HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

“Can’t”


What is the point this comment is trying to make? We can say this for every SaaS company on the planet.


Correct, "can't". Are you suggesting they secretly violate the contract and use the data anyway?



After PRISM and Room 641A, anything is possible.


Remind me in 10 years when the story breaks.


Hey ChatGPT, set a reminder for 2036 to tell me whether Google was found not to secretly violate TOS of School Chromebooks and use the data harvested from them to create value for it's shareholders.


Yes


they do not. I don't work there anymore and don't have any particular goodwill towards the employer that laid me off last year but I can guarantee that any data related to the education sector is under extremely strict controls.


Would anyone be shocked if they did? Tech firms seem to be immune from the law.


Legally they cannot, no. And sure, they could violate contracts and break data protection laws. But they’d be trading an enormous hit on their reputation, who knows how many hundreds of millions in educational contracts for, what, some basic demographic data on kids? Data they’ll almost certainly be able to get via other means once the kid becomes an adult?

I don’t like Google’s involvement in education. I don’t like Google much at all. But we should still be able to examine this stuff rationally without devolving into conspiracy theories that don’t make logical sense.


"reputation"


Honestly reputation isn't the main concern if you're in leadership there, although it is absolutely a concern. The main concern is having to do another consent decree with either the EU or the US government. Those are a complete pain in the ass.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: