HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

Canada has a charter of rights and freedoms, but there’s a section that allows governments to override it at will so it’s effectively worthless. And nobody knows that better than Quebec.
help



In Quebec's version of this law it's legal to insult politicians and police - but only in French.

tabarnak

the sad part is I can't tell if this is true or not

Doesn't Quebec have it's own slightly different constitution than the Canada wide one? If I remember right, there's been cases where things aren't allowed per Canada Charter but are allowed per Quebec's own one.

Sure, Quebec has a different constitution than Canada, but this isn't any different than US states having their own constitutions too.

The difference is that the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms has a "notwithstanding clause" which, when invoked, allows a province to avoid having one of its laws struck down by federal courts even if it goes against some parts of the Canadian Charter (though only applies to some rights, not all).


Eh, "effectively worthless" is a stretch, you still might have to spend political capital and breed resentment when invoking it, there's a reason the notwithstanding is not invoked every time.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: