HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

> If you can answer that question then the clankers can help you write a deterministic program for that same interaction and you only spend the tokens once.

The MCP is the deterministic program.

You need to take a step back and look at the problem you're discussing. What's exactly this MCP thing? It's a protocol to allow agents and coding assistants to access tools, services, and data sources, through a standardized interface.

It's the interface for your deterministic program. That's it.



they were suggesting that you take the agent out of the run time tool usage


> they were suggesting that you take the agent out of the run time tool usage

That only applies if you are talking about a well established recurrent workflow. That's not how MCPs are used to begin with.


It's easier if you started a while back shunning all human labor (including your own) in favor of fully deterministic systems. Reality is deterministic so your company or project logically can be run off a single compiled binary with formal verification of correctness for every possible scenario.


Heisenberg begs to differ with your view of reality.


So does Gödel. Maybe it was a joke? Unclear.


A protocol is not a program.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: