HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

Why should it apply to anyone that leaves? You haven’t justified that assertion.

If the intent is specifically to have a TLD for citizens and entities within the government’s scope, why should anyone outside that scope get to keep a domain? That is directly contradictory to the intent.

Governmental TLD’s are not supposed to be vanity domains that anyone can grab. That’s not the point.

help



How much justification do you want for an opinion?

And having one person be in the right location is hardly a strong binding to anything. It's a basic generic TLD. It's okay if 0.1% 'leak'.


Fair. You are entitled to your opinion, though it seems like you don’t have much to support it.

> having one person be in the right location

This is a strawman. I bet thousands at minimum of EU domains were registered in the UK.


You got that line backwards. I'm saying that a group/company that wants an EU domain only needs one person in the EU. The standards are very low, not something that gains a benefit from strict enforcement.

Yes, I did misunderstand what you meant there.

I don’t know what the EU officially requires.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: