No - a shoggoth speaking human language is not a human - it is a shoggoth whose behavior is best understood/predicted by understanding it's nature - what it is built to do, and how it is trained (predict and goal seek - RL).
To predict how a human may behave in a given situation requires understanding what humans are, including things like emotions and innate biases. We are not just predictors - evolution has made survival our singular goal, and given us these mechanisms to control our behavior in a way to achieve that.
If you think that an LLM is better modeled as a human than an LLM, then you are going to predict its behavior incorrectly.
To predict how a human may behave in a given situation requires understanding what humans are, including things like emotions and innate biases. We are not just predictors - evolution has made survival our singular goal, and given us these mechanisms to control our behavior in a way to achieve that.
If you think that an LLM is better modeled as a human than an LLM, then you are going to predict its behavior incorrectly.