as "very few good films use CGI".


I'd go as far as ask "what is your IDE of choice?" during the interview and rejected candidates that answer VSCode and VSCode clones. Now it doesn't matter because of LLMs though.



Why don't people use Google for such incredibly simple questions instead of asking the comment section?


It wasn't a request for information, since you can obviously look it up. It was a critique on people's inability to imagine their audience, particularly once it scales.


I'm not understanding the issue here, as everyone has different expectations for prose. No matter which LLM I use, I will provide a skill to generate high-quality prose. It is the first thing I add to my repo that I'm working on.


This mentality is exactly why the US is doing this. You've already condemned people without access to any good evidence. Besides, US defense requires the ability to do everything Israel did against Gaza.


> You've already condemned people without access to any good evidence.

And the live-streamed genocide that the world has watched over the past 3 years doesn't qualify as evidence? That's odd because I could have sworn the United Nations, The International Association of Genocide Scholars, B'Tselem, Physicians for Human Rights Israel, and Human Rights Watch had all labeled Israel's actions against Palestinians as genocide.

America's evidence against that? Israel says so.

> US defense requires the ability to do everything Israel did against Gaza

Since when does defence require killing innocent women and children indiscriminately? At what point does that sort of defence reach a level of inhumanity that you're willing to concede that it's genocidal?

As a Jewish man following true Jewish morals, I will stand by the statements of these international bodies that find Israel and its leaders guilty of committing genocide. Never again cannot mean only for jews; it can only be morally just when applied to everyone.


This is exactly what I mean: you take what the news reports as evidence, when the news is hearsay. Courts don't run off of hearsay. I know quite a bit of what actually happened, and it doesn't match what you're saying. You've bypassed epistemology and gone to condemnation.


What are you trying to say? Are you implying there is no good evidence that Netenyahu is committing war crimes in Gaza? Whether or not their actions are justified, war crimes are not.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: