HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

That's the question the article was trying to answer.

>>> "If you don't allow firms to hire immigrant workers, they just become smaller firms," Lewis said. "They are not replaced with US workers. Instead, the output of the firm shrinks, and there are fewer total workers."

So, no, if they had no choice they just shrink their operations, it seems. The apparent conclusion is that immigration bans will just force those companies to reduce operations or shut down, instead of paying higher wages to locals.

help



In this experiment, only some firms lost access to foreign labor.

The outcome could have been different had all of them lost access due to a foreign labor ban.


Japan and now China, have used automation rather than the importation of foreign workforces. China, according to many accounts, is doing quite well compared to other world economies, Japan is not too shabby either and moreover are not suffering from increased effects of importing foreign labor --China is noticing which path is more harmonious for its people.

They could open subsidiaries in other countries instead. Corporations are multinational entities.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: