HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

Whether removing copyright would lead to more "milking of same old topics" in movies. I think the answer is self-evidently yes.

This is not self-evident to me, at least as far as "milking" goes. Inspiration is not the same as milking. I specifically use the word "milking" for the sort of low-level repetitive quasi-effort that the cinemas are full of.

OTOH if someone takes, IDK, Don Quijote and rewrites it into a space opera, it might actually be genuine fun, even though the old idea was there as a foundation.



> Don Quijote and rewrites it into a space opera, it might actually be genuine fun

Don Quixote is in the public domain. Copyright isn’t holding back adaptations.


I know, but my point (I could have made it clearer) is that you cannot do the same with Geralt or Frodo Baggins.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: