HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submitlogin

"is Socialism" ... not it's not. I'm always puzzled how bad education must have been to those people putting the stamp "socialism" on everything they don't like.

Socialism is a political ideology centered (it's really at it's core!) the idea of "means of production must be in the hands of the people". In reality the "means of production" (capital, land, workforce) was in the hands of a small undemocratic elected ruling caste. But the core idea still prevails. In socialism banks were seized (capital), land was seized from the farmers and Kolchoses or LPGs (agricultural production cooperatives) were formed by force. Companies were seized and Kombinate" were formed. The underlying idea of all of this force is the "dictatorship of the proletariat", their way to tell themselves that cruelty and excessive physical and psychological force is okay, almost a must.

Right to repair has nothing to do with seizing capital, land, or pressing the workforce into mismanaged cooperatives.

Another central idea of socialism is the thinking of castes, err classes. Most notably the worker classes. That describes the situation in GB around the industrial revolution. But today? Won't fit in most countries.

Right to repair has nothing to do with working class. A professor (the "intelectual class") would also be able to repair his stuff.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: