HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

>His pretending to be a nerd/fan in Zhora's dressing room is too cringey to watch it's so bad

He's not pretending to be a nerd/fan. He's pretending to be a spineless small-time bureucrat doing an inspection that nervous with her.



You're probably right, but it doesn't excuse Ford's hackneyed performance.


But Harrison's Deckard isn't meant to embody that "ethics/work inspector" as a good actor would.

He is meant to portray him as a detective who is not that good with pretending to be someone else would.

Harrison might or might not be a good actor, but Deckard certainly isn't supposed to be a good one.


> Deckard certainly isn't supposed to be a good one.

Why not? He's a seasoned detective with a track record, why's it so hard to believe he picked up some tricks?


He's supposed to be a detective doing investigating work and killing robots. Not a method actor.

J.J. Gittes is also a seasoned detective, doesn't mean he would be great acting.


No, he's not. He's sushi, cold fish. He doesn't even know for sure if he's human. He can't be a good actor.

Actually, if he's a replicant made to believe he's human, he might even believe he was doing a good job, because he'd be clueless about what good acting is supposed to look like.


It’s just about the only comic relief in the film. Possibly it’s acted that way deliberately.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: