HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | 650's commentslogin

What’s stopping more electricity being generated in the US? It’s both financial and political, but private business could step up here?

Permitting reform is currently working its way through congress, for what it's worth.

It's federal permitting, local "NIMBY" veto control over everything, state environmental laws, tariffs on solar equipment, and out of control costs on infrastructure in the US (a combination of corruption, overpowered unions, and regulations).

Like many problems in the US, the causes are many and diffused across different layers of government, different departments, making it very difficult to solve.


regulatory capture by coal and gas companies

They're literally paying wind farm companies billions to go away - https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/trump-rwe-wind-farms/

my thoughts:

- bullshit jobs is a thing and many of these positions were make work anyways

- yes philosophically and economically, who will buy X product if all employees are laid off is a thing

- some of these will be rehired, some will be layed off if the voluntary buyout percentage is not large enough

- opinion: Microsoft as a company is a has been dinosaur, soon to be IBM, its (engineer) salaries were on the lower end and were very PM (Program Manager) heavy

- there is a lot of entrenched bureaucracy and top down mandates at this company.

- i personally use Macbooks/MacOS over Surface/XP, Google Docs over Word, GMail over Outlook, Slack over Teams, Firefox over Edge, etc. their user facing products are severely lacking in user experience.

- from my time in the tech industry/friends I understand their bureaucracy existing for the needs of the bureaucracy. their c-suite/leadership is a bunch of world salad morons


That bureaucracy is there for a reason, you often need bureaucracy to serve bureaucracy. About 85% of Microsoft's revenue comes from B2B/Enterprise/Governments. From their latest fiscal year report [1], the top 4 revenue groups were:

Server products & cloud services (39% of revenue) M365 Commercial products & cloud services, excludes Consumer (30.7%) Xbox / Gaming (6.6%) LinkedIn (6%)

[1] https://app.edgar.tools/companies/MSFT/disclosures/segments


what about the kind of bureaucracy where it takes 10 people to do what 2 could get done in 30-40 hours of week? the kind where one engineer is digging the hole while the scrum master, project manager, program manager, swe manager, director, HR, business analyst look on?


That’s exactly the type of work you have to do to get government contracts. Think about a 200 page PDF which requires you to restate several dozen times what measures you have in place to make sure that the government customer won’t get hacked. For each question you have to go find some product requirements somewhere and find the place where it says “procedure for security audit.” Many of those people “looking on” are partly there to check boxes for enterprise or government contract purposes.

I’m not claiming this is the most efficient way to get any kind of code written. But if you want to have one hacker sit down and ship the whole product in a couple weeks without any of these business dorks disturbing them, well, that’s exactly what brand-new startups are for.


>About 85% of Microsoft's revenue comes from B2B/Enterprise/Governments.

This is why I don't use their products anymore, they aren't made for me.

>LinkedIn (6%)

Wow. I would never have guessed it was that high.


Plenty of tech companies hired a lot during the pandemic. Even with these layoffs they will still have a higher employee count that before.

https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/MSFT/microsoft/num...


> bullshit jobs is a thing and many of these positions were make work anyways

Wouldn't those people choose to stay? Buyouts are much more attractive if you can easily get a new job.


i think they most likely will choose to stay yes, i'm just saying from the perspective of an outsider looking in, many of the jobs at microsoft were not needed.


The intro is great and has been making the rounds online:

“ In the past year American markets have digested the largest-ever initial public offering (SpaceX), equity raise by a public company (Google) or a foreign firm (sk Hynix), private-funding round (Openai) and private-debt deal (Broadcom), as well as most of the biggest bond issue in history (Amazon). There was the first $1trn exchange-traded fund, or etf (Vanguard), a record-breaking cash pile (Berkshire Hathaway) and stock-buyback programme (Nvidia), and the consummation of the largest-ever leveraged buyout (Electronic Arts). Then there are the enormous mergers in railways (Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern), utilities (NextEra and Dominion Energy) and media (Paramount and Warner Bros Discovery)—the last of which led, this week, to the largest ever junk-bond offering, beating a record set only last week (SoftBank). New markets have been created out of thin air (for compute) or become much bigger (for predictions). Worries about massive corporate scandals (First Brands) and hedge-fund blow-ups (Situational Awareness), which would have once occupied investors’ attention for months, are steamrollered by the relentless, totalising and extraordinarily flexible machine that is American finance.”


Out of curiosity did you do text transcription of a screencap to write this quote


Why do you ask that question when the text is selectable?


I would imagine because there are small differences "sk" vs "SK", "OpenAI" vs "Openai"


This makes us sound awesome.


Reminds me of some degen crypto stuff a few years ago, but now for the whole economy. Amazing


That's one word you could use, I guess


Or reckless.


I feel my job as an engineer is pretty safe, lots of domain knowledge required. Very confident no business type anywhere in the chain above me would be able to do the work I do in a month in even a year with the help of AI. Do we need 3 engineers now instead of 5 for the same output? Sure, can we replace a team of 5 junior, senior, staff with 1 staff - no unless all you do is maintenance. Business types are reaching.


You don't have to actually be replaceable for a very clever mba to get a very stupid idea.

You end up laid off either way.


Why do you think the models are ineffective at being trained on your expertise?


Google is entrenched with career opportunists who are self serving, and are, excuse the lack of a better word, shitting out work to move stupid KPIs and continue the bureaucracy. A bloated Product org that advocates that something must be done, and is not focused.


The first sentence is quite telling

>We’ve got amazing talent, world-class compute and products…

Products are third on the list. Google is an incubator for talent first and foremost. Products are an afterthought


My opinion is that you're reading way too much into this. Talent is obviously first. Without that you have no products worth speaking of.


Hasn't that always been the case with Google? Outside of a few that are mostly good and have stuck around, I've always seen Google has having great tech but being quite bad and making products out of it.


I was about to invest in Google, but your compelling observation has swayed me. Now it's obvious to me they are a dying company.


Guess I'm not taking out a second mortgage on my house anymore to invest in $GOOG.


If these products are the place that talent has brought us, of what use was the talent?


It just tells you about their intended audience: Investors rather than consumers.

Nowadays, every company—even huge ones—prefers to be seen as a "growth opportunity", so they are trying to play up their ability to create new products which will somehow be so incredible that the line keeps moving up forever.

That said, there is definitely a correlation between companies chasing new products and leaving old ones to become crap.


I'd bet my mortgage that if the first sentence was "We've got amazing products, amazing talent, and world-class compute", you'd be in the comments complaining that they didn't put talent first.


A company is made up of people, and makes products. Products can come and go for many reasons (or any reason) but the company will always have people.


So then it is similarly telling that compute is second on the list? They have more talent than compute? Layoffs incoming?


This is also how Y Combinator operates.

Founders are first. Ideas are second.


Google's revenue is 10x up in the last 10 years.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asha_Sharma

Bachelor of Science in Management from University of Minnesota

Marketing role at Microsoft 2011-2013 out of college, standard average college grad role.

---

There are thousands of more intelligent, harder working, better credentialed, better achieving college grads alone at this point.

---

COO of Porch ~2013-2017 - how does one go from a standard marketing role to COO, ok whatever maybe its a smol startup

"After departing Porch, she joined Facebook as VP Product & Engineering for their Messenger and Instagram Direct products."

lmfao - more credence to the fact that most "Product" roles are leeches. VP Product and Engineering at Meta is absolutely crazy at this point in anyones career.

Management Degree -> Marketing Role -> COO of startup (lolwut) -> VP Product/Eng at Meta (cough nepotism? cough)

---

COO of Instacart in 2021 LMAO

President of Core AI at Microsoft in February 2024 LMAO

insert "i have no technical ability whatsoever"


Reading on tea leaves has more credibility and substance than your “analysis”.


Please provide a rebuttal. 4 years from a marketing role they were in out of college at Microsoft to VP Product and Engineering at Meta?


No. You made claims, it’s your job to provide evidence. And you already contradict yourself - per your message she was 2 years at ms, and then 4 years at startup.

Honestly, I hate defending multimillionaire and get that to climb that fast at those companies anybody needs to be, most likely, ruthless corporate warrior. But you just throw claims and sound like a baseless hater.


Both the fact she spent 2 years at MS as a Marketing employee out of college and 4 years after she left MS she was VP at Facebook are true simultaneously, check the Wikipedia link I sourced.


Agree. My mistake on that part, misread your message.


Ponzi scheme stock market is also relevant here. Productivity will max out if RSI AGI doesn't pan out.


His apology seemed AI generated as well


Product managers at Google have a strangehold on their bad releases. It's become a whole thing for engineers to have to please their XFN (cross functional) partners in product and UX for review cycles and promos.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: