HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

I also find it unpleasant to be around people when they're high out of their minds. But the way society chooses to disincentivize a thing matters. What we presently choose is absolutely a punishment, and a cruel one. People who are addicts aren't partying anymore. They're broken inside, broken spiritually. You seek that solace because something happened and you're dealing with it alone.

On a purely human level we should all want to help someone like that. But we choose to turn a blind eye, criminalize their actions, break them further. Because it's uncomfortable right? To have to be a person and help someone else? Isn't it a lot easier to, say, throw them in jail?

I'm confused by your final statement. If you saw an employee nodding off on the job and ended up firing them, wouldn't that be job loss organically? I'm not sure how to respond to that? I don't think I'm making that argument though -- I'm saying it's possible to hold down some kinds of jobs while being a junkie. You're not running at full capacity but you can still do something -- so long as you aren't in jail.

I'll say this though: I am not against social consequences for drug addiction. You kinda need that to get clean? But it doesn't have to be criminal. It could be more like: when it's discovered you're using a drug, you're mandated to get it from the state while attending counseling, you have to check in with some state agency, etc. As opposed to: right to jail. Perhaps that's entirely too empathetic?

help





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: