HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

This sounds like a terrible idea. Do people need license to draw a picture or write a song? Why would we restrict other creative work in this way?


People doing "mechanical engineering" in their garage don't need licenses either. I don't love the licensing idea either, but that's not a good argument.


>Why would we restrict other creative work in this way?

Because it isn't creative work. Software underpins payment processors, medical services, emergency alerts, infrastructure. In the UK not long ago a ransomware attack took the healthcare system offline and surgeries had to be postponed. in 2021 the Colonial Pipeline attack took 50% of the US East Coast's oil supply offline. The entire German train system died a few weeks ago for half a day because of a software bug.

People's entire communication is in digital services, all of their private data, the economy grinds to a halt or national security is impacted monthly now by either deliberate attacks or just bugs.


Then license healthcare systems, payment processors, etc. Not humans


you license both. When you go in for surgery your hospital is accredited and the surgeon who operates on you is licensed. I don't even understand what you're trying to argue, you're okay with being operated on by a guy they found on craigslist as long as the hospital has a license? We should bridges let bridges be built by engineers who took a few courses on Khan Academy?

Of course professionals themselves need to be licensed, how else is any company supposed to have any confidence in who they employ or any legal security?


We weren't talking about doctors, but about coders writing utility apps being a different thing than payment processors




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: