HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

No one is celebrating and using LLMs isn't necessarily a waste of energy. Where I live isn't relevant, LLMs use the same amount of power regardless of where their users are. You also know nothing about how I use electricity in my home, how I monitor my overall energy use and carbon output, and how I offset it.


> You also know nothing about how I use electricity in my home

I don't

> Where I live isn't relevant,

But where you live does matter. Average monthly household energy usage in the EU is 200-400 kWh. In the US it's more like 800-900kWh. So what you consider "normal energy usage" may vary considerably by where you live.

At 200-400kWh total usage, 30kwh starts to look a lot more significant. So you should at least consider the possibility that it's not that energy usage from AI is insignificant, but that your existing energy usage is wasteful.


You're American and the same 2.3% of energy you use would probably represents 5-10% of what the average Japanese person uses, and likely 15-20% of what the average Indian or Ethiopian uses.

My point isn't to attack you personally (I'd rather attack your country's disastrous energy policies) but to point out that LLMs will constitute a huge increase in our energy consumption at a time where we haven't transitioned to renewable energy and we're probably 20-30 away from it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: