Indeed, Linus Torvalds is infamous for not caring what he ships (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50111350). That's why he's never been known to go on, let's say impassioned tirades against people who submit bad patches to the linux kernel. After all, it's not like he's ever apologized for inflammatory behavior before (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18000698).
On a more serious note, it's not a dichotomy that one either uses AI to code or they care about what they ship. Some people use AI to code and care what they ship.
Point 1 is dependent on the individual and often not the case. Especially in cases where the part that takes effort is figuring out the poorly documented syntax/api you’re stuck with for the task (extra fun with new components iterating rapidly and pinning the next version requires new scaffolding), you can read the invocation and the accompanying couple of lines of test code way faster than you’d mould them yourself. Which also translates neatly to point 2 (how efficiently can you in many cases ascertain the outcome of smearing the chosen bits on the cpu with easily digestible tests).
Also the emotionally laden appeal to "responsibility" is weak, as it glosses over the many cases where overspending resources on creating the thing would be the irresponsible choice.
> Point 1 is dependent on the individual and often not the case.
Not really. To properly understand code you must have a mental model of what it is doing. You need that model whether you are reading or writing the code. It is easier to build that model while writing the code than while simply reading it. To build the model while reading the code requires having the same understanding of the problem and the same approach already in mind, which is almost never the case for any moderately complex problem.
> Especially in cases where the part that takes effort is figuring out the poorly documented syntax/api you’re stuck with for the task
Reading LLM generated code does not avoid this, and in fact it is often worse since LLM comments are terrible at getting to the point.
> Some people use AI to code and care what they ship.
The vast, vast majority of people using LLMs to build software don't care at all about quality. I'll grant you Torvalds, but he's very much not the norm (and he's wrong: by the time you review the code the model wrote, you spent as much time reviewing it as you would've writing it, so no time was saved).
Believe it or not, some people actually know how to write code, and understand what it fucking does too!
I will never understand software dev's obsession with LLM generated slop. Compare it with the response from the likes of professional authors, artists.
I've said it before I'll say it again: a computer generating shit en masse for you is great if you don't know how to do it yourself, and don't care what the result is.
reply