HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | 20k's commentslogin

This is why I feel like any AI usage is making us all crabs in a bucket when it comes to progressing as a society. Any genuine creativity or effort is immediately stolen and repackaged as someone else's, which inherently means that its incredibly difficult for the original author to get any credit and devalues any genuine progress. And most importantly, people are doing this to deny the author any profit

We seem to be in a situation where 0.1% of people are creating anything new in the programming space, which isn't a change at all, but the difference now is that there's an absolute army of people waiting in the wings for the second they finish to take credit - and profit off their work without compensation. Because apparently that's progress, according to some people

This has been happening the most in realtime with news sites, where any news they publish is fed into chatgpt and recycled to avoid giving them any clicks or advertising money. What happens when all the news sites die because chatgpt ate their ability to survive? We'll go backwards as a society because we won't have news, and then suddenly chatgpt will lose its ability to report the news. Lose lose, unless you're an extreme short termist

It extends to everything with AI, its giving us negative progress as a society, because its society eating itself in exchange for the shortest time line go up


>Any genuine creativity or effort is immediately stolen and repackaged

So pretty much how things have worked almost all the time. For example after the US violently branched off from the UK we stole every idea we could. China operates the same way. Copy and make cheaper.

>Because apparently that's progress, according to some people

According to the people in power keeping information locked up for entire lifetimes is a good idea. They love that kind of progress to stay rich forever.


AI has industrialised and automated plagiarism in a way that we've never seen before, its 3 orders of magnitude worse. These AI companies stole literally everything on the planet

What we had previously wasn't ideal, but it was nowhere near as bad


And the AI models get stolen and distilled.

At the end of the day imaginary property is just that.


Yeah sure but now cat is out of the bag and we are in a prisoners dilemma where this inevitable. You can personally not use AI and get your shit stolen in milliseconds either way

I'd rather genuinely create something than steal other people's work

What does genuinely create something mean? Is it creating if you are inspired by anything? Is it creating if you have any prior information on the topic? Is it creating if you rewrite or build upon something existing? If it creating if you take a little part of something existing and copy it I to your creation? Is it creating if you take something, but reference the author? Is it creating if you are building something with an autocomplete/line completion/statistical model? Is it creating if you have an agent that searches the internet and helps you find the little snippets or material that might help you? It is creating if your idea needs you to use an AI to make a baseline in a certain "style"?

> because we won't have news

The masses will have "news" generated by LLMs and the rich will have their private information gathering that delivers actual facts. Finally we can keep the masses dumb and uninformed again, unable to mess up anyone's plans and operations. They will be kept busy fighting among each other.

Those with fuck-you money think they can afford and survive the destruction of society. I suspect we will find out ourselves how long that holds true.


This is a turtle drawing right?

I had the same idea, but due to UDLR being used and also LR having values larger than 2 it already means that the turtle is likely not orientation-aware and instead moves in cardinal directions.

The F flag for some commands could indicate to start/stop drawing.

There is also a singular 0 command which could indicate return to the origin.

This makes a lot of sense but everything I tried plotting looks pretty random.

There is also almost no closed loops (such that F could mean "flood-fill this polygon"). If it just means "fill this pixel" you just get 7 pretty random pixels.

If you assume an infinite canvas, no lines are drawn left to the origin, but the lines go above and below the origin. One could assume a fixed grid with the origin in a corner and wrapping on top/bottom but I also did not find anything there when trying multiple layouts. Using a fixed square size and wrapping horizontally and vertically also seem to create uninteresting pictures no matter which corner you start in.

It also doesn't seem to yield datamatrix or similar codes, so that's also not it.


I suspect the gap comes from whether or not you're being used for marketing/IPO bubble driving. I love Fil-C, and its still a small enough project that it doesn't make front page news if a problem with it is discovered. So I think the gap comes in in that they have no incentive to massively drum up the number of security vulnerabilities that they find, by publishing a huge number of false positives that then get quietly retracted

By contrast, when announces they've found XXXX vulnerabilities in Linux, it makes the news literally everywhere. Even if 0% of them turn out to be real, it doesn't matter - they've already gotten what they want out of it which is the round of coverage about how incredible is and its the end of the world


I think unfortunately companies are going to have to learn the extremely hard way what happens when your engineers no longer understand any of your code. The drive to eliminate institutional knowledge to create a perfectly replaceable worker was always dumb at best, and just leads to car crshes

Its incredibly depressing that LLMs have made so many facets of life strictly worse. Everything is absolutely inundated with slop

I'm mildly hopeful that when text watermarking comes in, we'll be able to automatically filter out all the LLM crap that gets generated currently. It feels like we're in the very early days of email becoming a tool used for mass spam, while we figure out exactly how to deal with that


watermarking will only work if it's embedded in the model (i.e. frontier/paid offerings). The rate at which open-source/open-weight models are advancing I think watermarks are probably only a temporary solution right? Fragmentation of the models available, or having more models that don't contain watermarks available will probably make this technique useless in the future I would think?

Watermarks have been working reasonably for images even though open models are absolutely competitive with commercial ones, and I guess the reason turned out to be that if someone's going to put in no effort, they're really going to put in no effort.

Relying on in person relationships and communication are vastly better if digital channels get saturated with noise.

But cultivating those takes so much time and is geographically limited. The quality is also less, as the pool of people is so much smaller. But I admit, in-person is more rewarding (for me personally, in the longer term).

I'm debating living in a van to have continued geographic flexibility in choosing social interactions of quality.

But there has to be a better way, right?

As for now, I cling dearly to the friends I have. But it's... worrying


Most human personal assistants don't have access to vast swathes of private data that they collected without permission, unless your house is the site of multiple watergates

This is just repeating a common meme. Blender's UI layout and organisation is fine, but this is a UI library. There's nothing wrong with blender's UI technically, in fact its pretty decent overall

> Blender's UI layout and organisation is fine

I absolutely detest it (TBF I haven't used it for the past ~2 years) but I also recognize that it's an incredibly difficult problem space that lacks an obviously good solution, the tool itself is inherently and irreducibly complex, it's a free project with extremely limited resources, it's been consistently improving over time, etc, etc.


Everybody hates all serious 3d application interfaces… they’re just complicated. I’m professionally competent in Houdini, Maya, Max, Blender, Zbrush, Marvelous Designer, the UE editor… they all suck in various ways but it’s all a giant set of trade-offs and priorities. Beyond that, lots of these programs have lineages that go back decades longer than almost any modern dev environment and being so complex, UI changes can be quite disruptive. Kind of like why so many *nix cli tools are the same as they were decades ago. A lot of (no, not all) developers think they have the most complex tooling in the computer world — they definitely don’t.

Its astonishing that anyone thinks that these companies even respect the checkbox. These are some of the objectively scummiest companies on earth that have violated nearly ever copyright law we have


People hate AI because culture is being turned into slop in front of our very eyes. There's clear evidence that people collectively reject:

1. AI games

2. AI Art

3. AI Music

4. AI literature in most forms, except for factual text like search

Or at least, they won't pay money for it

AI hatred isn't being pushed by people with a narrative. I can't use AI for my game, because it'll sell £0 if I do. That's the net result of millions of other people telling me that they despise AI and won't purchase my product if it contains any AI, and I'm just making a business decision

Also google and some other big tech companies were widely loved for a while. Microsoft/gates managed to entirely rehabilitate their image at one point, and google was seen as one of the good guys. Those days died with the cambridge analytica scandal, and there's no evidence its coming back


And why do those millions of other people have that opinion? Have they arrived at it of their own accord?

Yes, you can create garbage with AI tools. You can create garbage using Blender, Unreal Engine, Unity, GIMP, Ableton, iMovie and Word as well and there are mountains of garbage created with those tools that nobody pays for or likes. If you have some talent and put the same effort into creating art with AI that you do with a digital paint program then it won't be garbage. AI isn't a magic wand that you can wave around and get perfect results, it can save you time just like using an image editor saves you a lot of time compared to drawing and painting by hand but it won't do all of the work for you. It's a tool and a poor craftsman that blames his tools for his failure.

My point exactly that big tech was loved for a while and then hated and then loved again and hated again. Have they truly changed that much that often or is it your perception that has changed?


> Yes, you can create garbage with AI tools. You can create garbage using Blender, Unreal Engine, Unity, GIMP, Ableton, iMovie and Word

Do you not see any difference between creating garbage in these ways?

People have created low-quality things since the dawn of humanity, using all sorts of tools, professional and not. However, before AI, making most types of garbage still required some human work, it wasn't infinitely scalable. And what was automatable ended up being so horrible that most people could easily dismiss it on the spot, or for them to even be filtered out algorithmically. On the internet, it wasn't perfect, but the signal-to-noise ratio was still at a level where you reliably discern the signal part.

AI changed this. Even a beginner can set one up to run almost fully unattended - and while what comes out won't be good, it also won't be immediately apparent as such, especially to the general public. More and more I find myself being fooled by a website link, a YouTube video thumbnail or a paragraph in an article. AI lets people create garbage that can impersonate real effort decently well, and they've used that to great extents. As we speak, thousands of agents are working day and night to pump every online platform with their 'content', without a single person in the world to care about what they put out. They're taking over and removing any good signal we had, everything becomes diluted with trash on a scale we have never seen. People notice that. Many are clueless about AI, and social influence plays a role, but they're not being misled and have their opinions manipulated. They wouldn't enjoy most of this content regardless.

In addition to the dilution of good information, they care about appearances and how AI lets you create an appearance of caring about something. The cheap food stand seemed honest when they put up an unassuming print of a simple Word document, and now seems dishonest when they put up an AI-generated mess that looks nothing like the real product and desperately tries to seem more refined than they are. Their manager was at least honest when he replied with a lazy 'k', and now he's lying about caring by dumping out a bullet point list of AI-generated text for a response that we know he himself hasn't read. It's the dream product for scammers, grifters and people who simply don't care.

Can you use AI to help create something good? Sure, but anyone doing that still needs to take their time and put care into it. Even if AI makes them faster, by the time they finish, 10TB of more slop has already been produced to drown them out, because that can be fully automated. Effectively 99.9% of AI content ends up being garbage, so of course people are going to reject it. Most probably don't want the few nuggets of gold for the ocean of waste.


People hate these outputs, as well as the wholesale enclosure of their commons (training on public data ignoring their copyrights and the social contracts that enabled them). Additionally, despite how it might appeal to a subset of humanity, "we're going to take all of the jobs" is not a fantastic sales pitch.


How can the output both be so much worse than what a human could produce while simultaneously taking all the jobs and displacing the human made data it was trained on?

If everyone hates AI output and refuses to buy anything made with it then in what way is it a threat to people who don't use AI in their work?

Are these talking points perhaps crafted to benefit a small group of people who will lose the edge they currently have to a larger number of people enabled by these new tools?


Not really an accurate view, and the conspiracy angle isn't helping.

The output could be fine in itself, except people (arbitrarily, some could say) value the human production. Displacement is simply a matter of volume: the sleepless machine can churn indefinitely while people can not. The thing is too, most outputs being mass produced are of a substantially lower quality than people (and what is possible).

A problem is people are being tricked into it, or being given little choice. If 90% of companies use AI (as in, mandated from leadership), what "choice" is there? If people recognize the 10% remaining and do business with them exclusively, economics will take over and force either price hikes or the 10% to grow. It's playing chicken.

Based on what the trends seem to be, people will unknowingly keep taking in products with AI (mostly out of not understanding the choice).

As for the enclosure point which is important: People make things for their enjoyment. When people try to profit off their work, they rightfully get put off. The deal is "if you can view this for free, it isn't meant to be sold. If it is sold, I deserve to have my time compensated". AI training/scraping has violated this agreement, and funnels the money to a third party to the people who made the valuable originating art. If it was not valuable, then why not train AI on its own output? Since that appears to be a "problem", there must be something about what humans create that has value AI cannot produce itself.

>Are these talking points perhaps crafted to benefit a small group of people who will lose the edge they currently have to a larger number of people enabled by these new tools?

That flavour of conspiratorial thinking is one of the reasons for polarization. Sometimes, people prefer the human touch. This applies mostly to art and other topics lumped into "the Humanities".

Hope that clears things up for you, or at least sheds light on why people might not see things in the way you do.


> people (arbitrarily, some could say) value the human production

This is a different argument, going into it would muddy the waters. It would devolve into a debate about how much and what type of input and individual perception. It's also been rehashed a million times since Duchamp thought to put a mass produced urinal on display as a fountain.

> most outputs being mass produced are of a substantially lower quality than people (and what is possible)

Different purposes and mass production does not eliminate the market for artisanal work, it replaces only the limited batch work done by hand previously.

> A problem is people are being tricked into it...

God help anyone who learns how the sausage is made.

> "if you can view this for free, it isn't meant to be sold. If it is sold, I deserve to have my time compensated"

This is mostly a matter for the courts but as long as the works are not being reproduced in whole unattributed or in violation of whatever license they held then it will mostly be allowed. If you look for it, you'll notice that artists "borrow" from each other constantly with no attribution and no payment to the originator. All but the grossest plagiarism goes entirely unpunished because everyone realizes that no one can stand alone. Is it different now that it is being made available as a service? Yes, there are now more legal ramifications due to an audit trail of scraping and purchases combined with the much larger output that can be measured and compared. Does it destroy the commons? No, people will use the outputs in their own work which will be published and become part of the commons just like any new style or media.

> that appears to be a "problem"

It's a solved problem. Synthetic training data is a valuable addition now. It requires a way to validate or rank it but that's not any worse than cleaning and filtering human data.

> conspiratorial thinking

An excellent smokescreen but we've been living in a soup of mass media propaganda for over a hundred years now so there's no denying that influence campaigns exist. Denying that humans act in coordinated ways to influence the opinion of others is absurd when you can get a degree in it, have it as a job title and build a trillion dollar industry on it.


>This is a different argument, going into it would muddy the waters. It would devolve into a debate about how much and what type of input and individual perception. It's also been rehashed a million times since Duchamp thought to put a mass produced urinal on display as a fountain.

On the contrary, it demonstrates an unwillingness to grapple with inconvenient problems, as does the rest of your reply.

>'s a solved problem. Synthetic training data is a valuable addition now. It requires a way to validate or rank it but that's not any worse than cleaning and filtering human data.

Untrue for artistic outputs oddly enough.

>build a trillion dollar industry on it.

Or selectively quote in the comment section to dullen the need to address issues.


You've got under 5 minutes to decide whether or not a widely reported critical security vulnerability actively being exploited in the while is severe enough to warrant taking down your site or not. The downside for taking down your site is approximately 0, and the upside is that you don't get shrekd

No security expert can or should work that fast. Its a completely reasonable thing to do given the hyperbolic reporting just in case it turns out to be true. Some websites being down for a few hours doesn't end the world


> The downside for taking down your site is approximately 0

> Some websites being down for a few hours doesn't end the world

Many governmental websites are still down and they say might stay down for days or weeks. Some are not directly related to PHP, but auth doesn't work due to firewall hardening or similar. There definitely is a non-zero downside.


Agreed. This is all lazy chair hindsight talk, maybe by those not affected by it. In the moment you act on the imperfect information you have available and you use the safe than sorry rule. And to demand perfect information is also a fallacy, it doesn’t exist until after the fact.


I hear you, but also I'm not so sure. I remember Log4j, heartbleed, etc. and they were just as serious, but I don't recall people just going dark immediately. Scripts to validate whether or not you had exposure were built, people ran them, and if you did have exposure you started checking to see whether or not it was exploited. This timeline for this seems wildly different to me.


Because it’s not the same type. There was no actual info until the patch dropped, with some people in the know , which made it dangerous to leave your site up. The stopgaps were wild guesses. The multi-upload mitigation wouldn’t have worked.

There was no check that could be trusted to be the check to mitigate it. So that left the scenario that we went through.


Presumably the lack of sober risk assessment was on the part of the hyperbolic reporters.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: